The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Reviews from the Nation’s Foremost Automotive Authority
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a bastion of automotive journalism, meticulously scrutinizing vehicles from every segment and category. Our commitment to comprehensive, unbiased road testing began in 1928 with the diminutive yet immensely popular Austin Seven, a benchmark of its era. Since that inaugural evaluation, we have subjected thousands of automobiles to rigorous examination, each culminating in a star rating out of five – a universally recognized symbol of our expert judgment. Achieving a perfect score is an exceedingly rare feat, a testament to true automotive brilliance, with typically only one or two vehicles per year earning this ultimate accolade.
In this exclusive compilation, we delve into the annals of Autocar’s archives to present the select few vehicles that have achieved the coveted five-star rating over the past decade. This is not merely a list; it is a curated collection of automotive masterpieces, a testament to engineering prowess, driver engagement, and unparalleled refinement. Out of the countless vehicles tested, a mere twenty-one have ascended to this hallowed status. Join us as we revisit the crème de la crème of the automotive world, exploring the cars that defined excellence and set new benchmarks for their respective classes. We will also provide the publication date of each original road test, allowing you to delve deeper into our initial impressions and the full context of our evaluations.
A Spectrum of Brilliance: Unveiling the Elite
This curated selection represents a diverse range of automotive segments, showcasing that true excellence can manifest in various forms. From agile city cars to opulent luxury sedans and groundbreaking performance machines, the common thread is an uncompromising dedication to quality, innovation, and the sheer joy of driving.
Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio (October 2020)
The Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio, a name synonymous with passion and performance, has long captivated the hearts of driving enthusiasts. In our October 2020 review, this Italian marvel solidified its legendary status. Powered by a Ferrari-derived twin-turbocharged 2.9-liter V6 engine, the Quadrifoglio delivers an exhilarating 505 horsepower, catapulting it from 0 to 60 mph in a breathtaking 3.9 seconds. However, its appeal extends far beyond raw power. The Giulia Quadrifoglio boasts a chassis tuned for sublime handling, offering razor-sharp steering, remarkable agility, and an uncanny ability to communicate with the driver. The adaptive suspension system works in concert with the sophisticated all-wheel-drive system (Q4) to provide tenacious grip and confidence-inspiring stability, even when pushed to its limits. The interior, while sporting, exudes an Italian flair, with premium materials and supportive sport seats that envelop the driver in comfort. The infotainment system, though perhaps not the most cutting-edge by 2020 standards, is intuitive and functional. For those seeking a four-door sedan that offers a visceral connection to the road and a soundtrack to match its performance, the Giulia Quadrifoglio remains an unparalleled choice. Its ability to blend supercar-like performance with everyday usability is a rare and remarkable achievement. This vehicle consistently ranks high in discussions about the best performance sedans and luxury sports sedans.
Audi RS6 Avant (May 2021)
The Audi RS6 Avant, a legendary “super-wagon,” redefined the concept of a practical yet ferociously fast family car when it received its five-star assessment in May 2021. Audi’s RS division has a storied history of transforming everyday Audis into extraordinary machines, and the RS6 Avant is arguably their magnum opus. Under its sculpted hood lies a potent 4.0-liter twin-turbocharged V8 engine, producing a colossal 591 horsepower and 590 lb-ft of torque. This prodigious power is channeled through Audi’s quattro all-wheel-drive system and an eight-speed Tiptronic transmission, enabling the RS6 Avant to accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in a mere 3.6 seconds. What truly sets the RS6 Avant apart, however, is its ability to effortlessly blend blistering performance with the practicality of an estate car. The spacious interior, premium materials, and advanced technology create a luxurious environment for both driver and passengers. The ride quality, while firm to manage its immense capabilities, is surprisingly compliant for daily driving, a testament to Audi’s sophisticated dynamic chassis control. The RS6 Avant is more than just a fast car; it’s a statement of intent, proving that you don’t have to sacrifice utility for exhilaration. It’s a vehicle that can ferry the kids to school and then dominate a track day with equal aplomb. This model is frequently sought after by those interested in fast estate cars and performance wagons.
