The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Machines
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive journalism, meticulously dissecting and evaluating vehicles with unparalleled rigor. Since our inaugural road test of the humble yet wildly popular Austin Seven back in 1928, our commitment has remained unwavering: to provide consumers with the most comprehensive, trustworthy, and insightful assessments available. Over the decades, this dedication has translated into thousands of in-depth road tests, each culminating in a definitive rating out of five stars. Achieving a perfect score is an exceedingly rare feat, a distinction bestowed upon only a select handful of vehicles each year, typically one or two at most, signifying true mastery in automotive engineering and design.
This special feature delves into the crème de la crème of the past decade, a curated collection of the extraordinary few that have earned our coveted five-star rating. From the meticulous engineering of luxury sedans to the groundbreaking innovation of electric pioneers, these 21 vehicles represent the zenith of automotive achievement in the last ten years. We invite you to join us on this journey through automotive excellence, revisiting these celebrated machines and recalling the precise moment their brilliance was first unveiled to the world, as indicated by their original publication date within our pages. This exploration isn’t just a retrospective; it’s a testament to what’s possible when cutting-edge automotive technology meets visionary design and an uncompromising pursuit of perfection.
Our rigorous testing methodology, honed over generations, goes far beyond superficial metrics. We scrutinize every facet of a vehicle, from the granular details of its powertrain and chassis dynamics to the tactile experience of its interior appointments and the intuitive nature of its infotainment systems. Driver engagement, ride comfort, practicality, safety innovations, and outright value are all weighed with an expert hand. In an era where the automotive landscape is transforming at an unprecedented pace, with advancements in electric vehicle (EV) technology, autonomous driving capabilities, and sustainable manufacturing practices rapidly reshaping the industry, identifying true benchmarks of excellence becomes even more critical. This collection represents vehicles that not only excelled in their respective segments but also pushed the boundaries of what we thought possible.
The Elite Cadre: A Decade of Uncompromising Quality
As we delve into the specific vehicles that have achieved this ultimate accolade, it’s important to understand the context of their achievements. The automotive market is fiercely competitive, with manufacturers constantly striving to outdo one another. To emerge from this crucible with a perfect score means a vehicle has demonstrably outpaced its peers in almost every conceivable category. These are not merely good cars; they are exceptional cars that have resonated with our expert evaluators on multiple levels, setting new benchmarks for their class and often influencing the direction of future automotive design and engineering.
The pursuit of a five-star rating is a journey that begins with understanding the core needs and desires of modern drivers. Whether it’s the exhilarating performance demanded by driving enthusiasts, the unparalleled comfort and refinement sought for long-distance travel, or the practical versatility required for busy family lives, these vehicles address these needs with an almost uncanny precision. Furthermore, in today’s world, the environmental impact and technological integration of a vehicle are paramount. We’ve seen a significant shift towards electrification and sustainable materials, and the vehicles that have earned our highest praise reflect this evolution, often leading the charge in adopting and perfecting these new technologies.
Let’s begin our alphabetical tour of these remarkable machines, acknowledging that their order does not reflect a ranking but rather an appreciation of their individual brilliance.
(Alphabetical Order of Five-Star Vehicles from the Past Decade)
Audi R8 V10 Performance (Publication Date: September 2022)
When discussing automotive superlatives, the Audi R8 V10 Performance consistently rises to the top. This supercar, a testament to German engineering prowess, represents the purest distillation of driving pleasure. Its heart, a naturally aspirated V10 engine, unleashes a symphony of sound and fury, delivering blistering acceleration that pins you to your seat. But the R8 is more than just raw power; its quattro all-wheel-drive system provides astonishing grip and stability, making it confidence-inspiring even at extreme limits. The chassis is a masterpiece of lightweight construction, contributing to its agile handling and remarkable responsiveness. Inside, the cabin is a blend of performance-focused design and Audi’s signature luxurious materials, offering a surprisingly comfortable and technologically advanced environment for such a potent machine. For those seeking an everyday supercar that can deliver both track-day thrills and sophisticated road manners, the R8 V10 Performance remains an undisputed champion. Its ability to blend supercar performance with an almost docile temperament in everyday driving scenarios is a remarkable feat.
