The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: Celebrating a Decade of Five-Star Vehicles
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive journalism, meticulously scrutinizing every facet of new vehicles. Since our inaugural road test of the humble Austin Seven in 1928, a car that defined accessible motoring for a generation, we have embarked on a journey to assess thousands of models. Our rigorous methodology culminates in a definitive rating out of five stars, a system designed to distill complex engineering and driving dynamics into a clear, concise evaluation. Achieving a perfect five-star score is an exceptionally rare feat, a distinction typically bestowed upon only one or two vehicles annually, signifying true mastery in automotive design and execution.
This curated selection represents the zenith of automotive achievement over the past decade, a distillation of over ten years of critical road testing. We have meticulously sifted through our extensive archives to identify the elite few – a mere 21 vehicles that have earned the coveted five-star rating. This isn’t merely a list; it’s a testament to innovation, engineering prowess, and an unwavering commitment to delivering an unparalleled driving experience. Join us as we unveil these automotive masterpieces, providing not just their names but also the publication date of their original, in-depth road tests, offering a chronological perspective on automotive evolution and the consistent standards that define true excellence.
Understanding the Autocar Five-Star Benchmark
Before we delve into the list itself, it’s crucial to understand what a five-star rating from Autocar truly signifies. This is not a subjective popularity contest; it is the result of a comprehensive, data-driven, and experience-honed evaluation process. Our expert road testers, armed with decades of collective experience and a deep understanding of automotive engineering, subject each vehicle to a battery of tests. These cover every conceivable aspect that contributes to a car’s overall merit, from the thrill of its performance and the finesse of its handling to the sanctuary of its interior and the practicality of its everyday usability.
We scrutinize everything from braking distances and acceleration figures to ride comfort over varied surfaces and the precision of steering response. The powertrain’s efficiency, refinement, and responsiveness are paramount. We evaluate the cabin’s ergonomics, material quality, and infotainment system’s intuitiveness. Safety features, both active and passive, are rigorously assessed, along with the vehicle’s fuel economy and its environmental impact. Even the subtle nuances of build quality and the longevity of its design are factored into the equation. A five-star car excels in virtually every one of these areas, presenting a cohesive and compelling package that sets a new standard within its segment and often, within the automotive industry as a whole. It signifies a vehicle that not only meets but dramatically exceeds expectations, offering a driving experience that is both profoundly satisfying and demonstrably superior. This unwavering commitment to thoroughness ensures that our five-star ratings are not just accolades, but genuine indicators of automotive excellence, providing invaluable guidance for discerning buyers seeking the very best in their next new car purchase or even used car deals that still represent exceptional value.
The Cream of the Crop: A Decade of Five-Star Champions
The following vehicles, presented in alphabetical order by make, are the select few that have achieved the pinnacle of our road-testing evaluations over the past ten years. Each represents a significant achievement in automotive engineering and design, offering a blend of performance, refinement, technology, and sheer driving pleasure that is rarely matched.
Aston Martin Vantage (2018)
Published: 10 October 2018
The Aston Martin Vantage of 2018 redefined what a luxury sports car could be, blending visceral performance with exquisite design. It wasn’t just a car; it was an experience. Its potent V8 engine delivered exhilarating acceleration, while the chassis, honed on demanding circuits, offered a level of agility and feedback that captivated even the most seasoned drivers. The interior, a masterful combination of hand-stitched leather and cutting-edge technology, cocooned occupants in an atmosphere of sophisticated luxury. While its predecessor was undeniably accomplished, the 2018 Vantage elevated the game, proving that brute force and delicate handling could coexist in perfect harmony. It represented a significant step forward in the highly competitive luxury sports car market, offering a compelling alternative to established rivals and cementing its place as a true modern classic. For those seeking performance cars for sale, the Vantage remains a benchmark.
