The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Cars in the United States
For nearly a century, Autocar has been the unwavering benchmark for automotive evaluation, meticulously dissecting vehicles with a discerning eye. Our legacy, stretching back to 1928 with the inaugural road test of the then-ubiquitous Austin Seven, is built on a foundation of comprehensive analysis. Over these decades, we’ve subjected thousands of automobiles to rigorous scrutiny, assigning each a performance score out of a possible five. True perfection, as we’ve learned, is an exceedingly rare commodity; typically, only one or two vehicles per year ascend to the hallowed ground of a full five-star rating.
This exclusive compilation delves into the crème de la crème of automotive engineering and design from the past decade, specifically highlighting those vehicles that have earned our ultimate commendation: the coveted five-star rating. In an era saturated with compelling automotive choices, achieving this distinction is a testament to exceptional engineering, groundbreaking innovation, and an unyielding commitment to driver and passenger satisfaction. We’ve meticulously curated this list, presenting only the 21 vehicles across the United States that have truly captured our expert panel’s imagination and met our exacting standards. Join us as we journey through the last ten years of automotive history, celebrating the machines that redefined excellence and set new benchmarks for the best new cars.
Our selection process is not merely about raw power or dazzling aesthetics, though these often play a role. Instead, we evaluate a holistic blend of factors: driving dynamics, comfort, practicality, technological integration, safety, fuel efficiency, and overall value proposition. This ensures that our five-star recipients are not just aspirational objects but genuinely outstanding automobiles that excel in everyday use and long-term ownership. For enthusiasts and discerning buyers alike, this list represents the ultimate guide to purchasing a truly world-class vehicle.
The Elite Few: A Deep Dive into America’s Five-Star Automotive Achievements
The automotive landscape of the United States is a dynamic tapestry of innovation and fierce competition. To rise above the throng and earn a perfect score from Autocar is an accomplishment of monumental significance. This curated selection, presented in alphabetical order for equitable consideration, showcases the vehicles that have demonstrably pushed the boundaries of what is possible in automotive design and performance. Each of these top-rated vehicles has been meticulously scrutinized, evaluated across a spectrum of criteria that reflect the evolving demands of the modern driver.
Audi RS e-tron GT (Publication Date: May 2021)
The Audi RS e-tron GT stands as a beacon of electric performance, a potent blend of supercar aesthetics and sustainable power. This remarkable machine doesn’t just drive; it glides with an almost supernatural composure, yet unleashes ferocity when prompted. Its all-wheel-drive system, coupled with adaptive air suspension, delivers a ride that is both exquisitely comfortable on long journeys and dynamically engaging on winding roads. The dual-motor setup provides instantaneous torque, catapulting the RS e-tron GT from a standstill with breathtaking acceleration. Beyond its performance, the interior is a masterclass in minimalist luxury, featuring premium materials and cutting-edge infotainment technology. For those seeking an electric vehicle that doesn’t compromise on excitement or refinement, the Audi RS e-tron GT is a compelling proposition, redefining what electric sports cars can be. It represents a significant leap forward in the quest for high-performance, zero-emission mobility, making it a truly standout contender in the electric vehicle market. The sophisticated handling characteristics and the sheer pleasure of driving this car solidify its place among the elite. The attention to detail in its construction, from the aerodynamic sculpting of its exterior to the intuitive interface of its digital cockpit, speaks volumes about Audi’s commitment to excellence. It’s a vehicle that delivers on the promise of exhilarating performance while embracing the future of automotive propulsion, making it a wise investment for those looking at performance EVs.
