The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Machines
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive journalism, rigorously evaluating vehicles from the roaring twenties to the cutting edge of 2025. Our commitment to comprehensive road tests began in 1928, with an inaugural examination of the Austin Seven, a car that defined an era of accessible motoring. Since that foundational test, we have subjected thousands of vehicles to our discerning scrutiny, awarding each a holistic rating out of five stars. Achieving a perfect score is an exceedingly rare honor, typically bestowed upon no more than one or two vehicles annually.
This exclusive compilation celebrates the zenith of automotive achievement, showcasing the select few vehicles that have earned our coveted five-star rating over the past decade. This esteemed group, comprising a mere 21 exceptional machines, represents the absolute best of what the automotive world has offered since 2015. We invite you to journey with us through this curated collection of automotive masterpieces, meticulously reviewed and recognized for their unparalleled brilliance. Each entry is accompanied by the original publication date of its road test, offering a glimpse into the historical context of its excellence.
The Uncompromising Pursuit of Automotive Perfection: What Defines a Five-Star Vehicle?
In an automotive landscape brimming with innovation and incremental improvements, the pursuit of a five-star rating from Autocar is a testament to a vehicle’s ability to transcend the ordinary. It’s not merely about ticking boxes or meeting baseline expectations; it’s about delivering an experience that is profoundly moving, impeccably executed, and consistently superior across every conceivable metric. Our road tests, a cornerstone of Autocar’s legacy, delve deep into the soul of a car, examining everything from the visceral thrill of acceleration to the subtle nuances of ride comfort, the intuitive functionality of its technology, and the enduring quality of its craftsmanship.
For a car to achieve this ultimate accolade, it must demonstrate an exceptional command of its segment, often setting new benchmarks for others to aspire to. This involves a harmonious blend of performance, efficiency, comfort, safety, and technological sophistication. It’s about a holistic package where every component, every design choice, and every engineering decision culminates in a cohesive and utterly compelling whole. We consider the driving dynamics – the steering feel, the chassis balance, the responsiveness of the powertrain – as paramount. A five-star car inspires confidence and elicits joy behind the wheel, making every journey, whether a daily commute or a cross-continental adventure, a memorable occasion.
Furthermore, the interior must be a sanctuary, meticulously crafted with premium materials, ergonomic brilliance, and a level of refinement that cocoon the occupants from the outside world. Infotainment systems need to be intuitive, seamlessly integrated, and technologically advanced, offering connectivity and entertainment without distraction. Safety is, of course, non-negotiable. A five-star vehicle will invariably feature a comprehensive suite of active and passive safety systems, offering peace of mind to drivers and passengers alike. Beyond the tangible, there’s an intangible quality – a certain desirability, a character that sets it apart. This might be an audacious design, a groundbreaking innovation, or simply an unshakeable sense of purpose.
In essence, a five-star car isn’t just a mode of transportation; it’s an embodiment of automotive passion and engineering prowess. It’s a machine that not only meets but consistently exceeds the highest expectations of discerning drivers and industry experts. The selection process is rigorous, objective, and uncompromising, ensuring that only the truly exceptional earn their place among the automotive elite. This dedication to rigorous evaluation is what makes Autocar’s five-star ratings so highly valued by consumers and manufacturers alike, serving as a definitive guide to the pinnacle of automotive achievement in any given year.
A Decade of Dominance: The 21 Cars That Earned Autocar’s Highest Accolade
The past ten years have witnessed an extraordinary evolution in automotive engineering and design. From the quiet revolution of electrification to the relentless pursuit of performance and luxury, the automotive industry has been a hotbed of innovation. Here, we present the twenty-one vehicles that, through their sheer brilliance and unwavering excellence, have captivated our test drivers and secured the ultimate five-star rating. These are not just cars; they are icons, setting standards that continue to influence the automotive landscape today.
The following list is presented in alphabetical order by manufacturer, each entry a testament to the enduring pursuit of automotive perfection. We’ve strived to present a diverse range of vehicles, reflecting the varied tastes and demands of the modern motorist, from the sublime to the sporty, the practical to the outright exhilarating.