Bentley Continental GT Speed (November 2019)
In November 2019, the Bentley Continental GT Speed earned its five-star distinction, embodying the pinnacle of British luxury and performance. Bentley’s unwavering commitment to craftsmanship and refinement is evident in every facet of the Continental GT Speed. This grand tourer is powered by a formidable 6.0-liter twin-turbocharged W12 engine, producing a staggering 650 horsepower and 664 lb-ft of torque. The sheer torque output is immense, allowing for effortless acceleration and a top speed that redefines automotive dynamism. The experience of driving a Continental GT Speed is one of unparalleled opulence and effortless power. The interior is a sanctuary of handcrafted leather, polished wood veneers, and meticulously detailed metalwork. The ride is supremely comfortable, absorbing imperfections in the road with grace, yet the dynamic capabilities are surprisingly potent, allowing for spirited driving on winding roads. The engineering is sublime, providing a blend of brute force and sophisticated control. It’s a car designed for covering vast distances in supreme comfort and style, making it the ultimate luxury grand tourer. The attention to detail, from the knurled switchgear to the exquisite stitching, is a testament to Bentley’s enduring legacy.
BMW M3 Competition (G80) (July 2021)
The arrival of the G80 generation BMW M3 Competition in July 2021 marked a significant moment in the evolution of this iconic performance sedan, earning it a coveted five-star rating. BMW’s M division has a legendary reputation for creating driver-focused machines, and the M3 Competition is the embodiment of that philosophy. Under its aggressive hood lies a potent 3.0-liter twin-turbocharged inline-six engine, delivering an impressive 503 horsepower and 479 lb-ft of torque. This power is delivered with a thrilling immediacy, pushing the M3 Competition from 0 to 60 mph in under 4 seconds. What truly elevates the M3 Competition is its razor-sharp handling and communicative chassis. The steering is precise, the suspension is expertly tuned for both track-day prowess and acceptable road manners, and the optional M xDrive all-wheel-drive system offers the perfect blend of rear-wheel-drive bias and all-weather capability. The interior is a driver-centric cockpit, featuring supportive M Sport seats, a digital instrument cluster, and intuitive iDrive infotainment system. While the exterior styling of the G80 generation has been a point of discussion, the driving dynamics and overall performance are undeniably exceptional. It’s a car that demands to be driven and rewards the driver with an engaging and exhilarating experience, solidifying its status as a benchmark performance sedan. For those considering new BMW M3 models, this represents the peak of their performance offerings.
Ferrari Roma (February 2022)
The Ferrari Roma, a contemporary interpretation of the elegant La Dolce Vita lifestyle, captured our attention and a five-star rating in February 2022. This striking front-engined V8 GT embodies a blend of timeless design and modern performance. Its 3.9-liter twin-turbocharged V8 engine, a multiple award-winner, produces a formidable 612 horsepower and 561 lb-ft of torque. The power delivery is smooth and progressive, allowing for effortless cruising and exhilarating bursts of acceleration. The Roma’s design is a masterclass in automotive sculpture, drawing inspiration from the graceful lines of 1950s and 60s Ferraris. The interior is equally captivating, with a driver-focused cockpit featuring innovative dual-screen displays and premium materials. Despite its elegant demeanor, the Roma possesses a keen chassis that allows for spirited driving, offering a delightful balance between comfort and dynamism. It’s a car that excels as a sophisticated grand tourer, capable of long-distance journeys in supreme comfort while also delivering the unmistakable thrill of a Ferrari. The Ferrari GT cars segment has a new, exceptionally compelling contender with the Roma.
