The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Cars from the Experts
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive journalism, meticulously scrutinizing vehicles through comprehensive road tests. Our legacy began in 1928 with a thorough examination of the Austin Seven, a model that reigned supreme as the UK’s best-seller. Since that foundational moment, we have subjected thousands of automobiles to our rigorous evaluation process, culminating in an overall score out of five. Achieving a perfect score, a rare five-star rating, is an extraordinary feat; typically, only one or two vehicles annually earn this distinguished accolade.
This exclusive compilation delves into the crème de la crème of the automotive world, spotlighting every car that has garnered a flawless five-star rating from Autocar in the past decade. A mere 21 vehicles have ascended to this elite echelon, a testament to their exceptional engineering, performance, and desirability. Prepare to embark on a journey through the finest automobiles of the last ten years, presented in alphabetical order, each accompanied by the publication date of its comprehensive Autocar road test. This isn’t just a list; it’s a curated collection of automotive mastery, representing the absolute best in new car reviews and luxury vehicle testing.
The Unwavering Pursuit of Automotive Perfection
The automotive landscape is a constantly evolving tapestry, driven by innovation, evolving consumer demands, and an unyielding commitment to pushing the boundaries of what’s possible. At Autocar, our role has always been to act as the discerning voice of the consumer, translating complex engineering into understandable insights and ultimately, helping individuals make informed decisions about their next automotive investment. When we assign a five-star rating, it signifies a vehicle that has not only met but profoundly exceeded our stringent expectations across a multitude of crucial criteria. This isn’t merely about speed or luxury; it’s about the holistic experience of driving, owning, and living with a car.
Our evaluation process is a multifaceted endeavor. We meticulously assess everything from the initial design philosophy and build quality to the nuanced driving dynamics, the effectiveness of safety systems, the practicality of the interior, and the overall value proposition. For electric vehicles, particular attention is paid to range, charging infrastructure compatibility, and the seamless integration of cutting-edge battery technology. For gasoline and hybrid counterparts, we scrutinize fuel efficiency, powertrain refinement, and the often-overlooked but critical exhaust emissions performance. The goal is to provide a comprehensive understanding of each vehicle’s strengths and weaknesses, allowing our readers to gain a deep appreciation for the engineering prowess and thoughtful design that underpins truly exceptional automobiles. This dedication to thoroughness is what solidifies our position as a trusted source for automotive expertise and car buying advice.
A Decade of Distinction: The 2015-2025 Autocar Five-Star Hall of Fame
The past decade has witnessed a remarkable surge in automotive advancement, particularly in the realms of electrification and sophisticated driver assistance technologies. Our five-star recipients reflect this progression, showcasing a blend of established automotive giants and innovative newcomers who have redefined industry standards. Let’s explore these exceptional machines:
Aston Martin DB11 (V8 and V12)
(Publication Date: October 2016)
The Aston Martin DB11 arrived as a breathtaking statement of intent, a glorious evolution of the iconic Grand Tourer formula. Its design, penned by Marek Reichman, was an instant classic, a perfect fusion of sculpted athleticism and understated elegance. Beyond its stunning aesthetics, the DB11 delivered a driving experience that was both exhilarating and supremely comfortable. The V8 and V12 engines offered prodigious power and a symphonic soundtrack, while the chassis, a collaborative effort with Mercedes-AMG, provided a remarkable balance of agility and stability. The interior was a sanctuary of handcrafted luxury, with exquisite materials and a user-friendly infotainment system. The DB11 wasn’t just a car; it was an emotional statement, embodying the very essence of sophisticated motoring. Its enduring appeal places it firmly in the conversation for best luxury GT cars and high-performance coupe reviews.
