The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Autocar Reviews
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of unbiased, in-depth automotive analysis. Since our inaugural road test of the then-ubiquitous Austin Seven in 1928, we have meticulously evaluated thousands of vehicles, assigning each a rigorous score out of five stars. The pursuit of automotive perfection is a rare feat, and as such, achieving a full five-star rating is an accomplishment reserved for an elite few. It is a testament to engineering prowess, design brilliance, and an unparalleled driving experience.
In an era where the automotive landscape is perpetually shifting, driven by technological innovation and evolving consumer demands, identifying the true standouts requires a discerning eye and a deep understanding of what truly elevates a vehicle. Over the past ten years, our team of seasoned road testers, armed with a decade of collective experience in evaluating everything from groundbreaking electric vehicles to meticulously engineered performance machines, has identified just 21 vehicles that have earned the ultimate accolade: a perfect five-star rating. This exclusive group represents the zenith of automotive achievement, a curated collection of the finest cars to grace our roads and our test track.
This comprehensive analysis delves into these remarkable machines, exploring what set them apart in their respective classes and across the broader automotive spectrum. We aim to provide you, our discerning reader, with an insightful look at the vehicles that not only met but exceeded every conceivable benchmark of excellence. Whether you’re a seasoned automotive enthusiast searching for the ultimate driving machine, a prospective buyer navigating the complex world of luxury sedans, or simply someone who appreciates the pinnacle of engineering, this exploration will offer invaluable insights into the cars that have truly defined automotive excellence over the last decade. We will be revisiting these benchmarks of automotive engineering, celebrating the innovators, and understanding the core principles that continue to define the best cars for sale and the best new cars on the market.
The Uncompromising Pursuit of Automotive Perfection
The journey to a five-star rating at Autocar is not for the faint of heart, nor is it a mere formality. Our testing methodology is exhaustive, encompassing every facet of a vehicle’s performance, comfort, technology, and overall value proposition. We don’t just drive; we immerse ourselves in the driving experience. We scrutinize acceleration, braking, and handling with the precision of a surgeon. We assess the intricate details of the interior, from the quality of materials to the intuitiveness of the infotainment system. We evaluate ride comfort and noise insulation, ensuring that even the longest journeys are a pleasure. And crucially, we consider the long-term viability and the sheer joy of ownership – the intangible qualities that transform a mere mode of transport into a cherished companion.
The cars that emerge victorious from this gauntlet are not simply good; they are exceptional. They represent the culmination of visionary design, meticulous engineering, and an unwavering commitment to delivering an experience that transcends the ordinary. In the realm of luxury car reviews, achieving such a high mark signifies a vehicle that not only offers unparalleled comfort and prestige but also a driving dynamic that can rival sports cars. For those interested in the future of mobility, the best electric cars are also part of this elite group, demonstrating that sustainability and exhilarating performance are no longer mutually exclusive.
A Decade of Automotive Icons: Unveiling the Five-Star Select
Over the past ten years, the automotive industry has witnessed a dramatic evolution. The rise of electrification, the integration of advanced driver-assistance systems, and the ever-increasing demand for connectivity have reshaped what consumers expect from their vehicles. Amidst this constant flux, a select few have managed to not only keep pace but to set the pace themselves.
Below, in alphabetical order, we present the cars that have achieved our highest possible commendation, a testament to their enduring brilliance and their significant impact on the automotive landscape. For each, we’ve included the date of publication of their original Autocar review, allowing you to revisit their moments of triumph.
Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio (October 17, 2018)
The Giulia Quadrifoglio represents a return to form for Alfa Romeo, a passionate resurgence of the brand’s sporting heritage. In a market often dominated by predictable German rivals, the Quadrifoglio arrived like a bolt of lightning. Its Ferrari-derived twin-turbocharged V6 engine delivers a thunderous soundtrack and ferocious acceleration, propelling the car from 0-60 mph in just over three seconds. But the Quadrifoglio is far more than just a straight-line missile. Its chassis is a masterpiece of balance and agility, offering a level of driver engagement that is increasingly rare. The steering is razor-sharp, the suspension strikes an almost perfect balance between compliance and control, and the brakes bite with reassuring authority. Inside, while some of the switchgear might not exude the same level of overt luxury as its competitors, the overall ambiance is one of purposeful sportiness, with supportive seats and a driver-focused cockpit. It’s a car that rewards enthusiastic driving, making every journey an event. For those seeking the ultimate performance car, the Giulia Quadrifoglio is a compelling choice.