Ford Mustang Mach-E GT (March 2023)
The Ford Mustang Mach-E GT, in its March 2023 assessment, demonstrated that electrification can indeed deliver exhilarating performance and iconic styling, earning a well-deserved five-star rating. Ford has successfully translated the Mustang’s legendary spirit into an all-electric SUV, and the GT variant pushes the boundaries of what an electric performance vehicle can be. Powered by a dual-motor all-wheel-drive system, the Mach-E GT produces an impressive 480 horsepower and a colossal 600 lb-ft of torque (634 lb-ft with the Performance Edition). This potent combination allows it to accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in a blistering 3.5 seconds. Beyond its straight-line speed, the Mach-E GT offers surprisingly engaging handling for an SUV, with responsive steering and a well-sorted suspension that keeps body roll in check. The interior is modern and minimalist, dominated by a large central touchscreen that controls most of the vehicle’s functions. The practical cargo space and the convenience of electric propulsion make it a compelling choice for families and individuals seeking a high-performance electric SUV. The Mustang Mach-E GT is a significant step forward for electric performance vehicles and a strong contender in the best electric cars market.
Honda Civic Type R (FK8) (January 2018)
The Honda Civic Type R (FK8 generation), reviewed in January 2018, cemented its reputation as the king of front-wheel-drive performance cars, achieving a flawless five-star rating. This hot hatch is powered by a potent 2.0-liter VTEC turbocharged four-cylinder engine, delivering 306 horsepower and 295 lb-ft of torque. While the horsepower figure might seem modest compared to some rivals, the Type R’s magic lies in its expertly tuned chassis, incredibly precise six-speed manual gearbox, and aggressive aerodynamic package. The steering is telepathic, the suspension strikes a remarkable balance between track-day aggression and everyday usability, and the limited-slip differential ensures that power is deployed effectively, even under hard cornering. The interior is functional and driver-focused, with supportive bucket seats and a sporty aesthetic. The FK8 Civic Type R proved that an engaging driving experience and exhilarating performance don’t require all-wheel drive or excessive power; rather, it’s about intelligent engineering and a deep understanding of driver feedback. It remains a benchmark for hot hatch performance and a beloved choice for driving enthusiasts seeking pure, unadulterated fun. Its legacy in the compact performance car segment is undeniable.
Hyundai Ioniq 5 N (September 2024)
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 N, making its debut in our road test calendar in September 2024, immediately set a new standard for electric performance vehicles, earning a remarkable five-star rating. Hyundai’s N division, known for its track-honed performance cars, has delivered a truly electrifying experience with the Ioniq 5 N. This dual-motor, all-wheel-drive EV boasts an astonishing peak output of 641 horsepower (with overboost), enabling it to achieve 0-60 mph in a blistering 3.4 seconds. But the Ioniq 5 N is far more than just straight-line acceleration. It features an advanced integrated drive axle, performance-tuned electronic suspension, and an innovative “N e-shift” system that simulates the feel and sound of an internal combustion engine gearbox, complete with virtual gear changes and an engine rev-matching function. This level of driver engagement in an electric vehicle is unprecedented. The interior is suitably sporty, with bolstered seats and N-specific performance displays. The Ioniq 5 N redefines what an electric performance car can be, offering a thrilling and engaging driving experience that rivals and, in many ways, surpasses traditional sports cars. It represents a significant leap forward for performance EVs and a testament to Hyundai’s commitment to pushing the boundaries of automotive innovation.
