The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Cars
For nearly a century, Autocar has been the authoritative voice in automotive journalism, rigorously evaluating vehicles to guide discerning buyers. Our commitment to comprehensive road testing began in 1928 with the humble Austin Seven, a bestseller that paved the way for countless vehicles to come under our scrutiny. Through the decades, we’ve subjected thousands of cars to our meticulous examination, assigning each a holistic score out of five. Achieving a perfect score, a rare five-star rating, is the ultimate accolade, bestowed upon a select few vehicles that truly transcend the ordinary. In this exclusive compilation, we revisit the crème de la crème – the 21 vehicles that have earned the coveted five-star rating from Autocar in the past ten years. Prepare to journey through a decade of automotive mastery, celebrating the finest engineering, design, and driving dynamics that have graced our roads.
The quest for the ultimate driving machine is a constant pursuit, a dance between innovation and the enduring pursuit of perfection. At Autocar, our road test methodology has been refined over generations, aiming to capture the essence of a vehicle’s performance, comfort, practicality, and sheer driving pleasure. When a car achieves a five-star rating, it signifies an exceptional achievement, a testament to the manufacturer’s dedication to pushing boundaries and delivering an unparalleled experience. These aren’t just cars; they are icons of automotive engineering that have set new benchmarks and redefined what’s possible. Understanding what makes these vehicles stand out is crucial for anyone looking to invest in a truly remarkable automobile, whether it’s a new luxury sedan in Chicago or a high-performance sports car in Los Angeles.
Our stringent criteria mean that a five-star rating is not easily won. It requires a harmonious blend of cutting-edge technology, flawless execution, and a visceral connection between driver and machine. In an era where electric vehicles are rapidly evolving and autonomous driving features are becoming more prevalent, the vehicles that have achieved this distinction demonstrate a remarkable ability to integrate these advancements seamlessly, while still offering the soul and engagement that enthusiasts crave. The best cars of the past decade have consistently proven their mettle across a spectrum of real-world conditions, from navigating congested urban landscapes to conquering challenging open roads.
As we delve into this curated list, you’ll notice a distinct emphasis on vehicles that offer not just performance, but also a profound sense of refinement and desirability. The luxury SUV comparison often highlights vehicles that balance opulence with capability, and our five-star selections certainly exemplify this. Similarly, for those seeking exhilarating speed and precision, the sports car reviews within this timeframe have identified machines that deliver on every front, offering unparalleled handling and exhilarating acceleration. The electric vehicle tests have also become increasingly significant, with manufacturers proving that zero-emission motoring can be as thrilling and luxurious as its internal combustion counterparts.
The Elite 21: A Decade of Automotive Perfection
The following vehicles, listed in alphabetical order, represent the zenith of automotive engineering and design as judged by Autocar’s expert road testers over the past ten years. Each has been subjected to our most rigorous assessment, emerging as a clear leader in its respective segment and setting a standard for others to follow.
Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio (Published: March 22, 2017)
The Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio burst onto the scene as a formidable challenger to established German performance sedans, and it didn’t just compete; it conquered. Its Ferrari-derived twin-turbocharged V6 engine is a masterpiece of engineering, delivering a potent 503bhp and an intoxicating soundtrack. But the Quadrifoglio is more than just raw power. Its chassis is a work of art, offering an exquisite balance of agility and composure. The steering is razor-sharp, the brakes are immense, and the adaptive suspension masterfully controls body roll without sacrificing ride comfort. Inside, the cabin blends sporty intentions with Italian flair, featuring supportive carbon-fiber bucket seats and high-quality materials. For enthusiasts, the Giulia Quadrifoglio is a return to form for Alfa Romeo, a car that engages the senses and delivers a driving experience that is both exhilarating and deeply satisfying. Its ability to deliver such a pure driving connection in a practical sedan package is what truly sets it apart. For those searching for the ultimate performance sedan reviews, the Giulia Quadrifoglio remains a benchmark.