BMW M3 Competition / M4 Competition (Publication Date: October 2021)
BMW’s M division has long been synonymous with pure driving pleasure, and the M3 Competition and its coupe counterpart, the M4 Competition, are no exception. These performance sedans and coupes embody a perfect equilibrium between track-bred capability and everyday usability. The potent inline-six turbocharged engine delivers a visceral and engaging experience, while the chassis, honed through countless hours of development, provides exceptional grip and feedback. Whether you opt for the rear-wheel-drive purist’s choice or the all-wheel-drive xDrive variant, the driving dynamics are sharp, precise, and exhilarating. The interior, while driver-focused, offers a surprising degree of comfort and practicality, making these machines surprisingly adept at navigating daily commutes as well as spirited weekend drives. These are performance sedans that don’t just compete; they set the standard, offering a driving experience that is both challenging and rewarding. They represent the apex of BMW’s engineering prowess, delivering a driving sensation that is both raw and refined. The introduction of their latest iteration has further solidified their reputation as benchmark sport sedans, proving that internal combustion engines can still deliver an unmatched visceral thrill. For those in search of a vehicle that ignites the senses and provides an unadulterated connection to the road, the M3 and M4 Competition remain unparalleled choices in the luxury performance car segment.
Ferrari SF90 Stradale (Publication Date: November 2020)
The Ferrari SF90 Stradale is not just a supercar; it’s a paradigm shift in performance motoring. This plug-in hybrid marvel combines a ferocious V8 twin-turbocharged engine with three electric motors, creating a powertrain that produces a staggering 986 horsepower. The result is a level of acceleration and outright speed that redefines the supercar genre. Yet, astonishingly, the SF90 Stradale also offers a semblance of usability, with an advanced hybrid system that can propel it on electric power alone for short distances. The driving experience is utterly captivating, a symphony of mechanical and electrical power that engages all the senses. Ferrari’s mastery of chassis dynamics is on full display, delivering a car that is both incredibly fast and remarkably composed, even at the limit. It’s a testament to what is possible when cutting-edge technology meets the artistry of Italian engineering, making it a true icon in the realm of hypercars and a significant achievement for hybrid sports cars. The SF90 Stradale is a bold statement about the future of high-performance vehicles, demonstrating that electrification can enhance, rather than detract from, the thrilling experience of driving a Ferrari. This vehicle is a cornerstone for anyone interested in the bleeding edge of supercar technology.
Genesis GV80 (Publication Date: May 2020)
The Genesis GV80 has proven that a luxury SUV can offer both opulence and exceptional value. This Korean newcomer has rapidly ascended the ranks, challenging established players with its distinctive design, impeccable craftsmanship, and sophisticated technology. The interior is a sanctuary of comfort and quietude, featuring premium materials and intuitive controls. The driving experience is refined and composed, with a ride quality that smooths out imperfections in the road, yet retains a reassuring sense of stability. Genesis has managed to create a vehicle that feels every bit as luxurious as its German rivals, often at a more accessible price point. It’s a compelling choice for those seeking a premium SUV that doesn’t compromise on style, comfort, or substance, marking a significant milestone for luxury SUVs and proving the capabilities of Korean luxury cars. The GV80’s success underscores Genesis’s dedication to creating vehicles that offer a complete luxury experience, from the initial purchase to the daily drive. It’s a testament to their understanding of what discerning consumers expect in the premium SUV market.
Hyundai Ioniq 5 (Publication Date: July 2021)
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 is a revolutionary electric vehicle that artfully blends retro-futuristic design with cutting-edge technology. Its distinctive styling, inspired by Hyundai’s Pony coupe concept, sets it apart from the conventional EV crowd. Inside, the Ioniq 5 offers a spacious and airy cabin, thanks to its dedicated electric platform, creating a lounge-like atmosphere. Performance is brisk and smooth, with impressive range and incredibly fast charging capabilities, thanks to its 800-volt architecture. It’s a practical, stylish, and immensely appealing electric car that represents a significant step forward for Hyundai and the electric car industry. The Ioniq 5 isn’t just another EV; it’s a statement of intent, showcasing Hyundai’s commitment to innovation and design leadership in the zero-emission vehicles sector. It’s a prime example of a family electric car that doesn’t sacrifice style or performance. Its innovative features and user-friendly interface make it an excellent choice for electric car buyers looking for something truly special.