Jaguar F-Pace SVR (August 2020)
In August 2020, the Jaguar F-Pace SVR received a five-star accolade, proving that a high-performance SUV could deliver an exceptional blend of luxury, utility, and sheer driving pleasure. The SVR (Special Vehicle Operations) division at Jaguar has a talent for extracting the very best from their vehicles, and the F-Pace SVR is a prime example. At its heart lies a supercharged 5.0-liter V8 engine, producing a potent 550 horsepower and 502 lb-ft of torque. This muscular powerplant, mated to an eight-speed automatic transmission and all-wheel drive, propels the F-Pace SVR from 0 to 60 mph in a swift 3.8 seconds. What truly sets this performance SUV apart is its ability to handle its considerable power with remarkable agility and poise. The steering is direct and communicative, the suspension is taut yet compliant enough for daily use, and the chassis feels remarkably well-balanced, defying its SUV proportions. The interior is appointed with premium materials, comfortable sport seats, and a modern infotainment system, offering a luxurious and refined cabin. The F-Pace SVR is a compelling choice for those seeking a performance SUV that doesn’t compromise on luxury or driving dynamics, offering a thrilling alternative in the luxury SUV segment.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO (January 2020)
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO, reviewed in January 2020, demonstrated that even in an evolving automotive landscape, the raw passion and performance of a naturally aspirated V10 supercar remain undiminished, earning it a five-star rating. The Huracán EVO continues Lamborghini’s tradition of delivering breathtaking supercars with an uncompromising focus on performance and driver engagement. Powered by a naturally aspirated 5.2-liter V10 engine, it produces a phenomenal 631 horsepower and 443 lb-ft of torque. The soundtrack alone is a symphony of mechanical passion, and the acceleration is nothing short of ferocious, pushing the car to extreme speeds with exhilarating ease. The Huracán EVO features advanced aerodynamics and a sophisticated all-wheel-drive system that provides exceptional grip and stability, allowing drivers to explore its immense capabilities with confidence. The interior, while driver-focused and sporting, offers a more refined experience than some previous Lamborghinis, with updated technology and premium materials. The driving experience is visceral and utterly thrilling, a testament to Lamborghini’s DNA. It remains a benchmark for supercar performance and a definitive example of naturally aspirated engines in the modern era.
McLaren 720S (September 2018)
In September 2018, the McLaren 720S was awarded a five-star rating, solidifying its position as one of the most exceptional supercars of its generation. The 720S, part of McLaren’s Super Series, represents a significant leap forward in performance, technology, and design. It is powered by a 4.0-liter twin-turbocharged V8 engine that produces a prodigious 710 horsepower and 568 lb-ft of torque. The acceleration is simply staggering, with 0-60 mph achieved in around 2.8 seconds. However, the 720S is much more than just its blistering speed. Its innovative carbon fiber Monocage II chassis provides an incredibly light yet incredibly strong structure, contributing to its sublime handling and agility. The active aerodynamics, electro-hydraulic steering, and advanced suspension system work in perfect harmony to deliver an unparalleled connection between driver and machine. The interior is minimalist and driver-focused, with dihedral doors that add to its dramatic presence. The McLaren 720S is a testament to cutting-edge engineering and a benchmark for supercar handling and aerodynamic efficiency. For those seeking the absolute pinnacle of performance car technology, the 720S stands out.
Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S 4-Door Coupé (November 2019)
The Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S 4-Door Coupé, reviewed in November 2019, proved that four doors don’t mean a compromise on true AMG performance, earning a five-star rating. This potent machine seamlessly blends the practicality of a four-door sedan with the unadulterated performance that defines the AMG brand. It’s powered by a formidable 4.0-liter twin-turbocharged V8 engine, generating a colossal 630 horsepower and 664 lb-ft of torque. Mated to an AMG Speedshift MCT 9-speed transmission and 4MATIC+ all-wheel drive, it rockets from 0 to 60 mph in a mere 3.2 seconds. The GT 63 S is a masterclass in automotive engineering, offering breathtaking acceleration, razor-sharp handling, and a refined yet athletic ride. The interior is a luxurious cockpit, featuring premium materials, supportive AMG sports seats, and the intuitive MBUX infotainment system. The dynamic Select drive modes allow drivers to tailor the car’s character from comfortable cruiser to track-focused beast. It’s a car that can effortlessly transport four adults in supreme comfort and then deliver a spine-tingling performance experience. This model is a top contender for those seeking luxury performance sedans and high-performance four-door coupes.