Aston Martin DB11 (Published: October 12, 2016)
Aston Martin has always excelled at crafting grand tourers that are as beautiful as they are potent, and the DB11 is perhaps the pinnacle of this philosophy. Replacing the iconic DB9, the DB11 introduced a new era for the brand, boasting a more advanced platform and a potent new twin-turbocharged 5.2-liter V12 engine. The result is a car that effortlessly blends blistering performance with refined cruising ability. The exterior design is a breathtaking evolution of Aston Martin’s signature styling, with elegant lines and a muscular stance. Inside, the cabin is a sanctuary of luxury, featuring exquisite craftsmanship, premium leather, and the latest infotainment technology. The ride is supple yet controlled, allowing for relaxed long-distance journeys, while the immense power of the V12 ensures effortless acceleration and a thrilling soundtrack. The DB11 isn’t just a car; it’s a statement of intent, a sophisticated companion for the discerning driver who appreciates both style and substance. It’s a prime example of a luxury grand tourer test that solidified its position at the top.
Audi R8 V10 Plus (Published: October 26, 2016)
The Audi R8 has always been a car that punches above its weight, offering supercar performance in a package that is surprisingly usable for everyday driving. The V10 Plus, in particular, is a sensational machine. Its naturally aspirated 5.2-liter V10 engine, shared with Lamborghini, produces an ear-splitting roar and prodigious power, propelling the R8 from 0 to 60 mph in under three seconds. Yet, the R8 remains remarkably accessible. Its quattro all-wheel-drive system provides immense grip and confidence, while the dynamic ride control offers a comfortable setting for cruising and a firm, focused setup for spirited driving. The interior is typically Audi: beautifully crafted, ergonomically sound, and packed with technology. The R8 V10 Plus represents a sweet spot in the supercar market, offering blistering performance without the extreme demands of some of its rivals, making it a compelling choice for those seeking an everyday supercar. It remains a benchmark in sports car reviews electric and gasoline, proving the enduring appeal of naturally aspirated engines.
Bentley Continental GT (Published: January 25, 2018)
The Bentley Continental GT is the epitome of a luxury grand tourer, a car that blends opulent comfort with immense power and sophisticated style. The latest generation, launched in 2018, took this formula and elevated it to new heights. Powered by a magnificent W12 twin-turbocharged engine (or a potent V8), the Continental GT offers effortless acceleration and a driving experience that is both exhilarating and incredibly refined. The exterior design is a masterful blend of classic Bentley cues and modern aggression, exuding a sense of presence and prestige. Inside, the cabin is a haven of bespoke luxury, featuring the finest leather, intricate stitching, and cutting-edge technology seamlessly integrated into the design. The ride quality is sublime, absorbing bumps and imperfections with remarkable ease, while still offering a taut and engaging feel when the driver demands it. For those who seek the ultimate in refined performance and unparalleled luxury, the Bentley Continental GT is a peerless choice, a true icon of automotive craftsmanship. Its reputation in luxury car reviews is unparalleled.
BMW M3 Competition (G80) (Published: November 10, 2021)
The BMW M3 has long been a benchmark for performance sedans, and the G80 generation, particularly the Competition variant, continues this legacy with a potent blend of power, technology, and driving dynamics. Its twin-turbocharged inline-six engine delivers a formidable 503bhp, coupled with the option of rear-wheel drive or the more potent M xDrive all-wheel-drive system. The chassis is exceptionally capable, offering sharp handling, precise steering, and impressive grip. The ride, while firm, is surprisingly compliant for a performance car, especially in its comfort settings. Inside, the M3 Competition boasts a driver-focused cockpit with supportive M sport seats, high-quality materials, and BMW’s latest iDrive infotainment system. It’s a car that demands to be driven, rewarding its occupants with a thrilling and engaging experience, whether on a track day or a spirited drive through winding country roads. The M3 Competition stands as a testament to BMW’s enduring expertise in crafting performance sedan reviews that consistently set the standard.
BMW M4 Competition (G82) (Published: November 10, 2021)
Sharing much of its mechanical prowess with its M3 sibling, the G82 BMW M4 Competition offers a similarly exhilarating driving experience in a sleeker, more coupe-like silhouette. The potent twin-turbocharged inline-six engine, renowned for its character and performance, is paired with the option of rear-wheel drive or the advanced M xDrive all-wheel-drive system. The chassis is finely tuned for maximum agility and driver feedback, providing a direct connection to the road. The adaptive M suspension ensures a balance between sporty stiffness and everyday comfort. Visually, the M4 Competition makes a bold statement with its distinctive grille and aggressive styling. The interior mirrors the M3’s driver-centric approach, offering supportive seating and a wealth of technology. For those who prioritize a dynamic driving experience wrapped in a stylish coupe body, the M4 Competition is an undeniable contender in the sports car reviews arena.