Aston Martin DBS Superleggera (Published: October 17, 2018)
The Aston Martin DBS Superleggera is more than just a grand tourer; it’s a visceral statement of intent. Combining breathtaking aesthetics with ferocious performance, this British icon redefined the ultra-luxury GT segment. Its potent V12 engine, meticulously tuned chassis, and opulent interior create an driving experience that is both exhilarating and supremely comfortable. The Superleggera’s ability to effortlessly blend brute force with refined elegance makes it a truly special machine, capable of crossing continents with effortless grace or dominating a winding mountain pass with unbridled ferocity. The sheer drama and theatre of its V12 soundtrack, coupled with its sophisticated handling, leave an indelible mark on any driver fortunate enough to experience it. It represents the very essence of what makes an Aston Martin so desirable: a blend of exquisite design, potent power, and an unshakeable sense of occasion.
Audi RS6 Avant (C8) (Published: January 22, 2020)
In the realm of performance estates, the Audi RS6 Avant (C8) stands as a titan. This isn’t merely a spacious family car with a powerful engine; it’s a supercar disguised as an everyday vehicle. The thunderous V8 powertrain delivers blistering acceleration, while the quattro all-wheel-drive system ensures tenacious grip and astonishing composure in all conditions. Yet, what truly elevates the RS6 Avant is its remarkable versatility. It can transport a family with ease, haul large loads with practical flair, and then unleash supercar-rivaling performance when the mood strikes. The interior is a masterclass in modern luxury and technology, seamlessly integrating cutting-edge digital displays with high-quality materials. It’s a car that doesn’t compromise, offering an unparalleled blend of everyday usability and outright performance, making it a benchmark for high-performance wagons globally, and a prime example of Audi’s commitment to delivering exceptional performance cars.
BMW M3 Competition (G80) (Published: February 10, 2021)
The latest generation BMW M3 Competition (G80) represents a significant evolution in the legendary M3 lineage. While its polarizing grille design sparked debate, its on-road prowess silenced any critics. This iteration delivers a truly captivating driving experience, characterized by razor-sharp handling, immense grip, and a potent turbocharged inline-six engine that offers a thrilling surge of power. The engineers at BMW M have perfected the art of creating a car that is both a formidable track weapon and a surprisingly compliant daily driver. The sophisticated chassis allows for a remarkable degree of driver engagement, rewarding skilled pilots with a deep sense of connection to the road. The interior is a modern haven of premium materials and advanced technology, enhancing both the sporting and luxurious aspects of the M3 experience. It’s a car that embodies the spirit of performance driving, proving that sports sedans can still deliver an exhilarating and deeply satisfying experience.
BMW M5 CS (Published: April 7, 2021)
The BMW M5 CS is, quite simply, the ultimate iteration of the M5. Stripping away weight and maximizing performance, this limited-edition model is a track-focused hyper-sedan that redefines what’s possible. Its V8 engine produces astonishing power, matched by a chassis and suspension tuned for absolute precision and agility. The M5 CS delivers a level of dynamic capability that belies its four-door format, offering an experience so intense and rewarding it borders on the supernatural. This is a car for the true driving enthusiast, a machine built without compromise for ultimate performance. It’s a benchmark for luxury performance sedans and a rare breed of vehicle that pushes the boundaries of automotive engineering.
Bugatti Chiron Pur Sport (Published: October 7, 2020)
The Bugatti Chiron Pur Sport is an exercise in extreme automotive focus. While the standard Chiron is a marvel of speed and luxury, the Pur Sport dials up the track-day intensity. Featuring revised aerodynamics, a stiffer suspension, and shorter gearing, this Bugatti is designed for maximum agility and cornering prowess. It’s a testament to Bugatti’s relentless pursuit of hypercar perfection, pushing the boundaries of what’s physically achievable in a road-legal vehicle. The sheer engineering brilliance and the insane power output of its W16 engine, combined with the enhanced handling, make it an unforgettable experience, albeit one for the most discerning and capable drivers seeking the ultimate in hypercar performance.
Ferrari 488 Pista (Published: March 20, 2019)
The Ferrari 488 Pista represents the pinnacle of Ferrari’s V8 mid-engined sports cars. Building upon the already impressive 488 GTB, the Pista amplifies the performance with a more potent engine, revised aerodynamics, and a lighter, more track-focused chassis. The result is a car that delivers an electrifying driving experience, with razor-sharp responses, incredible grip, and a soundtrack that ignites the senses. It’s a true driver’s car, designed to thrill and reward with every input. The Pista demonstrates Ferrari’s unparalleled expertise in crafting supercars that are as exhilarating to drive as they are beautiful to behold, a true embodiment of Italian automotive passion and engineering prowess.
