The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Cars
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive journalism, meticulously scrutinizing every facet of vehicle design, engineering, and performance. Our commitment to comprehensive road tests began in 1928, with the venerable Austin Seven, a motorcar that captivated the United Kingdom and set the standard for mass-produced automobiles. Since that inaugural evaluation, our team of seasoned road testers has piloted thousands of vehicles, subjecting each to our rigorous assessment framework, culminating in an overall score out of five stars. Earning a perfect score, a coveted five-star rating, is an exceptionally rare achievement, a testament to vehicles that transcend the ordinary and redefine automotive excellence. Typically, only one or two vehicles each year manage to ascend to this rarefied echelon.
This feature delves into an exclusive collection: the 21 vehicles that have achieved the ultimate accolade, a perfect five-star rating from Autocar over the last ten years. We invite you to join us as we revisit the crème de la crème of the automotive world, a decade defined by groundbreaking innovation, breathtaking performance, and unparalleled luxury. Each entry is presented with the date of its original publication, offering a chronological glimpse into the evolution of automotive perfection.
A Legacy of Acclaim: The Five-Star Cars of the Past Decade
In the pursuit of identifying the truly exceptional, we have meticulously compiled a roster of vehicles that have not only met but exceeded every conceivable benchmark of automotive prowess. These are not merely cars; they are masterpieces of engineering, artistry, and advanced technology, each representing a significant leap forward in its respective category. From groundbreaking electric vehicles challenging the established order to ultra-luxury sedans offering an oasis of refinement, and from exhilarating performance machines to supremely capable SUVs, this selection represents the apex of what the automotive industry has achieved in the past ten years.
The process of awarding a five-star rating is an arduous one. Our experienced road testers, armed with over a decade of collective automotive analysis, subject each vehicle to an exhaustive battery of tests. This includes an in-depth examination of driving dynamics, from steering feedback and suspension composure to braking performance and acceleration. We meticulously evaluate powertrain efficiency and responsiveness, scrutinize interior ergonomics and material quality, and assess the effectiveness of advanced safety systems. Furthermore, considerations such as technological integration, infotainment usability, and the overall ownership experience play a crucial role in our final judgment. A five-star car must excel in virtually every measurable aspect, offering a holistic package that leaves no room for compromise.
The Elite 21: A Decade of Automotive Ascendancy
Presented here, in alphabetical order, are the 21 vehicles that have earned the ultimate commendation from Autocar, a testament to their enduring excellence and their impact on the automotive landscape. These are the cars that have set new standards, inspired competitors, and provided unforgettable driving experiences for their fortunate owners.
Aston Martin DB11
When the Aston Martin DB11 arrived, it wasn’t just a new car; it was a statement of intent. Building upon the iconic lineage of Aston Martin grand tourers, the DB11 elevated the formula with a stunning new design language and a potent twin-turbocharged V8 engine that delivered thunderous performance with sophisticated grace. The interior, a sanctuary of hand-stitched leather and exquisite craftsmanship, cocooned occupants in unparalleled luxury. Its dynamic capabilities struck a perfect balance between athletic agility for spirited drives and serene comfort for long-distance cruising, solidifying its position as a benchmark for luxury sports cars. The engaging steering and composed ride meant that whether navigating winding coastal roads or covering vast highways, the DB11 offered an intoxicating blend of power and refinement.
Audi RS6 Avant (C8)
The Audi RS6 Avant has long been synonymous with the ultimate fast estate car, and the C8 generation cemented this reputation. More than just a powerful station wagon, it’s a marvel of practicality blended with supercar-baiting performance. Its prodigious twin-turbocharged V8 engine unleashes immense power, delivered through Audi’s renowned Quattro all-wheel-drive system, ensuring tenacious grip and breathtaking acceleration in all conditions. The chassis, while capable of handling the immense forces, also provides a surprisingly compliant ride for daily usability. Inside, the RS6 offers a luxurious and technologically advanced cabin, complete with Audi’s Virtual Cockpit and high-quality materials, making it a truly compelling proposition for those who demand both exhilaration and everyday utility. For discerning drivers in cities like Chicago or Atlanta, the RS6 Avant offers a unique blend of performance and practicality that few other vehicles can match, making it a sought-after option in the luxury SUV and performance sedan markets.