Audi RS6 Avant (C8)
(Publication Date: December 2019)
The Audi RS6 Avant has long been the benchmark for the high-performance estate car, and the C8 generation cemented that status with unparalleled authority. This isn’t merely a fast car; it’s a masterclass in practicality fused with extreme performance. The twin-turbocharged V8 engine delivered ferocious acceleration, propelling the substantial estate with astonishing alacrity. Yet, what truly sets the RS6 apart is its incredible versatility. It can comfortably transport a family and their luggage, navigate challenging weather conditions with unflappable composure thanks to its quattro all-wheel-drive system, and then unleash blistering performance on a winding road. The interior is a testament to Audi’s renowned build quality and technological sophistication, offering a premium environment for all occupants. For those seeking a vehicle that can do it all without compromise, the RS6 Avant remains the undisputed king, a prime example of performance SUV alternatives and family car reviews.
Bentley Continental GT (3rd Generation)
(Publication Date: December 2017)
The Bentley Continental GT is a legend in its own right, and the third generation further refined its already exceptional formula. This is automotive opulence personified, a car that effortlessly blends brute force with exquisite craftsmanship. The W12 engine (and later the potent V8) provided immense power and a velvety smooth delivery, while the new platform offered a surprising level of dynamic capability. The exterior design evolved gracefully, maintaining its imposing presence while adding a touch of modern dynamism. Inside, the Continental GT is a haven of luxury, adorned with the finest leather, real wood veneers, and meticulous attention to detail. It’s a car that makes every journey an event, a true statement of wealth and discerning taste, frequently cited in premium sports car comparisons and exclusive car reviews.
BMW M3 Competition (G80) & M4 Competition (G82)
(Publication Date: January 2021)
The latest iterations of the BMW M3 and M4 represent a bold, unapologetic return to the legendary driving dynamics that have defined the M division for decades. While their controversial grille design initially sparked debate, the sheer performance and engagement on offer quickly silenced the critics. The twin-turbocharged inline-six engine delivers ferocious power and torque, channeled through a chassis that is incredibly communicative and agile. These are cars that demand to be driven, rewarding the enthusiastic pilot with razor-sharp responses and an intoxicating sense of connection to the road. The interior, while overtly sporty, retains BMW’s hallmark ergonomics and premium feel. For drivers who prioritize outright performance and driving pleasure, the M3 and M4 Competition are exceptionally compelling choices, often lauded in track-focused car reviews and performance sedan comparisons.
Ferrari 296 GTB
(Publication Date: July 2022)
The Ferrari 296 GTB represents a significant and exciting new chapter for the Prancing Horse, seamlessly integrating a groundbreaking plug-in hybrid powertrain into a mid-engined supercar. This isn’t just about reducing emissions; it’s about delivering unprecedented levels of performance and driving engagement. The electric motor and V6 engine combine to produce a staggering output, offering electrifying acceleration and a thrilling, almost otherworldly soundtrack. The chassis is a marvel of engineering, providing razor-sharp handling and immense grip, all while maintaining a surprising degree of usability. The cabin is a driver-focused cockpit, replete with cutting-edge technology and Ferrari’s signature blend of luxury and sporting intent. The 296 GTB is a potent demonstration of how electrification can enhance, rather than detract from, the supercar experience, securing its place among future supercar technology and hybrid sports car reviews.
Honda Civic Type R (FL5)
(Publication Date: March 2023)
The Honda Civic Type R has always been a darling of the hot hatch segment, and the FL5 generation takes this legacy to an even higher level. This is a car that perfectly balances raw performance with everyday usability. The potent turbocharged engine delivers explosive acceleration, and the manual gearbox remains a joyous companion for enthusiastic driving. What truly sets the Type R apart is its chassis tuning. It’s incredibly agile, communicative, and confidence-inspiring, making it an absolute blast to drive on any road. The aggressive styling hints at its performance capabilities, while the practical hatchback body style ensures it can handle daily duties with ease. The interior is functional and sporty, focused on the driving experience. The Civic Type R remains the gold standard for front-wheel-drive performance, a consistent performer in hot hatch reviews and affordable performance cars.