Porsche 911 Carrera S (992) (March 2020)
In March 2020, the latest generation of an automotive icon, the Porsche 911 Carrera S (992), received its five-star recognition. Porsche has a remarkable ability to evolve the 911 without ever losing its soul, and the 992 generation is a perfect example. Powered by a 3.0-liter twin-turbocharged flat-six engine, the Carrera S produces 443 horsepower and 390 lb-ft of torque. While these figures might seem conservative on paper, the 911’s genius lies in its perfectly balanced chassis, incredibly precise PDK dual-clutch transmission, and driver-focused engineering. The acceleration is potent and progressive, and the handling is nothing short of sublime, offering an unparalleled connection to the road. The interior is a sophisticated blend of classic 911 design cues and modern technology, with a digital instrument cluster and intuitive infotainment system. The 992 Carrera S is a car that excels in all areas – daily driving, spirited back-road assaults, and even track days. It embodies the essence of a true sports car and remains the benchmark for rear-engined sports cars. Enthusiasts seeking the ultimate Porsche 911 models will find the Carrera S a compelling choice.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S (September 2020)
The Porsche Taycan Turbo S, evaluated in September 2020, demonstrated that electric performance could not only match but in some areas, exceed the thrills of traditional sports cars, earning a five-star rating. Porsche’s foray into the electric vehicle market with the Taycan has been met with widespread acclaim, and the Turbo S variant is the undisputed performance king. Its dual electric motors generate a staggering 750 horsepower and 774 lb-ft of torque in overboost mode, allowing it to achieve 0-60 mph in a mind-bending 2.8 seconds. Beyond its brute acceleration, the Taycan Turbo S offers Porsche’s signature dynamic prowess. The all-wheel-drive system, sophisticated chassis tuning, and low center of gravity contribute to exceptional handling and agility, even at high speeds. The interior is a futuristic sanctuary of premium materials and cutting-edge technology, with a focus on driver experience. The Taycan Turbo S is a testament to what is possible when a legendary sports car manufacturer embraces electrification, offering a truly exhilarating and engaging electric sports car experience. It stands as a pinnacle of performance EVs and a benchmark for luxury electric vehicles.
Rimac Nevera (December 2022)
The Rimac Nevera, reviewed in December 2022, redefined the very concept of automotive performance, achieving a remarkable five-star rating. This Croatian hypercar is an engineering marvel, powered by four independent electric motors that collectively produce an astonishing 1,914 horsepower and 1,741 lb-ft of torque. The result is performance figures that were once the realm of science fiction: 0-60 mph in an unbelievable 1.74 seconds and a top speed exceeding 258 mph. But the Nevera is more than just raw power; it’s a symphony of cutting-edge technology. Its carbon fiber monocoque chassis, advanced aerodynamic systems, and sophisticated software control all contribute to its mind-bending capabilities. The interior is a blend of extreme performance and bespoke luxury, with bespoke materials and a focus on driver interaction. The Nevera represents the absolute cutting edge of automotive engineering and is a clear indication of the future direction of hypercar performance. It is an undisputed leader in the electric hypercar segment and a testament to the boundless potential of electric powertrains.
Rivian R1S (June 2023)
The Rivian R1S, assessed in June 2023, earned a five-star rating by showcasing its exceptional blend of rugged capability, luxurious comfort, and innovative electric powertrain. Rivian has carved out a unique niche in the rapidly expanding electric vehicle market, and the R1S, its three-row SUV, exemplifies this. Powered by a quad-motor setup, the R1S offers exhilarating performance with up to 835 horsepower and a truly remarkable off-road capability. Its adjustable air suspension allows for significant ground clearance, and the sophisticated all-wheel-drive system provides excellent traction in diverse conditions. The interior is spacious, thoughtfully designed, and appointed with premium, sustainable materials, offering a comfortable and modern environment for families. The R1S’s ability to seamlessly transition from daily commuting to adventurous off-roading sets it apart. It represents a compelling option for those seeking a versatile and capable electric SUV with a focus on adventure and practicality, a standout in the adventure vehicle category.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (January 2019)
In January 2019, the Tesla Model 3 Performance achieved a five-star rating, highlighting its impressive blend of electric performance, cutting-edge technology, and increasing refinement. Tesla has been a driving force in the EV revolution, and the Model 3 Performance version of its popular sedan represents a significant milestone. It features a dual-motor all-wheel-drive system, producing a potent combination of acceleration and range. The 0-60 mph sprint is accomplished in under 3.5 seconds, offering a thrilling driving experience that rivals many gasoline-powered sports sedans. The minimalist interior, dominated by a large central touchscreen, controls most of the vehicle’s functions and provides access to Tesla’s advanced infotainment and Autopilot features. While early iterations had some interior quality concerns, the Performance model demonstrated a marked improvement in build quality and overall refinement. The Model 3 Performance remains a benchmark for performance electric sedans and a testament to Tesla’s impact on the automotive industry, showcasing the capabilities of performance EVs.