Ford Mustang Mach-E GT (Published: July 14, 2021)
The Ford Mustang Mach-E GT represents a significant evolution in the Mustang lineage, embracing electrification while retaining the spirit of performance and style associated with the iconic nameplate. The GT model, with its dual-motor all-wheel-drive setup, delivers blistering acceleration, capable of challenging many traditional sports cars. Its long-range battery offers impressive range, addressing a key concern for electric vehicle buyers. The interior is modern and spacious, featuring a large central touchscreen that controls most vehicle functions, and a comfortable, well-appointed cabin. While it may deviate from the traditional Mustang silhouette, the Mach-E GT proves that electric vehicles can be exciting, practical, and possess a sense of occasion. It’s a compelling option for those exploring electric SUV reviews with a performance focus, showcasing Ford’s commitment to the future of automotive mobility.
Honda Civic Type R (FK8) (Published: June 21, 2017)
The Honda Civic Type R has always been a darling of the hot hatch segment, and the FK8 generation cemented its status as a class leader. Its aggressive styling, complete with a prominent rear wing, hints at the performance lurking beneath. The 2.0-liter turbocharged VTEC engine delivers an impressive 306bhp, offering a surge of power that is both exhilarating and usable. The chassis is a marvel of engineering, providing exceptional grip, precise handling, and a communicative steering feel. The triple-source exhaust system contributes to a sporty, engaging sound. Inside, the cabin is practical and well-equipped, with supportive bucket seats that hug you during spirited driving. The Type R is a car that encourages you to seek out twisty roads, offering a level of driver engagement that is rare in a front-wheel-drive car, making it a standout in hot hatch reviews.
Jaguar F-Pace SVR (Published: June 12, 2019)
The Jaguar F-Pace SVR takes the luxury SUV formula and injects it with a healthy dose of supercar performance. Powered by a supercharged 5.0-liter V8 engine producing a thunderous 542bhp, the F-Pace SVR is astonishingly quick, capable of accelerating from 0 to 60 mph in just over four seconds. Yet, despite its immense power, it remains a supremely comfortable and practical SUV. The chassis has been fettled by Jaguar’s Special Vehicle Operations (SVO) team to provide impressive agility and body control, while the adaptive suspension ensures a compliant ride. The interior is a blend of luxury and sportiness, with supportive SVR-branded seats and high-quality finishes. For those seeking a potent blend of performance, luxury, and SUV versatility, the F-Pace SVR offers an intoxicating and highly accomplished package, a true standout in performance SUV reviews.
Kia EV6 GT (Published: December 7, 2022)
The Kia EV6 GT represents a bold leap forward for electric performance, showcasing Kia’s ambition and engineering prowess. This range-topping model boasts a dual-motor all-wheel-drive system delivering a staggering 577bhp, making it one of the most powerful production cars from Kia ever. The acceleration is relentless, propelling the EV6 GT from 0 to 60 mph in under 3.5 seconds. Beyond its straight-line speed, the GT variant features a bespoke performance-tuned suspension and a limited-slip differential, providing remarkable handling and agility. The striking, futuristic exterior design is matched by a modern, high-tech interior. The EV6 GT proves that electric vehicles can deliver not only efficiency and advanced technology but also an exhilarating and engaging driving experience, making it a compelling proposition in the electric performance car reviews.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO (Published: May 22, 2019)
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO is a supercar that embodies raw emotion and breathtaking performance. Its naturally aspirated V10 engine, a glorious symphony of mechanical noise, produces an exhilarating 631bhp. The all-wheel-drive system provides immense grip and confidence, allowing drivers to exploit the Huracán’s incredible capabilities with remarkable ease. The steering is sharp and direct, and the chassis is brilliantly tuned to offer a thrilling and communicative driving experience. Visually, the Huracán EVO is a masterpiece of aggressive, aerodynamic design. The interior is focused and driver-oriented, with high-quality materials and a sense of occasion. For those seeking a visceral, analog supercar experience that is both accessible and utterly thrilling, the Huracán EVO is an exceptional choice, a true icon of the supercar reviews landscape.