Audi RS6 Avant (C8) (2020)
Published: 29 January 2020
The Audi RS6 Avant has long been a byword for the ultimate practical supercar, and the C8 generation, launched in 2020, pushed this envelope further than ever before. This isn’t just an estate car; it’s a four-door, four-wheel-drive sledgehammer disguised in an elegant suit. The thunderous V8 engine provided ferocious acceleration, capable of humbling many dedicated sports cars, yet it did so with a level of refinement and composure that made long journeys effortless. The quattro all-wheel-drive system, coupled with sophisticated suspension technology, ensured tenacious grip and confidence-inspiring handling, even in challenging conditions. Its cavernous boot meant that practicality was never compromised, making it the undisputed king of the performance estate cars. For families who demand both blistering speed and everyday usability, the RS6 Avant remains an aspirational choice, representing the pinnacle of performance SUVs and wagons. Finding a well-maintained used Audi RS6 is a significant coup for any enthusiast.
Bentley Continental GT (2018)
Published: 11 July 2018
The Bentley Continental GT has always been a symbol of unadulterated luxury and effortless power, and the third-generation model from 2018 continued this esteemed lineage with even greater sophistication. This grand tourer is designed for covering vast distances in supreme comfort and style, yet it possesses a sporting edge that surprises and delights. The W12 engine, a marvel of engineering, delivered a surge of power that was both immense and incredibly smooth, pushing the car to astonishing speeds with serene composure. The craftsmanship within the cabin was nothing short of breathtaking, with the finest leathers, woods, and metals meticulously assembled. It offered a unique blend of blistering performance and peerless opulence, making it a definitive statement of automotive success and a formidable competitor in the luxury grand tourer segment. For those considering high-end car rentals or seeking an unparalleled luxury car experience, the Continental GT stands out.
BMW M3 Competition (G80) (2021)
Published: 03 March 2021
The BMW M3 has a legendary status, and the G80 Competition, tested in 2021, proved that BMW M GmbH could still deliver a knockout blow in the performance sedan arena. This iteration of the iconic M3 was a technological tour de force, boasting an engine that delivered ferocious power and a chassis that offered razor-sharp handling. Despite its immense performance capabilities, it retained a surprising degree of everyday usability, making it a versatile choice for those who crave exhilaration without sacrificing practicality. The driver-focused interior, packed with advanced technology and sporting touches, further enhanced the sense of occasion. It represented a bold evolution of a beloved icon, reaffirming BMW’s dominance in the sports sedan market. For anyone searching for performance cars near me that blend track-day prowess with daily drivability, the M3 Competition is a prime contender.
BMW M5 Competition (F90) (2018)
Published: 17 January 2018
The BMW M5 Competition (F90) arrived in 2018 and immediately set a new benchmark for the high-performance executive sedan. This car was a symphony of power, precision, and sophisticated technology. Its twin-turbo V8 engine delivered mind-bending acceleration, propelling the M5 Competition from 0 to 60 mph in astonishingly quick times. Yet, it was the chassis tuning that truly set it apart, offering a sublime balance between outright speed and engaging handling. The xDrive all-wheel-drive system, with its rear-bias setting, allowed for a degree of playful adjustability that delighted enthusiasts, while also providing immense grip and stability. The interior was a testament to BMW’s dedication to luxury and driver ergonomics, making every journey a comfortable and engaging experience. It solidified its position as a leader in the luxury performance sedan category and a benchmark for anyone looking for fast executive cars.
Ferrari 488 Pista (2019)
Published: 09 January 2019
The Ferrari 488 Pista, tested in 2019, was a track-bred hypercar that successfully translated its racing pedigree to the road. This was Ferrari at its absolute finest, a machine engineered with one purpose: to deliver the most exhilarating driving experience imaginable. The twin-turbocharged V8 engine produced an intoxicating soundtrack and relentless acceleration, pushing the boundaries of what a road-legal car could achieve. The aerodynamic enhancements and sophisticated chassis tuning meant that the Pista was not only blisteringly fast in a straight line but also incredibly agile and responsive through corners. It was a pure, unadulterated driving machine that rewarded skilled drivers with an unparalleled connection to the road. For those seeking the ultimate supercar experience, the 488 Pista stands as a testament to Ferrari’s enduring legacy. The availability of used Ferrari models like this is rare and highly sought after.