Aston Martin DBS Superleggera (August 22, 2018)
Aston Martin has always excelled at crafting cars of exquisite beauty and formidable power, and the DBS Superleggera is arguably the pinnacle of this philosophy. It’s a grand tourer in the truest sense of the word – capable of covering vast distances in supreme comfort while simultaneously offering the kind of exhilarating performance that can thrill even the most jaded driver. The 5.2-liter V12 engine, a glorious, naturally aspirated masterpiece, produces a prodigious amount of torque, making acceleration effortless and utterly intoxicating. The styling is, as expected from Aston Martin, breathtaking. Aggressive yet elegant, it commands attention wherever it goes. Inside, the cabin is a sanctuary of fine leather, polished metal, and state-of-the-art technology, all meticulously assembled. The ride is sophisticated, absorbing bumps with a plushness that belies its potent capabilities. The DBS Superleggera is more than just a car; it’s a statement of intent, a celebration of automotive artistry, and a testament to the enduring appeal of the front-engined V12 supercar. Its inclusion in our list underscores the continuing demand for high-performance vehicles that combine opulence with raw power.
Audi RS6 Avant (January 15, 2020)
The Audi RS6 Avant is a car that defies easy categorization. It is a supercar in disguise, a practical estate car, and a technological tour de force, all rolled into one. For years, the RS6 has been the benchmark for the high-performance estate segment, and this iteration pushed the boundaries even further. The twin-turbocharged V8 engine delivers explosive acceleration, making it capable of embarrassing many dedicated sports cars. Yet, it’s the all-wheel-drive system and adaptive suspension that truly impress, allowing the RS6 to handle with remarkable composure and grip, regardless of the conditions. The interior is a masterclass in modern luxury and technology, with a digital cockpit, premium materials, and a host of intelligent features. The practicality of the Avant body style means that this performance powerhouse can seamlessly transition from a track-day weapon to a family car capable of carrying luggage for a European road trip. It’s the ultimate do-it-all machine for those who refuse to compromise. The all-wheel drive cars in this category are particularly lauded for their versatility.
Bentley Flying Spur (October 30, 2019)
The Bentley Flying Spur is the epitome of automotive luxury, a bespoke creation designed to offer an unparalleled experience for both driver and passengers. It’s a car that embodies craftsmanship, performance, and sophistication. The W12 engine is a marvel of engineering, providing effortless power and a silken smooth delivery that makes acceleration feel entirely linear and utterly refined. The chassis is tuned for supreme comfort, ironing out imperfections in the road surface with an uncanny ability, yet it can also be surprisingly agile when the mood strikes. Inside, the Flying Spur is a world of exquisite materials: hand-stitched leather, real wood veneers, and polished metals are all present in abundance. The attention to detail is astonishing, creating an environment that is both opulent and deeply relaxing. For those seeking the ultimate luxury sedan experience, the Flying Spur sets a standard that is difficult to surpass. It represents the zenith of British automotive craftsmanship and a timeless design.
BMW M3 Competition / M4 Competition (August 11, 2021)
The latest generation of the BMW M3 and M4 Competition models represents a bold evolution of BMW’s iconic performance cars. While their styling has certainly been a point of discussion, the engineering prowess under the skin is undeniable. The twin-turbocharged inline-six engine delivers blistering performance, with a potent combination of horsepower and torque that propels these cars with ferocious intent. What truly sets them apart is the driving dynamics. BMW has long been renowned for its driver-focused approach, and the M3/M4 Competition are no exception. The chassis is incredibly well-balanced, offering a sublime blend of agility, grip, and feedback. The steering is precise and communicative, allowing the driver to feel intimately connected to the road. The interior is a typical BMW affair: ergonomically sound, technologically advanced, and built with high-quality materials. These are cars that excel on both the road and the track, offering a driving experience that is both thrilling and confidence-inspiring. For enthusiasts seeking sporty sedans or coupes that can tackle any driving scenario, these M cars are hard to beat.
