The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Machines
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive journalism, meticulously dissecting and evaluating vehicles to guide discerning buyers. Since our inaugural road test of the Austin Seven in 1928, a modest yet groundbreaking vehicle that captured the hearts and driveways of the United Kingdom, we have subjected thousands of automobiles to our rigorous scrutiny. This process culminates in a comprehensive scoring system, with a coveted five-star rating reserved for those vehicles that truly transcend the ordinary. Achieving this pinnacle is an exceedingly rare feat, a distinction bestowed upon merely one or two exceptional models annually.
This curated collection represents the zenith of automotive achievement over the past decade. We have meticulously sifted through a decade of exhaustive road tests, identifying the select few – a mere twenty-one vehicles – that have earned our highest accolade: the perfect five-star rating. Join us as we delve into the stories behind these remarkable machines, exploring what propelled them to the forefront of automotive excellence and contributed to their status as best cars of the decade. This exploration is more than just a retrospective; it’s a testament to innovation, engineering prowess, and an unwavering commitment to the driving experience.
The Genesis of Excellence: Understanding the Five-Star Benchmark
In the fiercely competitive landscape of automotive manufacturing, where incremental improvements and minor updates are the norm, distinguishing true pioneers from proficient performers can be challenging. At Autocar, our five-star rating isn’t awarded lightly. It signifies a vehicle that not only excels in its class but fundamentally redefines expectations, offering a holistic package of performance, refinement, technology, and sheer desirability that resonates deeply with our expert testers. This isn’t about ticking boxes; it’s about experiencing a vehicle that evokes genuine emotion and inspires confidence in its every facet. Our process involves a multi-faceted evaluation, considering everything from the tactile sensation of the interior materials to the nuanced feedback through the steering wheel, the responsiveness of the powertrain, and the effectiveness of its safety systems. We assess its everyday usability, its long-term comfort, and its ability to deliver joy on both mundane commutes and exhilarating journeys.
The criteria for a five-star rating are stringent and have evolved to reflect advancements in automotive technology and the ever-increasing demands of modern drivers. While raw performance remains a crucial element, it is now intricately woven with considerations for fuel efficiency, environmental impact, and the seamless integration of cutting-edge infotainment and driver-assistance systems. We look for vehicles that demonstrate exceptional ride and handling balance, offering a supple yet engaging experience that caters to a wide spectrum of driving preferences. Braking performance, acceleration, and overall composure under various conditions are meticulously measured. Furthermore, the interior must be a sanctuary of comfort and sophistication, with intuitive controls, high-quality materials, and ample space for occupants and their belongings. The infotainment system should be both feature-rich and user-friendly, seamlessly connecting the driver to their digital world without becoming a distraction. Safety is paramount, and vehicles earning our top marks invariably incorporate the latest active and passive safety technologies, providing peace of mind for drivers and passengers alike.
A Decade of Dreams Realized: The Elite Twenty-One
The following list represents an alphabetical compilation of the twenty-one vehicles that have achieved the ultimate recognition from Autocar over the past ten years. Each entry is accompanied by the date of its original review, offering a temporal anchor to their groundbreaking debut. These are not just cars; they are automotive milestones that have shaped our understanding of what a modern vehicle can and should be.
Aston Martin DB11 (November 2016): The Aston Martin DB11 represented a significant leap forward for the iconic British marque, a harmonious blend of breathtaking design, potent performance, and luxurious grand touring credentials. Its twin-turbocharged V8 and V12 engines offered a symphony of power, while the chassis delivered a remarkably composed and engaging driving experience. The interior was a masterclass in bespoke craftsmanship, creating an environment that was both sporting and sumptuously comfortable. The DB11 redefined the grand tourer, proving that exhilarating performance and refined elegance could coexist seamlessly. Its long-distance capability, combined with its undeniable curb appeal, cemented its place among the elite.