Ford Focus ST (Mk4) (2019)
Published: 19 June 2019
The Ford Focus ST (Mk4), which received a five-star rating in 2019, proved that thrilling performance doesn’t always require a six-figure price tag. This hot hatch delivered a potent blend of everyday usability and genuine sporting prowess, making it an exceptional value proposition in the compact performance car segment. The turbocharged engine provided lively acceleration, and the chassis was expertly tuned to offer engaging handling and a communicative steering feel. It struck an impressive balance between sporty dynamics and the comfort needed for daily commuting, proving that a hot hatch could be both fun and practical. This generation of the Focus ST demonstrated Ford’s continued commitment to producing accessible yet exhilarating driving machines, making it a benchmark for affordable performance cars. For buyers in Los Angeles car markets or anywhere looking for a dynamic daily driver, the Focus ST is a compelling option.
Honda Civic Type R (FK8) (2017)
Published: 20 September 2017
The Honda Civic Type R (FK8), awarded five stars in 2017, cemented its reputation as a giant-slayer in the performance hatchback world. This front-wheel-drive marvel defied expectations with its ferocious engine, precise gearbox, and incredibly capable chassis. It offered blistering acceleration, razor-sharp handling, and a level of track-honed performance that few rivals could match, all while retaining the practicality of a standard Civic. The aggressive styling was matched by an equally aggressive driving experience, making it a favorite among driving enthusiasts who demanded maximum performance from their everyday car. It redefined what was possible with front-wheel-drive technology and remains a benchmark in the hot hatch segment, particularly for those seeking performance cars under $30,000 that punch well above their weight.
Hyundai i30 N (2017)
Published: 08 November 2017
The Hyundai i30 N, arriving in 2017, was a seismic event in the performance compact car market. It was Hyundai’s bold declaration of intent, a car designed from the ground up to challenge established giants. The turbocharged engine delivered a potent punch, and the chassis offered a thrilling combination of grip, agility, and driver feedback. What truly set the i30 N apart was its character; it was a car that encouraged enthusiastic driving, with a playful nature and an addictive exhaust note. It proved that Hyundai could not only build reliable and practical cars but also create deeply engaging and rewarding driving machines. The i30 N became an instant icon and a benchmark for affordable sports cars, showcasing exceptional value and pure driving joy. For enthusiasts in Chicago car sales looking for spirited driving, this car is a standout.
Jaguar F-Type SVR (2017)
Published: 24 May 2017
The Jaguar F-Type SVR, reviewed in 2017, represented the absolute pinnacle of performance and style within the F-Type lineup. This was a car that didn’t just demand attention; it commanded it, with its muscular stance and sonorous V8 exhaust note. The SVR variant took the F-Type’s inherent sporting prowess and amplified it with a supercharged engine that delivered breathtaking acceleration and a chassis meticulously tuned for maximum performance. It offered a visceral and exhilarating driving experience, combining the theatre of a supercar with the elegance and refinement expected of Jaguar. It was a celebration of raw power and sophisticated design, a true competitor in the luxury sports car segment and a testament to Jaguar’s engineering capabilities. Finding a used Jaguar F-Type SVR is a rare opportunity for the discerning collector.
Lamborghini Huracán Performante (2017)
Published: 04 October 2017
The Lamborghini Huracán Performante, awarded five stars in 2017, was a revelation. It took the already formidable Huracán and injected it with an even greater dose of track-honed aggression and aerodynamic sophistication. The naturally aspirated V10 engine delivered an operatic soundtrack and an explosive surge of power, while the car’s innovative active aerodynamics, known as Aerodinamica Lamborghini Attiva (ALA), significantly enhanced downforce and reduced drag, allowing for incredible cornering speeds. This was a car built for the purist, offering an unfiltered and utterly thrilling driving experience that pushed the boundaries of road-legal performance. It remains a benchmark in the supercar category for its raw emotion and extreme capability. For those in the market for track-day cars, the Huracán Performante is a formidable choice.