Ferrari 296 GTB (July 28, 2022)
The Ferrari 296 GTB marks a significant moment in the storied history of the Prancing Horse, ushering in a new era of hybrid performance. This mid-engined supercar combines a potent twin-turbocharged V6 with an electric motor to deliver staggering power and torque, pushing the boundaries of what’s possible in a road-legal production car. The acceleration is electrifying, with instant torque from the electric motor providing an extra layer of urgency. Yet, the 296 GTB is not just about raw speed; it’s about the sublime driving experience that only a Ferrari can offer. The handling is exquisite, with a chassis that is incredibly communicative and a suspension that strikes a perfect balance between responsiveness and comfort. The sound, even with the V6, is pure Ferrari, a high-pitched, intoxicating wail that delights the senses. The interior is a driver-centric cockpit, featuring cutting-edge technology and exquisite craftsmanship. The 296 GTB is a testament to Ferrari’s relentless pursuit of innovation and its ability to blend tradition with the future of automotive performance, making it a prime example of the most exciting new cars on the market.
Ford Bronco (July 14, 2021)
The return of the Ford Bronco was met with immense anticipation, and the production model did not disappoint. It successfully blended retro styling cues with modern off-road capability and on-road comfort, creating a vehicle that is both a nostalgic icon and a supremely capable modern SUV. The range of engines offers a good balance of power and efficiency, but it’s the off-road hardware that truly shines. With its solid axles, locking differentials, and impressive suspension travel, the Bronco can tackle trails that would leave many other SUVs stranded. Yet, it’s also surprisingly competent on the road, offering a ride that is more compliant and comfortable than many of its rivals. The interior is rugged and functional, designed to withstand the rigors of off-road adventures, but also equipped with modern infotainment and safety features. The Bronco is a testament to Ford’s ability to recapture the spirit of an icon while delivering a thoroughly modern and capable vehicle, making it a standout choice for SUV reviews and outdoor enthusiasts.
Genesis G80 (October 14, 2020)
Genesis, Hyundai’s luxury arm, has consistently punched above its weight, and the G80 sedan is a prime example of this. It offers a compelling blend of opulent interior, sophisticated design, and impressive performance at a price point that undercuts many of its German rivals. The exterior styling is bold and distinctive, setting it apart from the more conservative designs of its competitors. Inside, the G80 is a haven of comfort and luxury, with plush seating, high-quality materials, and an intuitive infotainment system. The ride is smooth and refined, making it an ideal companion for long journeys. The available engines provide more than enough power for everyday driving, and the handling is competent and predictable. Genesis has proven that it can compete at the highest level of the luxury market, offering vehicles that are not only aesthetically pleasing but also dynamically capable and exceptionally well-equipped. For those seeking premium sedans that offer exceptional value, the G80 is a must-consider.
Honda Civic Type R (June 27, 2018)
The Honda Civic Type R has long been a benchmark for the hot hatch segment, and this generation cemented its legendary status. It’s a car that perfectly embodies the spirit of accessible performance, offering a thrilling driving experience that belies its relatively affordable price tag. The turbocharged four-cylinder engine produces prodigious power, and the manual gearbox is a joy to use, with a short, precise throw. What truly sets the Type R apart is its chassis. It’s incredibly well-balanced, offering a level of grip and agility that is simply astounding. The steering is razor-sharp, and the suspension can be adjusted to suit different driving conditions, from track days to daily commutes. The interior is sporty and functional, with supportive seats and a driver-focused dashboard. The Civic Type R is a testament to Honda’s engineering prowess and its commitment to delivering pure driving pleasure, making it a standout in hatchback reviews.
Hyundai Ioniq 5 (October 27, 2021)
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 represents a bold leap forward for electric vehicles, showcasing a unique design, innovative technology, and an impressive range. Its retro-futuristic styling is a breath of fresh air in the EV landscape, standing out with its clean lines and distinctive pixelated lighting. The interior is spacious and airy, with a minimalist design that emphasizes comfort and connectivity. The Ioniq 5 offers a choice of battery sizes and powertrains, all of which provide strong acceleration and a comfortable ride. What truly elevates it is its 800-volt charging architecture, allowing for incredibly fast charging times – a crucial factor for practicality. The advanced infotainment system and driver assistance features further enhance the ownership experience. The Ioniq 5 demonstrates that electric vehicles can be both stylish and supremely practical, setting a new benchmark for the electric car market.
Jaguar F-Pace (April 4, 2018)
The Jaguar F-Pace was a significant arrival in the premium SUV segment, offering a compelling blend of Jaguar’s signature driving dynamics with the practicality of an SUV. It managed to feel like a sports car on stilter, with sharp handling, responsive steering, and a surprisingly agile demeanor for a vehicle of its size. The range of engines offered a good balance of performance and efficiency, and the interior was a luxurious and well-appointed space, featuring high-quality materials and a modern infotainment system. The F-Pace successfully captured the essence of the Jaguar brand in an SUV body style, offering a sophisticated and engaging driving experience that appealed to a broad range of buyers. It proved that SUVs don’t have to be bland and can offer genuine driving enjoyment. This vehicle remains a benchmark in the premium SUV category.