Bentley Flying Spur
The Bentley Flying Spur represents the epitome of ultra-luxury motoring, offering a chauffeur-driven experience that rivals the finest in the world. Even when driven by its owner, the Flying Spur provides an astonishing level of refinement, effortless performance from its mighty W12 engine, and an interior that is a testament to the finest British craftsmanship. Every detail, from the diamond-quilted leather upholstery to the polished wood veneers, exudes opulence. The ride quality is exceptionally smooth, ironing out imperfections in the road surface to create a serene cabin environment. Advanced technology is seamlessly integrated, enhancing both comfort and convenience for all occupants. For those seeking the ultimate expression of automotive luxury and prestige, the Bentley Flying Spur stands in a class of its own, a symbol of status and unparalleled comfort.
BMW M2 Competition
The BMW M2 Competition injected a dose of raw, unadulterated driving excitement into the sports coupe segment. Stripped back and focused, it offered a visceral connection between driver and machine that is increasingly rare. Its potent inline-six engine delivered thrilling acceleration and a sonorous exhaust note, while the finely tuned chassis and rear-wheel-drive bias provided exceptional agility and predictable handling. The M2 Competition was a car that reveled in spirited driving, rewarding precise inputs with immediate and engaging responses. It wasn’t about outright lap times as much as it was about the sheer joy of the drive, making it a favorite among driving enthusiasts seeking a compact, high-performance coupe that offers an authentic M car experience, a key consideration for those in markets like Southern California where spirited driving is a way of life.
BMW M3 Competition (G80)
The arrival of the G80 M3 Competition marked a significant evolution for BMW’s legendary performance sedan. While its bold styling might be polarizing for some, its performance credentials are undeniable. The potent twin-turbocharged inline-six engine delivers blistering acceleration and a broad torque band, coupled with an all-wheel-drive system that can be configured for rear-wheel-drive fun. The chassis is a masterpiece of engineering, offering a remarkable balance between track-honed precision and everyday usability. Despite its performance capabilities, the M3 Competition remains a practical sedan, offering a well-appointed interior and sufficient space for passengers and cargo, making it a compelling choice for those who demand the ultimate blend of sportiness and daily practicality.
Ferrari 296 GTB
The Ferrari 296 GTB represents a groundbreaking shift for the Maranello marque, integrating a potent hybrid powertrain into its mid-engined supercar formula. This innovative approach delivers staggering performance, with electrifying acceleration and a dynamic prowess that remains unmistakably Ferrari. The V6 hybrid system works in perfect harmony with the electric motor, providing both immense power and surprising efficiency. The design is breathtakingly beautiful, embodying Ferrari’s signature aerodynamic artistry. Inside, the driver-focused cockpit is a testament to Italian craftsmanship, blending performance-oriented ergonomics with luxurious materials. The 296 GTB is a testament to Ferrari’s continuous pursuit of innovation, delivering an experience that is both exhilarating and technologically advanced, a significant development in the high-performance sports car segment for buyers in affluent areas like Miami.
Ford Focus ST
The Ford Focus ST has consistently championed the cause of the affordable, engaging hot hatch, and the latest iteration continued this noble tradition. It offered a delightful blend of sharp handling, responsive acceleration, and practical hatchback versatility, all at a price point that made it accessible to a wide range of driving enthusiasts. The turbocharged engine provided plenty of pep, and the chassis was expertly tuned to deliver an entertaining and confidence-inspiring driving experience, whether on a challenging B-road or navigating urban environments. The Focus ST proved that exceptional driving enjoyment doesn’t require a premium price tag, cementing its status as a benchmark for performance and value in its class, a crucial consideration for budget-conscious performance seekers.
Honda Civic Type R (FK8)
The FK8 Honda Civic Type R is widely regarded as one of the most accomplished front-wheel-drive performance cars ever made. Its ferocious turbocharged engine delivers explosive power, and the chassis engineers at Honda worked wonders to harness this power and deliver razor-sharp handling, remarkable grip, and exceptional feedback through the steering wheel. The advanced aerodynamic package not only contributes to its aggressive styling but also plays a crucial role in its high-speed stability. While its styling might be overtly aggressive for some, its performance on both road and track is nothing short of exceptional, making it a benchmark for front-wheel-drive dynamics, a key competitor in the enthusiast car market, especially for those seeking affordable performance and track capability.
Jaguar F-Pace SVR
The Jaguar F-Pace SVR represents the ultimate expression of performance within Jaguar’s SUV lineup. This potent machine seamlessly blends the practicality and commanding presence of an SUV with the raw power and dynamic flair of a performance car. Its supercharged V8 engine unleashes a torrent of acceleration, while the chassis has been meticulously tuned to handle the immense power with impressive composure and agility. The SVR delivers a thrilling driving experience, complete with a thunderous exhaust note that announces its arrival. Inside, the F-Pace SVR offers a luxurious and well-appointed cabin, befitting its premium positioning, making it a compelling choice for those who desire SUV versatility without compromising on exhilarating performance, a strong contender in the luxury performance SUV segment in markets like Los Angeles.