Tesla Model S Plaid (August 2021)
The Tesla Model S Plaid, reviewed in August 2021, earned a five-star rating by shattering expectations for electric vehicle performance and ushering in a new era of hyper-sedan capability. Tesla’s commitment to pushing the boundaries of electric performance is fully realized in the Model S Plaid. This tri-motor beast delivers a staggering 1,020 horsepower, enabling it to achieve a mind-blowing 0-60 mph in an astonishing 1.99 seconds (with rollout subtracted). The acceleration is relentless and unlike anything most drivers have ever experienced. Beyond its straight-line prowess, the Model S Plaid offers surprisingly adept handling and a comfortable ride, thanks to its adaptive suspension and refined chassis. The interior is a testament to Tesla’s minimalist design philosophy, featuring a panoramic glass roof and a futuristic infotainment system. The Model S Plaid is not just an electric car; it’s a technological tour de force that redefines what a sedan can be, setting a new standard for electric sedan performance and pushing the envelope for high-performance electric cars.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk8) (August 2021)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI, in its Mk8 iteration reviewed in August 2021, continued its reign as the benchmark for affordable, accessible performance, earning a five-star rating. The Golf GTI is more than just a car; it’s an institution, and the Mk8 generation proves that this iconic hot hatch can still deliver an exhilarating and engaging driving experience. Powered by a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, it produces a robust 241 horsepower and 273 lb-ft of torque, delivered through either a slick six-speed manual transmission or a refined DSG dual-clutch automatic. The GTI’s true magic lies in its perfectly balanced chassis, which offers a sublime blend of agility, comfort, and driver feedback. The steering is precise, the suspension strikes an ideal compromise between sporty handling and everyday usability, and the limited-slip differential ensures that power is delivered effectively. The interior is modern and refined, featuring a digital cockpit and an intuitive infotainment system. The Mk8 Golf GTI proves that you don’t need exorbitant power or all-wheel drive to have immense fun behind the wheel, solidifying its legacy as a cornerstone of the compact performance car market.
Looking Ahead: The Enduring Pursuit of Automotive Excellence
This curated selection represents the absolute zenith of automotive engineering and design from the past decade, as judged by the discerning eyes of Autocar’s expert reviewers. Each of these twenty-one vehicles has not only met but exceeded our rigorous standards, setting new benchmarks for performance, luxury, innovation, and driver engagement.
As we look towards the future, the automotive landscape continues its rapid evolution, driven by advancements in electrification, autonomous technology, and sustainable materials. Yet, the fundamental principles of what makes a truly exceptional car – a captivating driving experience, impeccable craftsmanship, and groundbreaking innovation – remain constant.
We invite you to explore these iconic vehicles further. Whether you’re a seasoned enthusiast seeking to understand the drivers behind automotive greatness or a discerning buyer in search of the ultimate driving machine, our in-depth road tests offer a comprehensive guide to the pinnacle of automotive achievement. Discover the full details of each review on the Autocar website and consider consulting with our trusted automotive partners to find the perfect vehicle that aligns with your passion and needs.