McLaren 720S (Published: March 15, 2017)
The McLaren 720S redefined what was possible in the supercar realm, setting new benchmarks for performance, handling, and driver engagement. Its twin-turbocharged 4.0-liter V8 engine produces a colossal 710bhp, delivering blistering acceleration and a top speed that borders on the astronomical. But the 720S is more than just straight-line speed. Its advanced aerodynamic design, lightweight construction, and sophisticated suspension system work in harmony to create a driving experience that is astonishingly agile and precise. The steering is telepathic, and the braking performance is immense. The dihedral doors and futuristic interior add to the car’s sense of occasion. The 720S is a technological tour de force, a pure driver’s car that delivers an unparalleled level of connection and exhilaration, solidifying its place in the pantheon of exotic car reviews.
Mercedes-AMG GT 4-Door Coupé (Published: March 27, 2019)
The Mercedes-AMG GT 4-Door Coupé defies easy categorization, blending the sportiness of a coupé with the practicality of a four-door sedan. Powered by AMG’s formidable 4.0-liter twin-turbocharged V8 engine, it offers breathtaking performance, with the range-topping models delivering well over 600bhp. The chassis is a masterpiece of engineering, providing a sublime balance of ride comfort and dynamic prowess. The interior is a luxurious and technologically advanced space, featuring AMG’s signature performance-oriented design and the latest infotainment systems. It’s a car that can comfortably transport passengers in opulence one moment and deliver spine-tingling performance the next, making it a unique and highly compelling proposition for those seeking a luxury performance sedan.
Mercedes-AMG GT R (Published: November 29, 2017)
The Mercedes-AMG GT R is the ultimate expression of AMG’s performance philosophy, a road-legal race car designed for maximum track performance while still being usable on the road. Its potent 4.0-liter twin-turbocharged V8 engine produces 577bhp and a relentless surge of power. The GT R features a host of track-focused enhancements, including a more aggressive aerodynamic package, a stiffer suspension setup, active rear-wheel steering, and a sophisticated traction control system with nine adjustable levels. The result is a car that offers phenomenal grip, incredible agility, and a truly raw and engaging driving experience. The interior is a blend of sportiness and luxury, with carbon-fiber accents and supportive AMG sports seats. For dedicated driving enthusiasts, the GT R is an uncompromised machine that delivers an unforgettable driving thrill, a benchmark in track day car reviews.
Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS (Published: February 16, 2022)
The Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS represents the pinnacle of the Cayman range, a track-focused machine that delivers an unadulterated driving experience. Powered by a glorious 4.0-liter naturally aspirated flat-six engine, borrowed from the 911 GT3, it produces a searing 493bhp and a captivating soundtrack. The lightweight construction, sophisticated aerodynamics, and exquisite chassis tuning combine to create a car of astonishing agility and precision. The steering is telepathic, and the feedback from the road is immense, allowing drivers to push the limits with confidence. While the ride is firm, it’s a necessary trade-off for the extraordinary performance it offers. The GT4 RS is a true driver’s car, a testament to Porsche’s enduring commitment to performance and driver engagement, making it a star in track focused sports car reviews.
Porsche 911 (992) Carrera 4S (Published: December 4, 2019)
The latest generation of the iconic Porsche 911, codenamed 992, continues to refine the legendary formula of the world’s most celebrated sports car. The Carrera 4S, with its all-wheel-drive system, offers a perfect blend of performance, everyday usability, and exquisite engineering. Its twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter flat-six engine delivers a potent 444bhp, providing effortless acceleration and a satisfyingly sporty engine note. The chassis is a masterclass in balance and composure, offering engaging handling and a ride that is both comfortable and sporty. The interior is a modern take on classic 911 design, with high-quality materials and advanced technology. The 992 Carrera 4S is a testament to Porsche’s ability to continuously improve upon perfection, a benchmark in all-wheel drive sports car reviews.
Porsche 911 GT3 (992) (Published: February 24, 2021)
The 992 generation Porsche 911 GT3 is more than just a car; it’s a purist’s dream. Its motorsport-derived 4.0-liter naturally aspirated flat-six engine, singing to an incredible 9,000 rpm, produces 503bhp and an unforgettable soundtrack. The chassis is a masterpiece of engineering, featuring double-wishbone front suspension for unparalleled steering feel and feedback, and a sophisticated rear axle. The aerodynamic package is functional and effective, generating significant downforce without compromising aesthetics. The GT3 offers an incredibly direct and engaging driving experience, allowing drivers to feel every nuance of the road. While track-focused, it remains remarkably usable for daily driving, offering a sublime blend of performance and everyday practicality, a highlight in naturally aspirated sports car reviews.