Kia EV6 (Publication Date: August 2021)
Sharing its platform with the Hyundai Ioniq 5, the Kia EV6 carves out its own unique identity with a sportier, more dynamic design and driving character. This electric crossover is a compelling package, offering exhilarating performance, impressive range, and the same lightning-fast charging speeds as its sibling. The EV6’s interior is modern and driver-oriented, with a focus on technology and premium materials. Its agile handling and responsive acceleration make it a joy to drive, whether navigating city streets or embarking on longer journeys. The Kia EV6 proves that electric vehicles can be exciting, stylish, and practical, solidifying Kia’s position as a major player in the electric vehicle market and offering another excellent option for new electric cars. It’s a standout in the eco-friendly car segment, delivering a compelling blend of performance and efficiency.
Land Rover Defender (Publication Date: March 2021)
The reborn Land Rover Defender is a triumphant return for an automotive icon. Far from simply rehashing the past, Land Rover has infused this legendary nameplate with modern technology and refined luxury while preserving its legendary off-road prowess. The new Defender is as capable on a remote mountain trail as it is cruising down the highway. Its rugged yet sophisticated interior is designed for durability and comfort, with a wealth of advanced features. The range of powertrains ensures there’s a Defender to suit various needs, from efficient four-cylinder options to potent six-cylinder and V8 variants. This is a vehicle that inspires confidence and adventure, a true all-rounder that excels in any environment, proving itself as one of the most capable off-road SUVs and a benchmark in the luxury SUV space. The Defender’s revival is a masterclass in respecting heritage while embracing innovation, offering a truly unique proposition in the SUV market. Its enduring appeal lies in its versatility and its ability to conquer any terrain.
Mercedes-AMG GT 4-Door Coupe (Publication Date: October 2019)
The Mercedes-AMG GT 4-Door Coupe is a bold and exhilarating fusion of a four-door sedan and a high-performance coupe. It offers the practicality of increased passenger and cargo space without sacrificing the aggressive styling and blistering performance that AMG is renowned for. Under the hood, potent V8 engines deliver thunderous power, coupled with a chassis that provides uncanny agility and grip. The interior is a luxurious and technologically advanced space, befitting a car of its caliber. This is a car for those who demand both exhilaration and everyday usability, a true performance sedan that pushes the boundaries of automotive engineering. It represents the pinnacle of luxury performance cars, offering an unparalleled driving experience for those who appreciate the finer things in life. For those seeking a four-door sports car that doesn’t compromise on luxury or speed, this AMG is a prime candidate.
Mercedes-Benz S-Class (Publication Date: December 2020)
The Mercedes-Benz S-Class has long been the undisputed benchmark for luxury sedans, and its latest iteration continues this illustrious tradition. This is not just a car; it’s a mobile sanctuary, a testament to automotive refinement and technological advancement. The interior is a haven of unparalleled comfort and opulence, featuring exquisite materials, cutting-edge infotainment systems, and advanced driver-assistance features that create an almost autonomous driving experience. The ride quality is sublime, gliding over the road with an effortless grace. It is the epitome of luxury sedans and a consistent leader in the premium car segment, setting the standard for all others to follow. The S-Class is more than just transportation; it’s an experience, a statement of success and sophisticated taste. For those who desire the absolute best in automotive comfort and technology, the flagship sedan remains the ultimate choice.
Porsche 911 Carrera S / Carrera 4S (Publication Date: January 2020)
The Porsche 911 Carrera S and Carrera 4S embody the enduring appeal and evolutionary brilliance of arguably the world’s most iconic sports car. Porsche has a remarkable knack for refining the 911 formula, enhancing its performance, handling, and driver engagement with each generation. The latest iteration offers a potent twin-turbocharged flat-six engine that delivers exhilarating acceleration and a glorious soundtrack. The chassis is a masterpiece of engineering, providing sublime handling, remarkable feedback, and an intoxicating connection between driver and machine. It remains the benchmark for sports cars, a timeless icon that continues to impress and delight enthusiasts. These are performance cars that transcend trends, offering a pure and unadulterated driving experience that is hard to match. For anyone seeking the ultimate rear-engine sports car, the 911 remains the undisputed champion.