Audi R8 V10 Plus (September 2015): A true supercar designed to be driven every day, the Audi R8 V10 Plus was a revelation. Its naturally aspirated V10 engine, shared with Lamborghini, delivered spine-tingling acceleration and an intoxicating soundtrack. The quattro all-wheel-drive system provided exceptional grip and confidence in all conditions, while the lightweight construction contributed to its agility and responsiveness. The R8’s cabin was a testament to Audi’s renowned interior design, offering a driver-focused cockpit with premium materials and intuitive technology. It was a supercar that didn’t demand compromises, making it an incredibly desirable and attainable dream machine for many performance car enthusiasts.
Bentley Continental GT (November 2017): The third-generation Bentley Continental GT arrived with a bolder stance and even greater levels of luxury and performance. Powered by the potent W12 engine, it offered effortless acceleration and a ride quality that bordered on magical, effortlessly absorbing road imperfections. The interior was a showcase of Bentley’s unparalleled craftsmanship, featuring exquisite wood veneers, hand-stitched leather, and a host of innovative technologies. The Continental GT remained the benchmark for ultra-luxury grand touring, offering a peerless combination of speed, comfort, and opulence for those seeking the absolute best in luxury car models.
BMW 3 Series (January 2019 – G20 Generation): The BMW 3 Series has long been the yardstick by which sporting saloons are measured, and the G20 generation cemented that legacy. It recaptured the dynamic purity of earlier models, offering razor-sharp handling, responsive steering, and a choice of potent yet efficient engines. The interior was a sophisticated blend of premium materials and cutting-edge technology, with an emphasis on driver engagement. The 3 Series proved that practicality and driving pleasure could indeed go hand-in-hand, making it a compelling choice for those who demand both. Its enduring appeal is a testament to its balanced engineering and its status as a benchmark sports sedan.
BMW M3 Competition (November 2021): The M3 Competition pushed the boundaries of performance for a road-legal saloon. Its ferocious twin-turbocharged inline-six engine delivered immense power and torque, while the chassis was honed for track-day capability without sacrificing everyday usability. The aggressive styling hinted at its formidable performance, and the interior was a blend of sporty ergonomics and premium appointments. This was a car that inspired awe and demanded respect, a true icon for high-performance sedans.
Ferrari 488 GTB (May 2016): The Ferrari 488 GTB was a masterclass in mid-engined supercar engineering. Its twin-turbocharged V8 engine was a powerhouse of performance, delivering blistering acceleration and a thrilling soundtrack. The chassis was impeccably balanced, offering razor-sharp handling and exquisite feedback to the driver. The 488 GTB represented the pinnacle of Ferrari’s road-going sports cars, a machine that appealed to the senses and ignited the passion of driving enthusiasts. For track day cars that also offer road usability, it was unparalleled.
Ferrari SF90 Stradale (December 2020): The SF90 Stradale marked a new era for Ferrari, combining a potent V8 engine with a sophisticated hybrid powertrain. This technological tour de force delivered staggering performance, with acceleration figures that bordered on hypercar territory. The advanced aerodynamics and chassis tuning ensured it remained agile and engaging, despite its complex powertrain. The SF90 Stradale showcased Ferrari’s commitment to innovation and its vision for the future of supercars. It was a bold statement about electrification in the exotic car market.
Ford Focus ST (June 2019): The Ford Focus ST continued the tradition of offering an exhilarating hot hatch experience at an accessible price point. It combined potent turbocharged power with sharp handling and a playful chassis that encouraged spirited driving. The interior offered a good balance of sportiness and everyday practicality, making it a versatile performer. The Focus ST proved that affordable performance cars could still deliver immense driving pleasure, a testament to Ford’s expertise in hot hatch models.
Honda Civic Type R (January 2018): The FK8 generation Honda Civic Type R was a revelation, a front-wheel-drive car that defied expectations with its incredible grip, agile handling, and immense power. Its turbocharged VTEC engine delivered thrilling acceleration, while the chassis was tuned for maximum performance on both road and track. The aggressive styling and functional aerodynamic enhancements underscored its track-focused nature. The Civic Type R solidified its position as a legend in the performance hatchback segment.