Hyundai Ioniq 5
(Publication Date: April 2021)
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 arrived as a breath of fresh air in the burgeoning electric vehicle market, captivating with its distinctive retro-futuristic design and its E-GMP platform. This innovative architecture allows for impressive interior space and remarkable charging speeds. The Ioniq 5 offers a smooth, refined, and surprisingly engaging driving experience, with multiple battery and powertrain options to suit diverse needs. Its standout feature is the ultra-fast charging capability, dramatically reducing downtime on longer journeys. The cabin is a minimalist, spacious haven, showcasing Hyundai’s commitment to innovative interior design and user-friendly technology. The Ioniq 5 proved that electric vehicles could be both practical and stylish, cementing its reputation in electric car reviews and EV buying guides. Its availability in major cities like Los Angeles EV dealerships and New York electric car sales further highlights its market impact.
Jaguar F-Type P450 RWD
(Publication Date: February 2021)
The Jaguar F-Type has long been a poster child for automotive beauty, and the P450 RWD version refined its performance credentials with a focus on driver engagement. Eschewing the more extreme all-wheel-drive variants, this rear-wheel-drive model delivers a more pure and visceral driving experience. The supercharged V8 engine provides a thunderous soundtrack and immense shove, while the chassis is beautifully balanced, offering a delightful blend of grip and playful agility. The F-Type’s exterior design remains one of the most evocative on the road, and the interior, while perhaps not as cutting-edge as some rivals, is comfortable and sumptuously appointed. It’s a modern classic that appeals to the senses, a strong contender in sports car comparisons and V8 engine cars.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO RWD
(Publication Date: June 2020)
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO RWD is a purist’s supercar, a machine that prioritizes driver involvement and raw, unadulterated V10 drama. Removing the all-wheel-drive system from the already potent Huracán EVO unleashed a more engaging and, dare we say, more rewarding driving experience. The naturally aspirated V10 engine is a masterpiece of engineering, delivering a glorious crescendo of sound and a relentless surge of power. The steering is direct and communicative, and the rear-wheel-drive setup allows for exhilarating slides and a deep connection to the road. The Huracán’s wedge-shaped styling is as dramatic as ever, and the interior is a purposeful, driver-focused environment. It’s a car that ignites the passion for driving, a cornerstone of supercar performance tests and V10 engine cars.
McLaren 720S
(Publication Date: April 2017)
The McLaren 720S redefined the supercar landscape upon its arrival, setting new benchmarks for performance, handling, and aerodynamic efficiency. Its groundbreaking MonoCage II carbon fiber chassis and advanced active aerodynamics contribute to a car that is astonishingly light and incredibly capable. The twin-turbocharged V8 engine delivers ferocious acceleration, while the steering is telepathic, and the suspension system offers an uncanny ability to absorb imperfections while maintaining razor-sharp composure. The design is a functional work of art, dictated by the car’s aerodynamic needs. The interior is minimalist and driver-focused, eschewing unnecessary fripperies for pure performance. The 720S remains a benchmark for modern supercar technology and track day cars, often mentioned in discussions about McLaren car reviews.
Mercedes-AMG A45 S 4Matic+
(Publication Date: September 2019)
The Mercedes-AMG A45 S 4Matic+ is a hot hatch that punches far above its weight, delivering supercar-rivalling performance in a compact, practical package. Its 2.0-liter turbocharged engine, the most powerful production four-cylinder in the world at the time of its launch, produces truly astonishing power figures. Paired with the sophisticated 4Matic+ all-wheel-drive system and an incredibly responsive transmission, the A45 S rockets from 0-60 mph in mere seconds. The chassis is expertly tuned to handle the immense power, offering a planted and agile feel. The interior is a premium space, benefiting from Mercedes-Benz’s renowned build quality and advanced MBUX infotainment system. It’s a potent reminder that exhilarating performance doesn’t always require a larger engine or body style, making it a frequent topic in performance compact car reviews and AMG vehicle tests.