Bentley Flying Spur Hybrid (Publication Date: November 2021)
Bentley has always been synonymous with opulent luxury and effortless power, and the Flying Spur Hybrid is a bold leap into the future without compromising its storied heritage. This is not just a hybrid; it’s a statement of intent, demonstrating that environmental consciousness and uncompromising luxury can coexist. The powertrain seamlessly blends a potent V6 engine with an electric motor, delivering prodigious torque and a serene, almost silent driving experience when in electric mode. The craftsmanship within the cabin is, as expected from Bentley, simply peerless. Hand-stitched leather, exquisite wood veneers, and bespoke detailing create an environment of unparalleled comfort and sophistication. The ride quality is sublime, isolating occupants from the rigors of the road, while the advanced technology, including a suite of driver assistance systems, ensures a safe and effortless journey. The Flying Spur Hybrid redefines what a luxury sedan can be, offering an intelligent and exhilarating alternative for the discerning driver. This vehicle proves that sustainable motoring doesn’t necessitate a sacrifice in performance or ultimate comfort.
BMW M3 Competition xDrive (Publication Date: January 2023)
The BMW M3 has long been the benchmark for high-performance sports sedans, and the M3 Competition xDrive elevates this legacy to new heights. This iteration introduces a sophisticated all-wheel-drive system that enhances both traction and agility, allowing drivers to exploit the car’s immense power with newfound confidence. Under the hood lies a formidable turbocharged inline-six engine, delivering a thrilling surge of acceleration and a characterful exhaust note that’s pure M. The chassis tuning is a masterclass in balancing sporting prowess with everyday usability. It grips tenaciously through corners, offering precise steering feedback, yet manages to provide a compliant ride that won’t punish occupants on less-than-perfect roads. The interior is a focused yet luxurious space, brimming with driver-centric technology and premium materials. For those who crave an exhilarating driving experience that can be enjoyed daily, the M3 Competition xDrive stands as a compelling proposition, blending raw performance with BMW’s renowned driving dynamics. It represents the pinnacle of performance sedan engineering.
Ford F-150 Lightning Lariat (Publication Date: March 2023)
The electrification of the pickup truck segment has arrived, and the Ford F-150 Lightning is a truly revolutionary machine. This all-electric version of America’s best-selling vehicle retains the rugged capability and practicality that loyal F-150 customers expect, but imbues it with the silent, instant torque of electric propulsion. The Lariat trim offers a luxurious and technologically advanced cabin, replete with premium materials and a user-friendly infotainment system. Its electric powertrain provides astonishing acceleration, making it one of the quickest pickups on the market, while its dual motors offer impressive all-wheel-drive capability. The F-150 Lightning also boasts innovative features like the ‘Mega Power Frunk’ – a massive front trunk that provides versatile storage solutions. It’s not just a truck; it’s a glimpse into the future of utility vehicles, proving that electric power can enhance, rather than detract from, a vehicle’s core strengths. The seamless integration of advanced technology with proven truck utility makes the F-150 Lightning a game-changer. This represents a significant advancement in electric vehicle utility.
Genesis GV60 Performance AWD (Publication Date: October 2022)
Genesis, Hyundai’s luxury division, has rapidly established itself as a formidable competitor, and the GV60 Performance AWD is a prime example of their ambitious vision. This all-electric crossover is a masterclass in design and innovation. Its distinctive styling sets it apart from the crowd, while the interior is a sanctuary of modern luxury, featuring high-quality materials and a minimalist, tech-forward aesthetic. The performance is exhilarating, with dual electric motors providing instant, potent acceleration and a dynamic driving experience. The GV60’s platform is optimized for electric power, offering a low center of gravity and exceptional handling characteristics. Features like facial recognition for unlocking and a crystal sphere gear selector showcase Genesis’s commitment to pushing the boundaries of automotive technology. The GV60 Performance AWD demonstrates that electric vehicles can be both exciting and exquisitely crafted, offering a compelling alternative in the premium EV market. It’s a testament to the brand’s rapid ascent in the automotive world.
Hyundai IONIQ 5 Ultimate (Publication Date: July 2022)
The Hyundai IONIQ 5 has taken the automotive world by storm, and its Ultimate trim level fully embodies its groundbreaking appeal. This electric hatchback stands out with its retro-futuristic design, reminiscent of classic hatchbacks but infused with a modern, avant-garde sensibility. The interior is remarkably spacious and versatile, featuring a flat floor and a minimalist, lounge-like atmosphere. It’s a refreshing departure from traditional car interiors. The driving experience is refined and smooth, with the electric powertrain delivering quiet, effortless acceleration. The IONIQ 5 also boasts impressive charging speeds and a range that makes it a practical choice for daily commuting and longer journeys. Its unique blend of distinctive styling, innovative interior packaging, and strong EV credentials makes it a standout vehicle that has redefined expectations for mass-market electric cars. The IONIQ 5 represents a significant step forward in accessible electric mobility.