Porsche Taycan (Publication Date: September 2020)
The Porsche Taycan represents a bold and highly successful foray into the electric vehicle market. Porsche has managed to imbue its first all-electric sports car with the DNA of its legendary performance heritage. The Taycan delivers breathtaking acceleration, dynamic handling, and the signature Porsche driving feel, all without emissions. Its advanced battery technology and rapid charging capabilities address key concerns for EV adoption. The interior is a modern and sophisticated space, featuring a minimalist design and an array of advanced technological features. The Taycan proves that electric performance can be just as thrilling as its gasoline-powered counterparts, establishing itself as a leading contender in the electric sports car segment and a vital part of the premium EV market. It’s a testament to Porsche’s ability to innovate and adapt, offering an electrifying driving experience.
Rimac Nevera (Publication Date: September 2022)
The Rimac Nevera is not just an electric hypercar; it’s a technological tour de force and a glimpse into the extreme future of automotive performance. This Croatian marvel boasts an all-electric powertrain producing an astonishing 1,914 horsepower, capable of mind-bending acceleration and blistering top speeds. Its advanced aerodynamic design and sophisticated chassis control systems ensure that this immense power is delivered in a surprisingly manageable and exhilarating manner. The interior is a blend of cutting-edge technology and minimalist luxury, befitting a machine of such exclusivity and performance. The Nevera is a statement about the limitless potential of electric propulsion, pushing the boundaries of what we thought possible in electric hypercars and performance EVs. It’s a rare breed of vehicle, representing the absolute pinnacle of automotive engineering and innovation. For those who crave the ultimate in electric performance and cutting-edge technology, the Nevera is an unparalleled achievement.
Rolls-Royce Ghost (Publication Date: December 2020)
The Rolls-Royce Ghost embodies the very essence of discreet luxury and effortless refinement. While sharing its platform with BMW’s most capable sedans, the Ghost is undeniably a Rolls-Royce, offering an unparalleled sense of occasion and serenity. The interior is a masterpiece of craftsmanship, with bespoke materials and an oasis of quietude that insulates occupants from the outside world. The ride is exceptionally smooth, providing a sensation of gliding rather than driving. It’s a car for those who appreciate the finer details and demand the ultimate in comfort and prestige, solidifying its position as a leading ultra-luxury car and a testament to the enduring appeal of high-end sedans. For those seeking the pinnacle of automotive indulgence and a truly bespoke experience, the Ghost offers an unmatched level of sophistication.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (Publication Date: June 2019)
The Tesla Model 3 Performance redefined expectations for electric sedans, offering an intoxicating blend of blistering acceleration, engaging handling, and impressive range. Tesla’s relentless innovation in software and battery technology ensures the Model 3 remains a compelling choice. The minimalist interior, dominated by a large central touchscreen, offers a futuristic and uncluttered driving environment. Its performance is so potent that it challenges many traditional sports cars, making it a groundbreaking electric sedan and a significant contributor to the growth of the EV market. The Model 3 Performance is a testament to Tesla’s vision for the future of driving, proving that electric cars can be both practical and incredibly exciting. It remains a benchmark for performance EVs available today.
Tesla Model S Plaid (Publication Date: June 2021)
The Tesla Model S Plaid represents the zenith of electric sedan performance, delivering acceleration figures that were once considered the exclusive domain of hypercars. With its tri-motor all-wheel-drive system, the Plaid achieves supercar-levels of speed and responsiveness. Despite its staggering performance, the Model S retains its practical four-door sedan body style and its signature minimalist interior. Tesla’s continuous software updates ensure that the Plaid remains at the cutting edge of automotive technology. It’s a groundbreaking vehicle that continues to push the boundaries of what is possible with electric propulsion, a true marvel in the high-performance EV category and a significant player in the electric car industry. For those seeking the ultimate combination of speed, technology, and electric range, the Model S Plaid is an unparalleled offering.