Mercedes-Benz S-Class (W223)
(Publication Date: November 2020)
The Mercedes-Benz S-Class has long been the benchmark for automotive luxury and technological advancement, and the W223 generation continued this tradition with impressive aplomb. This is not just a car; it’s a mobile sanctuary, a showcase of cutting-edge automotive engineering designed to provide unparalleled comfort, safety, and refinement. From its serene ride quality and exquisitely crafted interior to its comprehensive suite of advanced driver-assistance systems and sophisticated infotainment, the S-Class sets the standard for the premium sedan segment. It offers a glimpse into the future of personal transportation, blending effortless performance with an oasis of calm. For those seeking the ultimate in luxury sedan reviews and automotive technology advancements, the S-Class remains the undisputed leader, with strong interest in Mercedes S-Class price and S-Class lease deals.
Porsche 911 Carrera 4S (992)
(Publication Date: March 2019)
The Porsche 911 is a legend, and the 992 generation of the Carrera 4S further cemented its iconic status. This iteration masterfully blends evolutionary design with significant technological upgrades, maintaining the unmistakable silhouette while pushing performance boundaries. The twin-turbocharged flat-six engine delivers explosive power and a characteristic soundtrack, while the all-wheel-drive system provides immense grip and confidence in all conditions. The chassis is a marvel of engineering, offering razor-sharp handling and superb feedback, allowing drivers to exploit its full potential. The interior is a perfect marriage of modern technology and classic 911 ergonomics, creating a driver-focused cockpit. The 911 Carrera 4S is a benchmark in the sports car segment and a frequent subject of Porsche 911 reviews and all-wheel-drive sports car comparisons.
Porsche Taycan
(Publication Date: January 2020)
The Porsche Taycan marked a bold and brilliant entry into the electric vehicle arena, proving that an EV could possess all the dynamism and driver engagement expected of a Porsche. This car shattered preconceptions about electric performance, delivering searing acceleration, precise handling, and a level of refinement that is distinctly Porsche. The innovative powertrain and sophisticated chassis management systems create a driving experience that is both thrilling and remarkably composed. The Taycan’s interior is a testament to modern luxury, with a minimalist design, high-quality materials, and cutting-edge digital interfaces. It’s a car that redefines what an electric vehicle can be, a compelling choice for those interested in electric sports car reviews and premium EV performance. Interest in Porsche Taycan cost and Taycan charging solutions underscores its market significance.
Range Rover (L460)
(Publication Date: February 2022)
The latest generation Range Rover, codenamed L460, represents a significant evolution for the iconic luxury SUV. While retaining its unmistakable presence and legendary off-road capability, this new model introduces a heightened level of refinement, cutting-edge technology, and a more sustainable approach to luxury. The interior is a sumptuous and serene environment, meticulously crafted with the finest materials and offering an array of innovative comfort and convenience features. On-road dynamics have been significantly improved, providing a composed and luxurious ride, while its off-road prowess remains unmatched. The Range Rover continues to set the standard for luxury SUV reviews and off-road vehicle capabilities, with strong demand in markets like Denver luxury car dealerships and Aspen SUV sales.
Rimac Nevera
(Publication Date: August 2022)
The Rimac Nevera is not just a hypercar; it’s a technological tour de force, a fully electric machine that obliterates conventional notions of speed and performance. This Croatian marvel boasts an astonishing four electric motors producing over 1,900 horsepower, propelling it to mind-bending acceleration figures and record-breaking speeds. The advanced carbon-fiber monocoque and sophisticated torque-vectoring system ensure that this immense power is harnessed with incredible precision and control. The interior is a blend of minimalist luxury and advanced technology, reflecting the car’s groundbreaking nature. The Nevera is a glimpse into the extreme future of automotive performance, a leading example in electric hypercar reviews and automotive engineering breakthroughs.