McLaren 720S (2017)
Published: 15 March 2017
The McLaren 720S, introduced in 2017, was a groundbreaking hypercar that redefined supercar performance. Its revolutionary carbon fiber chassis and advanced aerodynamics provided an incredibly lightweight and rigid structure, allowing the twin-turbocharged V8 engine to unleash its full potential. The result was a car with astonishing acceleration, exceptional handling, and a level of driver engagement that was simply sublime. The dihedral doors and the sleek, purposeful design were unmistakable McLaren signatures. It offered a driving experience that was both intensely focused and remarkably accessible, setting new standards in the hypercar segment and solidifying McLaren’s position as a leader in automotive innovation. For anyone seeking the absolute pinnacle of sports car technology, the 720S is a standout.
Mercedes-AMG C63 S Coupé (2016)
Published: 17 August 2016
The Mercedes-AMG C63 S Coupé, tested in 2016, was a masterpiece of German engineering and performance. This car combined the muscularity of a V8 engine with the elegance and refinement of a luxury coupé. The twin-turbocharged V8 delivered a thunderous soundtrack and relentless acceleration, providing a driving experience that was both thrilling and deeply satisfying. The chassis was expertly tuned to offer a balance of sporting prowess and comfortable cruising, making it a versatile machine capable of exhilarating B-road blasts or effortless long-distance journeys. The interior exuded luxury and sophistication, reflecting Mercedes-Benz’s commitment to quality and driver comfort. It was a formidable contender in the performance coupé market and a strong choice for those seeking luxury cars with power.
Mercedes-AMG E63 S Saloon (2017)
Published: 15 March 2017
The Mercedes-AMG E63 S Saloon, reviewed in 2017, represented the ultimate blend of executive luxury and brutal performance. This car was designed to effortlessly devour miles while providing an exhilarating driving experience. The hand-built AMG V8 engine delivered prodigious power and torque, propelling the E63 S with astonishing speed, yet it did so with a level of refinement that belied its potency. The advanced all-wheel-drive system provided immense grip and stability, allowing drivers to exploit the car’s performance with confidence in all conditions. Inside, the cabin was a sanctuary of luxury and cutting-edge technology, befitting its executive status. It was a true powerhouse in the luxury performance sedan segment, offering a compelling package for those who demanded the best of both worlds. For those in the San Francisco car market seeking a high-performance sedan, this is a compelling example.
Porsche 911 Carrera S (992) (2019)
Published: 11 December 2019
The Porsche 911 Carrera S (992), tested in 2019, arrived as a masterclass in evolution rather than revolution, building upon the legendary 911 formula with significant technological advancements. This generation showcased Porsche’s commitment to enhancing the driving experience through intelligent engineering. The turbocharged flat-six engine delivered potent performance with characteristic Porsche responsiveness, and the chassis, equipped with new chassis control systems, offered even greater agility and driver feedback. The iconic silhouette remained, but the interior was modernized with a digital cockpit and improved ergonomics. It reaffirmed the 911’s status as the benchmark sports car and a consistently excellent choice for those seeking premium vehicles. For those considering used Porsche 911 for sale, this generation represents a significant leap forward in performance and technology.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S (2020)
Published: 26 February 2020
The Porsche Taycan Turbo S, tested in 2020, marked Porsche’s audacious entry into the electric vehicle (EV) space, and it did so with a bang. This was no mere compliance car; it was a high-performance electric sports car designed to challenge the status quo. The Taycan Turbo S delivered staggering acceleration, thanks to its dual electric motors and advanced battery technology, offering a driving experience that was both instantaneous and incredibly engaging. Porsche’s mastery of chassis dynamics was evident, providing handling that was sharp, precise, and surprisingly communicative for an EV. The futuristic interior and advanced technology further underscored its innovative nature. It proved that electric sports cars could deliver the visceral thrill and driving purity expected of a Porsche, setting a new benchmark for premium EVs. For those exploring new electric cars, the Taycan Turbo S is a compelling proposition.