Ferrari SF90 Stradale (Published: September 25, 2020)
The Ferrari SF90 Stradale marks a new era for the legendary Italian marque, introducing a groundbreaking plug-in hybrid powertrain. This extreme supercar combines a potent V8 engine with three electric motors, delivering mind-bending performance and astonishing acceleration. It’s a technological tour de force, showcasing Ferrari’s commitment to electrifying its future while retaining its core DNA of performance and emotion. The SF90 Stradale is not just fast; it’s a deeply engaging and remarkably accessible supercar, proving that hybrid technology can enhance, rather than detract from, the pure driving pleasure Ferrari is renowned for. It’s a significant step forward for electric performance cars and a glimpse into the future of supercars.
Ford Focus ST (Published: May 8, 2019)
The Ford Focus ST, in its most potent iteration, proved that exhilarating performance doesn’t require a six-figure price tag. This hot hatch delivered a driving experience that was pure, unadulterated fun. Its responsive turbocharged engine, agile chassis, and precise steering made it an absolute joy on both winding country roads and everyday commutes. The Focus ST offered an incredible blend of practicality, affordability, and sheer driving engagement, making it a standout in the competitive hot hatch segment. It demonstrated Ford’s enduring ability to create cars that connect with drivers on an emotional level, offering an accessible gateway to thrilling performance.
Honda Civic Type R (FK8) (Published: January 25, 2017)
Though the specific model tested predates the 10-year window for some publication dates, the FK8 generation of the Honda Civic Type R deserves mention for its profound impact. It redefined expectations for front-wheel-drive performance, offering a level of grip and agility that was simply astonishing. The turbocharged engine delivered immense power, and the finely tuned chassis provided a direct connection to the road. The Type R became a benchmark for front-wheel drive performance cars, proving that a well-engineered FWD layout could challenge even the most sophisticated AWD rivals. Its blend of raw performance and everyday usability cemented its status as a cult hero.
Jaguar F-Type R (Published: October 11, 2017)
The Jaguar F-Type R, in its V8 supercharged guise, was a symphony of sound and performance. This potent sports car delivered a driving experience that was both exhilarating and emotionally resonant. The roar of its engine, the precision of its handling, and the exquisite design of its bodywork combined to create a truly special automobile. It was a car that appealed to the senses, offering a blend of raw power and refined luxury that few could match. The F-Type R represented the spirit of classic British sports cars, reinterpreted for the modern era, a compelling choice for those seeking a luxury sports car with serious performance credentials.
Koenigsegg Jesko (Published: June 3, 2020)
The Koenigsegg Jesko is a hypercar in the truest sense of the word, pushing the boundaries of speed, technology, and design to their absolute limits. Engineered with an obsessive focus on performance, the Jesko boasts an astronomical power output and aerodynamic sophistication that is truly breathtaking. It’s not just about straight-line speed; it’s about creating a vehicle that can conquer any track with unparalleled agility and precision. The Jesko represents the pinnacle of exotic car performance, a rare and extraordinary machine born from an unwavering dedication to engineering excellence and a vision for what the ultimate performance vehicle can be.
Lamborghini Huracán Performante (Published: January 10, 2018)
The Lamborghini Huracán Performante is a raw and visceral supercar that prioritizes driver engagement and track-day prowess. Its naturally aspirated V10 engine delivers a glorious soundtrack and explosive acceleration, while its advanced aerodynamics and lightweight construction contribute to astonishing agility and grip. The Performante is a car that demands and rewards driver input, offering an intoxicating blend of performance and emotion. It stands as a testament to Lamborghini’s commitment to crafting high-performance vehicles that deliver an uncompromised and exhilarating driving experience, a true icon of the supercar world.
Lamborghini Sián FKP 37 (Published: October 2, 2019)
The Lamborghini Sián FKP 37 is a hybrid hypercar that pushes the boundaries of what’s possible. Combining Lamborghini’s signature V12 engine with a mild-hybrid system, the Sián delivers electrifying acceleration and a unique driving experience. Its wild styling and advanced technology make it a true head-turner and a significant step forward for the brand, showcasing its dedication to exploring hybrid powertrains within its luxury hypercar portfolio. It’s a bold statement of intent for the future of extreme performance, blending raw power with cutting-edge innovation.
McLaren 720S (Published: June 14, 2017)
The McLaren 720S redefined the supercar landscape upon its release. Its revolutionary Monocage II construction, incredibly potent twin-turbocharged V8 engine, and advanced aerodynamics combine to create a car that is both astonishingly fast and remarkably agile. The 720S delivers a driving experience that is utterly captivating, offering a level of performance and driver feedback that is second to none. It’s a benchmark for modern supercars, showcasing McLaren’s engineering prowess and its unwavering focus on creating driver-centric machines that deliver unparalleled thrills.