Tesla Model 3 Performance
(Publication Date: July 2018)
The Tesla Model 3, particularly in its Performance variant, has been a transformative force in the electric vehicle market. It demonstrated that a compelling electric car could offer exhilarating performance, impressive range, and a cutting-edge user experience at a more accessible price point than many luxury competitors. The Model 3 Performance delivers instantaneous acceleration and sharp handling, making it a surprisingly engaging car to drive. The minimalist interior, dominated by a large central touchscreen, is a signature Tesla design element. While its focus on software and over-the-air updates has redefined automotive user interfaces, its practicality and efficiency have made it a benchmark for performance electric cars and EV ownership reviews. Its widespread availability through Tesla showrooms nationwide and electric vehicle financing options has driven its massive adoption.
Tesla Model S Plaid
(Publication Date: June 2021)
The Tesla Model S Plaid represents the pinnacle of electric performance from Tesla, a ludicrously fast sedan that redefines acceleration. With its tri-motor powertrain, it achieves warp-speed acceleration figures that rival and even surpass the most potent hypercars. Beyond its straight-line prowess, the Model S Plaid offers a comfortable and technologically advanced interior, featuring Tesla’s signature minimalist design and a unique yoke steering wheel. The long-range capability and access to Tesla’s Supercharger network make it a practical choice for daily driving as well as exhilarating sprints. The Plaid is a statement about the potential of electric powertrains, a significant player in electric vehicle speed records and performance EV technology.
Toyota GR Yaris
(Publication Date: October 2020)
The Toyota GR Yaris is a rally-bred homologation special that has taken the hot hatch world by storm. Developed with input from Toyota’s Gazoo Racing division, this car is a masterclass in lightweight, agile performance. The unique three-door body, a bespoke platform, and a potent turbocharged three-cylinder engine combine to create a car that is incredibly fun and capable on any road. The GR Yaris’s compact size, stiff chassis, and sophisticated all-wheel-drive system make it a joy to drive, offering a level of engagement rarely found in modern performance cars. Its raw, unfiltered character has earned it a devoted following and critical acclaim as a true driver’s car, frequently topping hot hatch performance charts and rally-inspired car reviews.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk8)
(Publication Date: January 2021)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI has been the quintessential hot hatch for generations, and the Mk8 continues that esteemed lineage with a blend of performance, refinement, and everyday usability. While the styling is a subtle evolution, the driving dynamics have been sharpened, offering a more engaging experience for enthusiastic drivers. The turbocharged engine provides brisk acceleration, and the optional DSG gearbox delivers swift and seamless shifts. The interior is modern and well-equipped, featuring VW’s latest infotainment system and digital cockpit. The GTI remains the benchmark for a balanced performance hatchback, a consistent performer in hatchback reviews and VW Golf GTI comparisons. Its enduring popularity is evident in cities like Chicago car dealerships and Austin car sales.
Beyond the Numbers: The Essence of Five-Star Motoring
Achieving a five-star rating from Autocar is more than just accumulating a high score; it’s about embodying a holistic excellence that resonates with drivers on an emotional and intellectual level. These vehicles represent the zenith of automotive design, engineering, and manufacturing. They are the cars that inspire passion, provide unparalleled experiences, and set new benchmarks for their respective classes.
For prospective car buyers navigating the complex car buying process, understanding the significance of such accolades is paramount. It signifies a level of quality, reliability, and sheer driving pleasure that is truly exceptional. Whether you’re considering a new sports car purchase or exploring electric vehicle options, these five-star models offer a glimpse into the pinnacle of automotive achievement.
Your Next Step Towards Automotive Excellence
This journey through a decade of Autocar’s five-star vehicles has showcased some of the most remarkable automobiles ever produced. Each one represents a unique blend of performance, luxury, innovation, and sheer driving joy. If you’re inspired by this collection and are ready to explore the possibilities of owning a truly exceptional vehicle, we invite you to delve deeper. Research these models further, compare their specifications, and most importantly, experience them firsthand. Your journey to discovering your next five-star car begins now.