Kia EV6 GT
The Kia EV6 GT arrived as a potent statement of intent from the South Korean manufacturer, showcasing the thrilling potential of electric performance. This all-electric GT variant boasts dual electric motors that deliver instantaneous and immense torque, resulting in breathtaking acceleration that rivals many established performance cars. Beyond its straight-line speed, the EV6 GT surprised with its engaging handling and refined ride quality, demonstrating that electric vehicles can offer a dynamic and enjoyable driving experience. The futuristic interior design and advanced technology further enhance its appeal, positioning the EV6 GT as a groundbreaking contender in the electric vehicle market, a significant advancement for electric car enthusiasts in major metropolitan areas.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO represents a potent evolution of the already formidable Huracán lineage. Retaining its naturally aspirated V10 engine, it delivers an exhilarating soundtrack and a visceral driving experience that is quintessentially Lamborghini. The advanced all-wheel-drive system and torque vectoring technology ensure that the EVO offers exceptional traction and agility, allowing drivers to exploit its immense performance with confidence. The design remains strikingly aggressive and aerodynamic, a true head-turner on any street. Inside, the driver-focused cockpit is a blend of race-car inspiration and luxury, putting the driver firmly in command. The Huracán EVO continues to set benchmarks for naturally aspirated supercar performance, a dream machine for enthusiasts in high-performance car circles.
McLaren Artura
The McLaren Artura represents a bold new chapter for the British supercar manufacturer, embracing a revolutionary hybrid powertrain and a carbon-fiber chassis that pushes the boundaries of lightweight construction. This innovative approach delivers astonishing performance, with electrifying acceleration and a dynamic agility that is synonymous with the McLaren brand. The seamless integration of the hybrid system provides both enhanced power and improved efficiency. The Artura’s design is a masterclass in aerodynamic efficiency and visual drama, while the driver-centric cockpit offers a blend of cutting-edge technology and premium materials. It signifies McLaren’s commitment to the future of high-performance vehicles, a key development in the evolving supercar market, particularly for those interested in hybrid performance cars.
Mercedes-AMG GT Black Series
The Mercedes-AMG GT Black Series is an automotive masterpiece, a track-focused hypercar that pushes the limits of what is possible on public roads. Its monstrous twin-turbocharged V8 engine delivers blistering performance, while the aggressive aerodynamics, inspired by GT3 racing cars, generate immense downforce for unparalleled grip. The chassis has been meticulously engineered to provide extreme track capability, with adjustable suspension and braking systems. Inside, the cabin is a blend of race-inspired functionality and Mercedes-Benz luxury, creating an environment that is both focused and comfortable for high-speed excursions. The GT Black Series is a halo car, showcasing the pinnacle of AMG engineering and a dream for serious track enthusiasts seeking the ultimate driving machine.
Mercedes-Benz S-Class (W223)
The latest iteration of the Mercedes-Benz S-Class continues its reign as the benchmark for luxury sedans, setting new standards for comfort, technology, and refinement. The W223 model elevates the driving and passenger experience with a serenely quiet cabin, a supremely comfortable ride, and an interior that redefines automotive opulence. Advanced driver-assistance systems and a cutting-edge infotainment interface ensure that occupants are connected and protected. The S-Class offers a range of sophisticated powertrains that deliver smooth, effortless performance. For those seeking the ultimate expression of automotive comfort, prestige, and technological innovation, the Mercedes-Benz S-Class remains the undisputed champion, a leading choice for luxury car buyers in major cities across the United States.
Porsche 911 Carrera (992)
The 992 generation of the Porsche 911 Carrera represents a masterful evolution of an automotive icon. Porsche has once again demonstrated its unparalleled ability to blend timeless design with cutting-edge technology and exhilarating performance. The rear-engine layout continues to provide a unique and engaging driving dynamic, while the enhanced turbocharged flat-six engine delivers potent acceleration and a distinctive soundtrack. The chassis is a marvel of engineering, offering exceptional grip, precise handling, and a composed ride that makes it equally adept on a winding mountain road or during a daily commute. The interior combines classic 911 design cues with modern digital interfaces, creating a driver-focused environment that is both functional and luxurious. The 992 Carrera remains the definitive sports car, a benchmark for performance and driving engagement, highly sought after by sports car enthusiasts nationwide.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S
The Porsche Taycan Turbo S shattered preconceptions about what an electric performance car could be. It delivered blistering acceleration, thanks to its dual electric motors, and a dynamic driving experience that was unmistakably Porsche. The advanced all-wheel-drive system and sophisticated chassis tuning ensured exceptional handling and grip, even under demanding conditions. The Taycan’s interior was a blend of minimalist modern design and premium materials, featuring cutting-edge technology and a driver-focused cockpit. It proved that electric vehicles can offer not only impressive performance but also the engaging driving dynamics and build quality that enthusiasts expect from Porsche, a significant achievement in the luxury EV market, attracting buyers interested in high-performance electric vehicles.