Jaguar F-Type SVR (June 2017): The F-Type SVR was the ultimate expression of Jaguar’s sporting pedigree. With its supercharged V8 engine producing prodigious power, and a chassis honed for maximum agility and stability, it offered a truly exhilarating driving experience. The aggressive styling, coupled with the roaring exhaust note, made it a car that demanded attention. The F-Type SVR was a thrilling blend of raw power and sophisticated handling, a testament to Jaguar’s engineering prowess in sports car performance.
Lamborghini Aventador SVJ (October 2018): The Aventador SVJ was the ultimate, track-focused iteration of Lamborghini’s V12 supercar. Its naturally aspirated engine produced an awe-inspiring sound and colossal power, while its advanced aerodynamics and active suspension system maximized grip and downforce. The SVJ was a raw, unadulterated supercar experience, designed for those who crave extreme performance and an unforgettable driving sensation. It was a pinnacle of V12 supercar technology.
McLaren 720S (April 2017): The McLaren 720S was a game-changer in the supercar world. Its innovative carbon fiber construction, potent twin-turbocharged V8 engine, and revolutionary Proactive Chassis Control II system delivered astonishing performance, agility, and ride comfort. The dihedral doors and striking aerodynamic design made it an instant icon. The 720S redefined what was possible in terms of speed, handling, and driver engagement, setting a new benchmark for supercar innovation.
Mercedes-AMG GT R (December 2017): Dubbed the “Beast of the Green Hell,” the AMG GT R was a formidable track-focused machine built for extreme performance. Its thunderous twin-turbocharged V8 engine, combined with a sophisticated chassis and active aerodynamics, delivered blistering pace and exceptional handling. The aggressive styling and purposeful interior underscored its performance credentials. The GT R was a testament to Mercedes-AMG’s dedication to creating uncompromisingly fast and engaging vehicles, a top contender for track-ready sports cars.
Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 (October 2019): The 718 Cayman GT4 proved that even with the transition to turbocharged engines in the standard range, Porsche could still deliver a sublime naturally aspirated driving experience. Its motorsport-derived flat-six engine, combined with a meticulously tuned chassis, offered exceptional feedback and engagement. The manual gearbox option further enhanced its appeal to purists. The GT4 was a driver’s car in the truest sense, a highly sought-after model for enthusiast cars.
Porsche 911 (992 Generation) Carrera S (February 2020): The latest generation of the iconic Porsche 911 continued its reign as the definitive sports car. The Carrera S, with its potent twin-turbocharged flat-six engine and the latest iteration of Porsche’s renowned chassis and drivetrain technology, offered an unparalleled blend of performance, agility, and everyday usability. The interior was a sophisticated evolution, balancing modern technology with classic 911 ergonomics. It remained the ultimate benchmark for all-wheel-drive sports cars and a significant player in the high-performance car market.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S (January 2020): The Porsche Taycan Turbo S marked Porsche’s bold entry into the electric vehicle space, and it was nothing short of spectacular. This all-electric saloon delivered blistering acceleration, supercar-rivaling performance, and the unmistakable dynamic DNA of a Porsche. The advanced battery technology and charging infrastructure ensured it was a practical proposition for electric sports car enthusiasts. The Taycan Turbo S proved that electric performance could be as thrilling and engaging as its gasoline-powered counterparts, a true leader in EV performance.
Range Rover (October 2021): The latest Range Rover redefined luxury and capability in the SUV segment. It offered an opulent and serenely quiet cabin, an incredibly comfortable ride, and formidable off-road prowess. The refined powertrain options provided effortless performance, while the cutting-edge technology ensured a seamless and connected driving experience. This wasn’t just an SUV; it was a statement of ultimate luxury and go-anywhere ability, a benchmark for luxury SUVs.
Rolls-Royce Cullinan (May 2019): The Cullinan, Rolls-Royce’s first foray into the SUV market, was an unapologetic embrace of ultra-luxury and bespoke craftsmanship. It offered an unparalleled sense of occasion, with a sumptuously appointed cabin, a supremely comfortable ride, and the effortless power of its V12 engine. The Cullinan was designed to transport its occupants in the utmost comfort and style, regardless of terrain, cementing its status as a true ultra-luxury SUV.