Rimac Nevera (Published: September 21, 2022)
The Rimac Nevera is a hypercar that redefines the boundaries of electric performance. This Croatian-engineered marvel boasts four independent electric motors producing a staggering 1,914bhp, enabling it to achieve speeds that defy belief, including a sub-two-second 0-60 mph sprint. The Nevera is not just about raw power; it’s also a technological tour de force, featuring an advanced battery management system, sophisticated aerodynamics, and a lightweight carbon-fiber monocoque. The interior is a futuristic blend of luxury and cutting-edge technology. The Nevera proves that electric hypercars can be not only incredibly fast but also beautifully engineered and desirable, setting a new standard for electric hypercar reviews and the future of automotive performance.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (Published: July 17, 2019)
The Tesla Model 3 Performance has proven itself to be a game-changer in the electric vehicle segment, offering blistering acceleration and impressive handling at a relatively accessible price point. Its dual-motor all-wheel-drive system delivers a powerful punch, enabling 0-60 mph in under three seconds. Beyond its straight-line speed, the Performance model features upgraded brakes, a lowered suspension, and performance tires, enhancing its dynamic capabilities. The minimalist interior is dominated by a large central touchscreen, which controls most vehicle functions, and offers a spacious and modern environment. The Model 3 Performance makes a compelling case for electric motoring, proving that performance and practicality can coexist seamlessly, and has become a benchmark in electric sedan reviews.
Tesla Model S Plaid (Published: June 16, 2021)
The Tesla Model S Plaid represents the absolute pinnacle of electric performance from Tesla, pushing the boundaries of what is considered possible for an electric sedan. With its tri-motor all-wheel-drive setup, it boasts an astonishing 1,020bhp and a mind-bending 0-60 mph time of just 1.99 seconds (with rollout subtracted). The acceleration is utterly relentless, offering a sensation unlike anything else on four wheels. Beyond its extreme straight-line speed, the Plaid also features revised suspension and braking systems to cope with the immense power. The interior retains Tesla’s minimalist aesthetic, with a yoke-style steering wheel and a large central touchscreen. The Model S Plaid is a technological marvel, a statement of intent from Tesla, and a formidable competitor in the high-performance electric car reviews.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk8) (Published: February 5, 2020)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI has long been the benchmark for the hot hatch segment, and the Mk8 generation continues this tradition with a refined and engaging driving experience. While its power output might not match some rivals, its inherent balance, sharp handling, and everyday usability make it a perennial favorite. The 2.0-liter turbocharged engine delivers spirited performance, and the chassis offers a superb blend of agility and comfort. The interior is modern and packed with technology, though some of the touch-sensitive controls have proven to be a point of contention for traditionalists. Nevertheless, the Golf GTI remains an icon, offering a compelling combination of practicality, performance, and affordability that makes it a standout in compact car reviews for those seeking a pure driving pleasure.
The Enduring Appeal of Automotive Excellence
This collection of 21 vehicles represents a decade of automotive brilliance, each car a testament to innovation, engineering prowess, and an unwavering commitment to delivering an exceptional driving experience. These are not just modes of transportation; they are machines that stir the soul, ignite the senses, and provide unparalleled joy behind the wheel. Whether you’re in the market for a new sports car for sale in Miami or contemplating an electric SUV lease in Seattle, understanding the qualities that elevate these vehicles to five-star status offers invaluable insight into what truly constitutes automotive excellence in today’s competitive landscape.
As the automotive industry continues its rapid evolution, driven by advancements in electrification, connectivity, and autonomous technology, the pursuit of these exceptional vehicles will undoubtedly continue. The lessons learned from these 21 champions will shape the future of car design and performance, ensuring that the thrill of driving, the beauty of design, and the pursuit of ultimate excellence remain at the forefront of automotive innovation.
Discovering your next dream car is an exciting journey. Explore our in-depth reviews, compare models, and find the vehicle that perfectly aligns with your aspirations and needs. The road to automotive perfection awaits.