Range Rover (L460)
The L460 Range Rover represents a significant step forward for the iconic luxury SUV, redefining its blend of opulent comfort, exceptional off-road capability, and sophisticated on-road manners. The new platform offers a more composed and refined driving experience, while the interior has been elevated to new heights of luxury and technological integration. Despite its considerable size, the Range Rover remains remarkably agile, and its off-road prowess is as formidable as ever. The range of powertrains offers a balance of performance and efficiency, ensuring that it can tackle any journey with effortless grace. For those seeking the ultimate statement in luxury, capability, and refinement, the latest Range Rover stands as the pinnacle of the SUV segment, a highly desirable vehicle in affluent markets across the country.
Rolls-Royce Ghost
The Rolls-Royce Ghost embodies a more contemporary and minimalist approach to ultra-luxury motoring, while still retaining the brand’s hallmark of supreme refinement and exquisite craftsmanship. The Ghost offers an incredibly smooth and silent ride, cocooning its occupants in an oasis of calm. Its powerful V12 engine delivers effortless acceleration, making it feel surprisingly agile for its size. The interior is a masterpiece of bespoke customization, utilizing the finest materials and meticulous attention to detail, ensuring a truly personalized and opulent experience. The Ghost proves that luxury doesn’t always need to be ostentatious; it can be understated, sophisticated, and profoundly comfortable, a symbol of ultimate automotive prestige and comfort for discerning individuals.
Škoda Octavia vRS
The Škoda Octavia vRS has long been a champion of the sensible yet exhilarating performance car, offering a compelling blend of practicality, performance, and value. The latest iteration continued this legacy, providing strong acceleration from its turbocharged engine and sharp, engaging handling that made it a joy to drive on both winding roads and motorways. The Octavia vRS offers ample space for passengers and luggage, making it an ideal choice for families who don’t want to compromise on driving enjoyment. Its sophisticated interior and generous equipment levels further enhance its appeal, solidifying its position as a standout performer in the competitive performance estate and saloon market, a testament to smart engineering and attainable performance.
Toyota GR Yaris
The Toyota GR Yaris is a rally-inspired, homologation special that has captured the hearts of driving enthusiasts worldwide. Developed with input from rally champions, it boasts a potent turbocharged three-cylinder engine, a unique all-wheel-drive system that can be biased towards the rear, and a chassis engineered for ultimate agility and grip. Its compact size and focused design make it an incredibly engaging and fun car to drive, capable of exhilarating performance on both road and track. The GR Yaris is a rare breed, a car built purely for the joy of driving, proving that exceptional performance and driving dynamics can be found in a compact, accessible package, a truly special vehicle for automotive aficionados.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk8)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI, a nameplate synonymous with the definition of a hot hatch, continues its reign with the Mk8 generation. This latest iteration builds upon the legendary formula of offering a perfect balance between sporty performance and everyday usability. The turbocharged engine provides lively acceleration, while the chassis delivers sharp handling and a comfortable ride, making it a joy to drive in any situation. The Mk8 GTI’s interior features a modern, tech-forward design with intuitive controls and comfortable seating. It remains the benchmark for accessible performance, a car that can be used for daily commuting or enjoyed on a spirited weekend drive, a consistent favorite for driving enthusiasts seeking reliable performance and practicality.
The Enduring Quest for Automotive Perfection
The 21 cars featured here represent the zenith of automotive engineering and design over the past decade. They are testaments to innovation, passion, and an unwavering commitment to delivering exceptional driving experiences. From the raw emotion of a V10 supercar to the refined elegance of a luxury saloon, each of these vehicles has earned its place among the elite.
As the automotive industry continues its rapid evolution, driven by advancements in electrification, autonomous technology, and sustainable mobility, Autocar remains dedicated to identifying and celebrating the very best. Our road-testing expertise, honed over nearly a century, ensures that we continue to guide you through the landscape of automotive excellence.
Ready to discover the next generation of automotive stars? Explore our latest road tests and expert reviews to stay ahead of the curve and find the vehicle that defines your driving future.