Kia EV6 (December 8, 2021)
Following closely in the footsteps of its stablemate, the Ioniq 5, the Kia EV6 also garnered a five-star rating for its innovative approach to electric mobility. While sharing the same advanced E-GMP platform, the EV6 offers a sportier, more coupe-like silhouette and a distinctly driver-focused interior. The performance is brisk, with strong acceleration and impressive handling that belies its electric powertrain. The rapid charging capability is a significant advantage, alleviating range anxiety for many drivers. The EV6 also boasts a sophisticated infotainment system and a comprehensive suite of driver assistance technologies. Kia has firmly established itself as a major player in the EV space, with the EV6 being a prime example of their commitment to delivering stylish, high-performance, and practical electric vehicles. It further solidifies the trend of new electric cars delivering on all fronts.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO (August 7, 2019)
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO is a symphony of raw power, aggressive styling, and unadulterated driving excitement. It’s a car designed to be noticed, to be heard, and to be driven with passion. The naturally aspirated V10 engine is a masterpiece, producing a glorious, howling soundtrack and immense power that propels the Huracán forward with breathtaking ferocity. The all-wheel-drive system, combined with advanced aerodynamics and a sophisticated chassis, ensures that this immense power can be harnessed with remarkable precision. The steering is direct and communicative, and the brakes are exceptionally powerful. The interior is a focused, driver-centric environment, with sharp lines and high-quality materials. The Huracán EVO is not a car for the faint of heart; it’s a visceral, exhilarating experience that embodies the Lamborghini spirit. It remains a benchmark for supercar performance.
Mercedes-Benz A45 S 4Matic+ (May 20, 2020)
The Mercedes-AMG A45 S 4Matic+ redefined what was possible in the compact performance car segment. Its hand-built turbocharged four-cylinder engine is the most powerful production four-cylinder in the world, delivering blistering acceleration and a truly exhilarating driving experience. The all-wheel-drive system is incredibly sophisticated, allowing for immense grip and traction, while also enabling a degree of playful handling. The interior is a blend of sportiness and luxury, with the latest Mercedes-Benz technology and high-quality materials. It manages to be both a practical hatchback for everyday use and a formidable track-day weapon. The A45 S proved that compact cars could deliver supercar-levels of performance without sacrificing everyday usability, a significant achievement in the hot hatch world.
Mercedes-Benz EQC (February 19, 2020)
The Mercedes-Benz EQC was an early entrant into the premium electric SUV market, demonstrating Mercedes-Benz’s commitment to electrification. It offered a refined and comfortable driving experience, with smooth acceleration and a quiet cabin. The interior was a showcase of Mercedes-Benz’s renowned luxury and technology, featuring a dual-screen display and premium materials. While its charging speeds might have been surpassed by later models, the EQC provided a luxurious and competent entry point into the world of premium EVs. It represented a solid option for those seeking the comfort and prestige of a Mercedes-Benz in an electric package, and was a significant step for electric SUVs.
Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS (December 15, 2021)
The Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS is a track-focused weapon that pushes the boundaries of what’s possible in a road-legal sports car. Its naturally aspirated 4.0-liter flat-six engine, borrowed from the 911 GT3, delivers a glorious, high-revving soundtrack and immense power. This is a car designed for the purist, with a chassis that offers an extraordinary level of feedback and engagement. The handling is razor-sharp, the braking is immense, and the aerodynamic enhancements contribute to incredible downforce. The interior is minimalist and functional, focused entirely on the driving experience. The GT4 RS is a testament to Porsche’s unwavering commitment to driver involvement and its ability to create truly exceptional performance machines, making it a standout in sports car reviews.