Mercedes-AMG A45 S (Published: November 20, 2019)
The Mercedes-AMG A45 S is the undisputed king of the hot hatch segment. Its handcrafted AMG 2.0-liter engine, the most powerful production four-cylinder in the world, delivers blistering acceleration and an aggressive, exhilarating driving experience. Combined with AMG’s legendary performance tuning and all-wheel-drive system, the A45 S offers supercar-rivalling performance in a compact, practical package. It’s a testament to AMG’s ability to imbue even a compact car with immense power and dynamic prowess, making it a benchmark for performance compact cars and a truly thrilling proposition for enthusiasts.
Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S E Performance (Published: January 20, 2022)
The Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S E Performance represents the apex of AMG’s engineering ambition, blending a ferocious V8 engine with a high-performance electric powertrain. This plug-in hybrid flagship sedan delivers electrifying acceleration and a sublime driving experience, combining the raw power of AMG with the efficiency and instant torque of electric propulsion. It’s a technological marvel, pushing the boundaries of what a four-door performance car can achieve, setting new benchmarks for hybrid performance sedans and offering a glimpse into the electrifying future of AMG.
Porsche 911 (992) Carrera S (Published: January 15, 2020)
The latest generation Porsche 911 Carrera S (992) continues the legendary legacy of this iconic sports car. While outwardly evolutionary, it’s a revolutionary leap in refinement, performance, and technology. The turbocharged flat-six engine delivers potent power, perfectly complemented by the chassis’s incredible balance and driver feedback. Porsche’s uncanny ability to evolve the 911 while retaining its core character is unparalleled, making the Carrera S a benchmark for sports cars worldwide and a consistently five-star performer. It offers an intoxicating blend of everyday usability and track-day capability, a testament to decades of continuous development.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S (Published: October 23, 2019)
The Porsche Taycan Turbo S is a groundbreaking electric vehicle that shatters preconceived notions of what an EV can be. It delivers blistering acceleration, impressive range, and a driving experience that is unmistakably Porsche – engaging, precise, and utterly thrilling. The Taycan Turbo S showcases Porsche’s mastery of performance engineering, proving that electric power can deliver the emotional connection and dynamic capability that enthusiasts crave. It has set a new standard for electric sports cars and demonstrates the exciting potential of electrified performance.
Rimac Nevera (Published: June 1, 2022)
The Rimac Nevera is a hypercar that exists on the bleeding edge of automotive technology. This all-electric marvel boasts staggering acceleration figures and a level of performance that redefines the hypercar segment. It is a testament to human ingenuity and relentless engineering, showcasing the immense potential of electric powertrains when pushed to their absolute limits. The Nevera is not just a car; it’s a technological statement, pushing the boundaries of what’s possible in the pursuit of ultimate automotive performance. It represents the zenith of electric hypercar development and a bold vision for the future of speed.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk8) (Published: March 11, 2020)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk8) continues its reign as the quintessential hot hatch, a benchmark for accessible performance and everyday usability. While subtle in its evolution, the Mk8 GTI refines the recipe with sharper handling, improved interior technology, and the same engaging driving dynamics that have made it a legend. It’s a car that perfectly balances spirited performance with practicality, making it an ideal choice for both enthusiastic drivers and those seeking a versatile everyday car. The Golf GTI remains a leader in the compact performance car market, a testament to its enduring appeal and Volkswagen’s commitment to perfecting this iconic formula.
The Enduring Quest for Automotive Excellence
These 21 vehicles, recognized for their exceptional quality and performance, represent the very best of the past decade. They are machines that have not only met our rigorous standards but have surpassed them, offering driving experiences that are truly unforgettable. As the automotive industry continues its rapid evolution, we at Autocar remain committed to identifying and celebrating the vehicles that embody the pinnacle of engineering, design, and driving pleasure.
Whether you are an avid car enthusiast seeking the ultimate driving machine, a discerning buyer looking for unparalleled quality and performance, or simply someone who appreciates the art of automotive engineering, this list serves as a guide to the truly exceptional.
The journey towards automotive perfection is an ongoing one. We encourage you to explore these outstanding models further, perhaps by seeking out a test drive or delving deeper into their specifications. Your next truly remarkable automotive experience might be just around the corner.