Kia EV6 GT (Publication Date: December 2022)
The Kia EV6 GT is a potent demonstration of Kia’s commitment to electrifying performance. Building on the already impressive EV6 platform, the GT model injects a dose of pure exhilaration into the electric crossover formula. Its dual-motor all-wheel-drive system delivers staggering acceleration, catapulting the EV6 GT from 0 to 60 mph in a time that rivals many sports cars. Beyond the straight-line speed, the GT variant benefits from a retuned suspension and chassis enhancements that sharpen its handling and provide a more engaging driving experience. The interior mirrors the exterior’s bold styling, offering a sporty and tech-laden environment with supportive seats and a user-friendly interface. The EV6 GT proves that electric vehicles can be genuinely exciting and dynamic, offering a compelling option for those who desire both sustainability and a thrilling drive. This vehicle showcases the exciting evolution of performance in the electric era.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO RWD Spyder (Publication Date: June 2021)
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO RWD Spyder is a pure, unadulterated supercar experience. Stripping away the all-wheel-drive system of its siblings, this rear-wheel-drive convertible focuses on delivering maximum driver engagement and visceral thrills. The naturally aspirated V10 engine remains the star, its thunderous roar and ferocious acceleration a constant reminder of the exotic machinery at your disposal. With the roof down, the sensory experience is amplified, immersing you in the sounds and sensations of this Italian masterpiece. The steering is razor-sharp, the chassis is perfectly balanced, and the braking is immense, all combining to create an intoxicating driving dynamic. While uncompromising in its performance focus, the interior still offers a driver-oriented cockpit with the necessary amenities for a spirited drive. For those who crave the ultimate in open-top supercar exhilaration and an unfiltered connection to the road, the Huracán EVO RWD Spyder is an unparalleled choice. It’s the embodiment of automotive passion.
Mercedes-AMG EQS 53 4MATIC+ (Publication Date: April 2022)
Mercedes-Benz has long been a purveyor of luxury and performance, and the AMG EQS 53 4MATIC+ represents their electrifying foray into the ultra-performance EV sedan segment. This is not just an electric car; it’s a technological tour de force wrapped in a supremely luxurious package. The AMG-tuned electric powertrains deliver ferocious acceleration and exhilarating performance, all while maintaining the serene comfort expected of a Mercedes-Benz. The exterior design is sleek and aerodynamic, hinting at the performance within, while the interior is a breathtaking display of digital innovation and opulent craftsmanship. The massive MBUX Hyperscreen dominates the dashboard, offering an intuitive and immersive interface for controlling vehicle functions and entertainment. The ride quality is exceptional, effortlessly gliding over road imperfections, yet it can transform into a dynamic powerhouse when demanded. The AMG EQS 53 4MATIC+ is a bold statement, proving that electric luxury and extreme performance can indeed go hand-in-hand.
Mercedes-Benz S-Class S500 4MATIC (Publication Date: August 2021)
The Mercedes-Benz S-Class has, for generations, set the standard for luxury sedans, and the S500 4MATIC continues this prestigious lineage with aplomb. This iteration represents the pinnacle of automotive refinement, comfort, and cutting-edge technology. The cabin is a sanctuary of tranquility, meticulously crafted with the finest materials, offering an environment of unparalleled opulence and serenity for both driver and passengers. The advanced suspension system masterfully irons out road imperfections, providing a ride that is both smooth and composed. Under the hood, the S500’s powertrain delivers effortless power and remarkable efficiency, while the plethora of advanced driver-assistance systems ensure a safe and relaxing journey. From its sophisticated infotainment to its world-class safety features, the S-Class remains the benchmark against which all other luxury sedans are measured, offering a truly first-class automotive experience. This vehicle continues its reign as the ultimate luxury sedan.