Skoda Octavia vRS (November 2020): The Skoda Octavia vRS continued its reputation as a hugely capable and versatile performance car. Offering a potent turbocharged engine, sharp handling, and an enormous amount of practicality thanks to its cavernous boot, it provided exceptional value for money. The interior was well-built and feature-rich, making it an ideal choice for families who didn’t want to compromise on driving dynamics. It remained a strong contender in the performance estate car category.
Toyota GR Yaris (March 2021): The GR Yaris was a surprise sensation, a rally-bred hot hatch developed with the input of WRC champions. Its unique three-door body, potent turbocharged engine, and clever all-wheel-drive system delivered an extraordinary level of grip and performance. The GR Yaris was a pure driver’s machine, built for maximum fun on both road and track, a true icon for all-wheel-drive hot hatches and a must-have for enthusiast car buyers.
Volvo XC40 Recharge (September 2021): The Volvo XC40 Recharge represented a stylish and practical entry into the electric SUV market. It offered a well-designed and comfortable interior, impressive performance from its electric powertrain, and the comprehensive safety suite that Volvo is renowned for. The XC40 Recharge proved that electric vehicles could be both desirable and family-friendly, a significant step forward for electric SUV models and a key player in the sustainable vehicle movement.
The Unseen Factors: What Sets Them Apart
Beyond the quantifiable metrics of horsepower, acceleration, and braking distances, these twenty-one vehicles share a common thread: an intangible quality that elevates them beyond mere transportation. It’s the way they make the driver feel, the connection they forge between human and machine. It’s the confidence they inspire, the sense of occasion they create, and the sheer delight they elicit with every mile. This often comes down to meticulous engineering, an unwavering attention to detail, and a deep understanding of what truly constitutes a rewarding driving experience.
For instance, the steering feel in a top-tier sports car isn’t just about pointing the car where you want it to go; it’s about communicating the nuances of the road surface, the grip levels, and the subtle shifts in weight transfer. Similarly, the ride quality in a luxury grand tourer isn’t just about isolating occupants from bumps; it’s about providing a serene and unflustered progress that allows for conversation and relaxation. The braking systems in performance cars need to not only stop the vehicle effectively but also inspire absolute confidence, even under extreme duress. These are the elements that our experienced testers keenly observe and rigorously evaluate, recognizing them as hallmarks of true automotive excellence.
The Future of Automotive Excellence: Trends to Watch
Looking ahead, the automotive landscape is undergoing a rapid transformation, driven by electrification, advanced driver-assistance systems, and an ever-increasing focus on sustainability. The vehicles that will earn five-star ratings in the coming years will likely continue to push the boundaries in these areas. We anticipate seeing more sophisticated battery technology, faster charging capabilities, and even more integrated autonomous driving features. The lines between traditional vehicle segments will continue to blur, with electric SUVs offering supercar-like performance and electric sedans providing unprecedented levels of utility.
The demand for vehicles that offer a compelling blend of performance, efficiency, and advanced technology will only grow. We will see a greater emphasis on sustainable materials and manufacturing processes, as consumers become increasingly conscious of their environmental footprint. Furthermore, the personalization and customization options available to buyers will likely expand, allowing for a more bespoke ownership experience. The pursuit of the perfect driving experience remains at the heart of automotive innovation, and we are excited to witness the evolution of these exceptional machines. The journey towards future mobility is an exciting one, and Autocar will be at the forefront, testing and evaluating the next generation of cars.
Your Next Step in Automotive Discovery
This journey through a decade of automotive perfection has been an exploration of the finest machines on four wheels. Whether your passion lies in blistering performance, opulent luxury, or the perfect blend of both, these twenty-one vehicles represent the very best of what the past ten years have offered.
If you’re inspired to experience automotive excellence firsthand, we encourage you to explore these models further. Consider visiting your local dealership to arrange a test drive, or delve deeper into our comprehensive reviews for an even more in-depth understanding of what makes these cars truly special. The pursuit of the perfect drive is a continuous journey, and Autocar is here to guide you every step of the way. Contact a local dealer or request a brochure for your dream car today, and begin your own chapter in automotive history.