Toyota GR Yaris (Publication Date: November 2020)
The Toyota GR Yaris is a rally-bred hot hatch that delivers an unfiltered and exhilarating driving experience. Developed with input from motorsport professionals, this compact powerhouse boasts a unique three-door body, a potent turbocharged three-cylinder engine, and an advanced all-wheel-drive system designed for maximum grip and agility. The interior is functional and driver-focused, eschewing excessive luxury for a pure performance feel. It’s a car that rewards enthusiastic driving and provides a genuine connection to the road, making it a standout among hot hatches and a favorite among driving purists. The GR Yaris is a testament to Toyota’s commitment to creating exciting and engaging driver’s cars, proving that even in the era of electrification, there’s still a place for finely tuned internal combustion engines in the performance car segment.
Volvo XC40 Recharge (Publication Date: November 2021)
The Volvo XC40 Recharge injects Scandinavian design flair and safety consciousness into the compact electric SUV segment. This stylish and practical EV offers a comfortable and refined driving experience, with ample power from its dual-motor setup and a respectable range. Volvo’s commitment to safety is evident in its comprehensive suite of advanced driver-assistance systems. The interior is modern and minimalist, reflecting Volvo’s design philosophy, and offers good practicality for everyday use. The XC40 Recharge is an excellent choice for those seeking a well-rounded and safe electric SUV that doesn’t compromise on style or usability. It’s a strong contender in the compact electric SUV market, offering a premium experience in a smaller package.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Publication Date: August 2020)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI has long been the benchmark for the hot hatch segment, and its latest iteration continues to uphold that prestigious title. It masterfully balances everyday usability with exhilarating performance. The turbocharged engine provides ample power, and the chassis delivers a superb blend of sharp handling and comfortable ride quality. The interior is well-appointed and technologically advanced, reflecting VW’s commitment to quality and refinement. It remains the quintessential hot hatch, a car that appeals to both driving enthusiasts and those seeking a practical, well-rounded compact car. The Golf GTI is a testament to the enduring appeal of a well-executed performance compact, a reliable and fun choice in the compact car segment.
Volkswagen ID.4 (Publication Date: March 2021)
The Volkswagen ID.4 represents VW’s serious commitment to the electric vehicle revolution, offering a spacious, practical, and comfortable family-oriented SUV. Its dedicated electric platform allows for generous interior space and a smooth, quiet ride. Performance is adequate for daily driving, and the ID.4 boasts impressive range and fast-charging capabilities. The interior is modern and minimalist, focusing on intuitive technology. The ID.4 is a strong contender in the rapidly growing electric SUV market, providing a sensible and stylish option for families looking to transition to electric mobility. It’s a key player in the mainstream EV market, offering a compelling blend of space, efficiency, and technology for the everyday driver.
The Enduring Quest for Automotive Perfection
These 21 vehicles represent the pinnacle of automotive achievement over the past decade, meticulously selected for their outstanding performance, innovation, and overall excellence. Each has earned its five-star rating through a rigorous and unbiased evaluation process conducted by seasoned industry experts.
As the automotive industry continues its rapid evolution, driven by advancements in electrification, autonomous technology, and sustainable materials, the pursuit of automotive perfection remains our guiding principle. We are committed to continuously testing and evaluating the latest models, bringing you the most informed and insightful reviews to help you navigate the exciting world of cars.
Ready to experience automotive excellence for yourself? Explore our in-depth reviews of these five-star vehicles and discover the car that perfectly aligns with your driving aspirations. Your journey to owning an exceptional automobile begins here.