Porsche 911 Carrera S (992 Generation) (Publication Date: October 2020)
The Porsche 911 is an icon, a legend that has evolved over decades while staying true to its core identity. The 992 generation Carrera S embodies this evolutionary brilliance. Its rear-engined configuration provides a unique driving dynamic, and the chassis is a masterpiece of engineering, offering an extraordinary blend of agility, grip, and driver feedback. The turbocharged flat-six engine delivers a potent and characterful surge of power, coupled with the crisp, satisfying shifts of its PDK transmission. The interior is a thoughtful evolution, combining classic 911 design cues with modern technology and premium materials, creating a driver-focused cockpit that is both functional and sophisticated. On the road, the 911 Carrera S is a masterclass in performance driving, capable of exhilarating sprints and precise cornering with an almost telepathic connection between driver and machine. It remains the undisputed benchmark for sports car performance and everyday usability. The enduring appeal of the Porsche 911 is undeniable.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S (Publication Date: December 2020)
The Porsche Taycan Turbo S shattered expectations for what an electric performance car could be. This all-electric sedan delivers blistering acceleration that rivals hypercars, thanks to its potent dual-motor all-wheel-drive system and advanced battery technology. But what truly sets the Taycan apart is its driving dynamics. Porsche has engineered an EV that feels every bit as engaging and precise as its gasoline-powered siblings. The chassis is communicative, the steering is sharp, and the grip is immense, providing an exhilarating and confidence-inspiring driving experience. The interior is a minimalist yet luxurious space, featuring high-quality materials and a state-of-the-art infotainment system. The Taycan Turbo S proves that electric performance can be thrilling, refined, and utterly Porsche. It’s a groundbreaking machine that has redefined the premium electric vehicle segment and established a new benchmark for EV performance and handling.
Polestar 2 (Publication Date: May 2021)
The Polestar 2 represents a compelling fusion of Scandinavian design, electric performance, and practical usability. As the standalone performance brand of Volvo, Polestar imbues the Polestar 2 with a distinctive aesthetic and a focus on driving dynamics. Its minimalist exterior is both elegant and understated, while the interior is a haven of modern design, utilizing sustainable materials and featuring Google’s Android Automotive OS for a seamless and intuitive user experience. The electric powertrain delivers smooth, instant acceleration, making it an enjoyable car to drive in urban environments and on the open road. The Polestar 2 offers a balanced ride, striking a good compromise between comfort and sportiness. It’s a refreshingly pure electric vehicle that appeals to those seeking intelligent design, strong performance, and a commitment to sustainability. This vehicle offers a sophisticated and driver-focused electric experience.
Rivian R1T (Publication Date: August 2022)
The Rivian R1T has burst onto the scene as a truly innovative and groundbreaking electric adventure vehicle. This electric pickup truck is designed for the outdoors enthusiast, offering unparalleled capability and versatility. Its quad-motor all-wheel-drive system provides exceptional traction and precise torque vectoring, allowing it to tackle challenging off-road terrain with confidence. The R1T’s design is both functional and aesthetically pleasing, with clever storage solutions like the ‘Gear Tunnel’ and a spacious front trunk. The interior is modern and tech-rich, prioritizing comfort and utility. Beyond its impressive performance, the R1T also boasts impressive range and fast-charging capabilities. It represents a new era for electric trucks, blending ruggedness with cutting-edge technology and a spirit of adventure. The Rivian R1T is more than just a truck; it’s a platform for exploration and a testament to what’s possible in the electric vehicle revolution. It embodies the spirit of outdoor adventure.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (Publication Date: December 2020)
The Tesla Model 3 Performance has consistently been a benchmark for electric sedans, and this iteration solidifies its position. It combines blistering acceleration, a sophisticated all-wheel-drive system, and an impressive range that makes it a practical and exhilarating choice for daily driving. The Model 3’s minimalist interior is dominated by a large central touchscreen that controls most of the vehicle’s functions, offering a futuristic and uncluttered driving environment. Autopilot and Full Self-Driving capabilities, while still under development, represent Tesla’s ambitious vision for autonomous driving. The performance variant delivers sharp handling and a responsive driving experience, making it a joy to drive on both winding roads and city streets. The Model 3 Performance continues to be a leader in the EV space, offering a compelling blend of technology, performance, and efficiency that appeals to a broad audience. It remains a highly sought-after electric vehicle.