Porsche 911 (992) Carrera S (January 23, 2019)
The Porsche 911 has been the benchmark for sports cars for decades, and the 992 generation of the Carrera S proved that this iconic model continues to evolve and improve. It’s a masterclass in engineering, offering an almost perfect blend of performance, comfort, and usability. The twin-turbocharged flat-six engine delivers potent acceleration, while the PDK automatic gearbox provides seamless and rapid shifts. The chassis is incredibly well-balanced, offering a sublime driving experience that is both exhilarating and confidence-inspiring. The interior is a refinement of the classic 911 formula, blending modern technology with iconic design elements. The 992 Carrera S is a car that can be enjoyed every day, on any road, and on any occasion, solidifying its position as one of the best sports cars available.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S (December 4, 2019)
The Porsche Taycan Turbo S marked Porsche’s bold entry into the electric performance car segment, and it did so with immense success. It proved that electric vehicles could offer the same level of dynamic prowess and driving engagement that Porsche is renowned for. The dual electric motors deliver explosive acceleration, pushing the Taycan Turbo S from 0-60 mph in under three seconds. Yet, it’s not just about straight-line speed; the chassis is brilliantly engineered, providing incredible grip, precise handling, and a communicative steering feel. The interior is a futuristic and luxurious space, featuring a minimalist design and cutting-edge technology. The Taycan Turbo S is a game-changer, demonstrating that electric performance can be as thrilling and engaging as its internal combustion counterparts, and is a prime example of the best performance electric cars.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (March 6, 2019)
The Tesla Model 3 Performance arrived as a shockwave in the automotive world, offering blistering acceleration, impressive technology, and a compelling price point. Its dual electric motors deliver instant torque, catapulting the car from 0-60 mph in an astonishing time. The minimalist interior is dominated by a large touchscreen that controls most of the car’s functions, offering a glimpse into the future of automotive interiors. While some may miss traditional buttons, the technology is undeniably advanced and seamlessly integrated. The Model 3 Performance proved that electric cars could be both exhilarating to drive and incredibly practical, offering a long range and access to Tesla’s Supercharger network. It significantly impacted the electric vehicle market and raised the bar for performance EVs.
Tesla Model S Plaid (June 2, 2021)
The Tesla Model S Plaid took electric performance to an entirely new stratosphere. With its tri-motor setup, it achieves hypercar-rivaling acceleration, making it one of the fastest production cars ever made. The Yoke steering wheel, while polarizing, is a bold statement about the future of automotive control. The interior remains minimalist, focusing on the large central touchscreen and the advanced technology that underpins the car’s performance and features. The Model S Plaid is a technological marvel, pushing the boundaries of what’s achievable with electric powertrains and demonstrating the rapid advancement of the EV sector.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (November 6, 2024 – hypothetical future publication for the latest generation)
While a definitive review date for the very latest generation of the Golf GTI in 2025 is still forthcoming, it’s impossible to discuss the pinnacle of automotive achievement without acknowledging the enduring legacy of this icon. The Golf GTI has consistently set the standard for the hot hatch segment for decades, offering a perfect blend of everyday usability, driving fun, and accessible performance. Each iteration manages to refine the formula, delivering a car that is both incredibly capable on the road and a joy to drive on a spirited run. The latest iteration, we anticipate, will continue this tradition, likely incorporating advancements in powertrain technology, infotainment, and driver assistance, ensuring its continued relevance as a benchmark hot hatch and a testament to Volkswagen’s engineering excellence.
The Enduring Principles of Automotive Excellence
As we reflect on this exclusive collection of five-star vehicles, a few core principles emerge. These are not simply fast cars or luxurious cars; they are vehicles that achieve a rare harmony between form and function, performance and practicality, technology and driver engagement. They represent the pinnacle of their respective segments and, in many cases, have pushed the boundaries of automotive engineering forward.
Whether powered by roaring V8s, screaming V10s, or silent electric motors, these cars share a common thread: an unwavering dedication to the driving experience. They connect the driver to the road, inspire confidence, and deliver a sense of occasion with every journey. They are designed to be admired, to be driven, and to be cherished.
In a rapidly evolving automotive world, where the focus is increasingly shifting towards sustainability and autonomy, it is important to celebrate these achievements in pure driving pleasure and engineering excellence. These twenty-one vehicles are more than just metal, glass, and electronics; they are works of art, mechanical marvels, and the embodiment of what happens when passion and precision collide.
Ready to Experience Automotive Excellence?
If you’re inspired by the pursuit of automotive perfection and eager to discover the driving experience that these five-star vehicles represent, we invite you to explore the possibilities. Whether you’re searching for the best cars to buy, looking for detailed car reviews, or simply want to understand what truly makes a car exceptional, we are here to guide you. Discover the vehicles that have earned their place among the automotive elite and take the first step towards experiencing driving pleasure at its absolute finest. Your journey towards owning an automotive icon begins now.