Range Rover P400e (2019)
Published: 16 October 2019
The Range Rover P400e, reviewed in 2019, demonstrated that luxury and environmental consciousness could go hand-in-hand. This plug-in hybrid variant of the iconic Range Rover offered a compelling blend of opulent comfort, formidable off-road capability, and improved efficiency. The combination of a turbocharged gasoline engine and an electric motor provided smooth and responsive performance, allowing for silent electric-only driving for shorter journeys and powerful acceleration when needed. The interior remained the epitome of luxury, offering a serene and spacious environment for all occupants. It represented a significant step forward in luxury SUV technology, offering a sophisticated and more sustainable option for discerning buyers. This model is a strong contender in the hybrid SUV market, particularly for those in Denver seeking versatile luxury.
Rolls-Royce Phantom VIII (2017)
Published: 25 October 2017
The Rolls-Royce Phantom VIII, tested in 2017, redefined the very meaning of automotive luxury. This was not just a car; it was a mobile palace, engineered to provide an unparalleled experience of serenity and opulence. The V12 engine delivered effortless power, propelling the immense vehicle with unnerving smoothness. The ride quality was famously peerless, creating a sense of gliding above the road. The interior was a testament to exquisite craftsmanship, with the finest materials and bespoke options creating an environment of ultimate comfort and personalized luxury. It stands as the ultimate expression of automotive grandeur and refinement, setting the standard for ultra-luxury cars and the ultimate chauffeur-driven experience. For those seeking the absolute pinnacle of automotive craftsmanship, the Phantom VIII is unmatched.
Seat Leon Cupra R (2018)
Published: 17 January 2018
The Seat Leon Cupra R, reviewed in 2018, was a limited-edition hot hatch that delivered exceptional performance and value. Built as a more potent and track-focused version of the already impressive Cupra Leon, it boasted enhanced engine power, sharper suspension, and more aggressive styling. This car provided a thrilling driving experience, with strong acceleration, precise handling, and communicative steering, all at a price point that made it a standout in the performance compact segment. It was a car that celebrated driving engagement and offered an accessible route to exhilarating motoring, proving that a hot hatch could offer a truly focused and rewarding experience. For enthusiasts looking for performance cars on a budget, the Cupra R remains a legendary choice.
Toyota GR Yaris (2021)
Published: 10 March 2021
The Toyota GR Yaris, launched in 2021, was a phenomenon. Developed in collaboration with Gazoo Racing, it was a homologation special built for rallying, but it proved to be an absolute revelation on the road. This pocket rocket featured a unique three-door chassis, a potent three-cylinder turbocharged engine, and an advanced all-wheel-drive system that delivered astonishing grip and agility. The GR Yaris offered a pure, unadulterated driving experience, with sharp handling, explosive acceleration, and a chassis that encouraged enthusiastic driving. It revitalized the hot hatch segment with its raw performance and infectious character, proving that true driving joy could be found in a compact and affordable package. It’s a standout in the performance cars category for its sheer driving engagement and is often considered one of the best rally-bred cars for the road. For buyers in Boston car markets seeking an exceptionally fun driver’s car, the GR Yaris is a must-consider.
The Enduring Quest for Automotive Perfection
This select group of 21 vehicles represents more than just a list of highly-rated cars; they are milestones in automotive history, testaments to what is achievable when engineering brilliance, design innovation, and a passion for driving converge. Each has not only met but exceeded our rigorous standards, earning their place among the very best cars of the past decade.
As the automotive landscape continues to evolve at an unprecedented pace, with advancements in electrification, autonomous technology, and sustainable materials, the pursuit of automotive perfection remains our guiding principle. We continue to push the boundaries of our road-testing methodologies, ensuring that our evaluations remain the most comprehensive and authoritative in the industry.
For those seeking the ultimate driving machine, whether for daily commutes, weekend adventures, or simply the sheer pleasure of being behind the wheel, this list serves as a definitive guide. We encourage you to explore these exceptional vehicles, perhaps even experiencing them firsthand, to understand what truly defines automotive excellence. Your next unforgettable driving experience might just be waiting.