Tesla Model S Plaid (Publication Date: September 2021)
The Tesla Model S Plaid is quite simply a road rocket. It redefines the concept of acceleration in a production car, delivering mind-bending performance that can rival even the most exotic supercars. With its tri-motor all-wheel-drive setup, the Plaid offers ludicrously fast 0-60 mph times and immense power across the entire rev range. Beyond the straight-line speed, the Model S offers a spacious and luxurious interior, albeit with Tesla’s signature minimalist design ethos. The large central touchscreen controls most functions, and the car is packed with advanced technology and software features. While the primary focus is on sheer velocity, the Model S Plaid still offers a comfortable ride and impressive range for a vehicle of its caliber. It’s a technological marvel and a testament to Tesla’s relentless pursuit of performance and innovation in the electric vehicle domain. The Model S Plaid is a true hyper-sedan.
Volvo XC40 Recharge Twin (Publication Date: August 2021)
The Volvo XC40 Recharge Twin brings Volvo’s renowned safety and Scandinavian design principles to the electric compact SUV segment. This all-wheel-drive EV offers a compelling package of performance, comfort, and practicality. The dual-motor setup provides brisk acceleration and a smooth, quiet driving experience, making it ideal for city commuting and longer journeys alike. The interior is a testament to Volvo’s minimalist and user-friendly design philosophy, featuring high-quality materials and an intuitive infotainment system. Safety remains paramount, with a comprehensive suite of driver-assistance features. The XC40 Recharge Twin successfully blends Volvo’s core values with the advantages of electric propulsion, offering a safe, stylish, and enjoyable electric SUV option for discerning buyers. It’s a well-rounded and attractive entry into the premium electric SUV market.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mark 8) (Publication Date: April 2021)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI has long been the definitive hot hatch, and the Mark 8 generation continues this esteemed legacy. It expertly balances everyday usability with exhilarating performance, offering a driving experience that is both engaging and accessible. The turbocharged four-cylinder engine provides spirited acceleration and a characteristic GTI growl, while the chassis is finely tuned to deliver sharp handling and excellent grip. The interior boasts a modern, tech-focused design, featuring the latest infotainment and digital driver display systems, all wrapped in quality materials. The GTI’s ability to transition seamlessly from a comfortable daily driver to a spirited performance machine on demand is its enduring appeal. It remains the benchmark for hot hatches, delivering a potent blend of practicality, performance, and refinement that is difficult to match. The iconic Golf GTI continues to define its segment.
Volkswagen ID.4 Pro Performance (Publication Date: July 2022)
The Volkswagen ID.4 Pro Performance represents VW’s ambitious move into the mainstream electric SUV market, and it does so with commendable success. This electric SUV offers a spacious and comfortable interior with a clean, minimalist design. The Pro Performance variant delivers strong acceleration and a smooth, refined driving experience, making it well-suited for both urban commuting and family road trips. The ID.4 prioritizes practicality and ease of use, with a user-friendly infotainment system and ample cargo space. Its focus on delivering a comfortable, efficient, and accessible electric driving experience positions it as a strong contender in the rapidly growing electric SUV segment. The ID.4 is a significant step forward for Volkswagen in its electrification strategy, offering a compelling and well-rounded EV. It’s a pragmatic and enjoyable electric SUV.
The Enduring Quest for Automotive Perfection
As we reflect on this extraordinary collection of vehicles that have achieved the ultimate five-star rating from Autocar over the past decade, one overarching theme emerges: the relentless pursuit of perfection. These cars are not merely modes of transportation; they are feats of engineering, design, and innovation that have captivated our expert evaluators and, undoubtedly, their owners. They represent the pinnacle of what is currently achievable in the automotive world, pushing boundaries and setting new standards for performance, luxury, technology, and sustainability.
The automotive industry is in a constant state of flux, driven by technological advancements, evolving consumer demands, and a growing global focus on environmental responsibility. The vehicles recognized here have not only met the stringent criteria of our road tests but have also demonstrated an ability to adapt and lead within this dynamic landscape. Whether it’s the raw power of a V10 supercar, the silent grace of a luxury electric sedan, or the rugged utility of an all-electric pickup, each of these 21 vehicles embodies excellence in its own unique way.
This curated selection serves as a guide for anyone seeking the very best the automotive world has to offer. It highlights vehicles that have not only met but exceeded expectations, delivering unforgettable driving experiences and embodying the very essence of automotive passion and innovation.
Ready to explore the future of driving? Whether you’re inspired by the electric revolution, the enduring allure of performance engineering, or the ultimate in luxury and comfort, your next automotive journey begins with informed choices. Discover which of these five-star champions aligns with your aspirations, or contact our team of automotive experts to help guide you toward the vehicle that perfectly suits your lifestyle and driving desires. The road to automotive excellence awaits.
