The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Cars Unveiled
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive journalism, meticulously dissecting and evaluating vehicles to guide discerning buyers. Since our inaugural road test of the Austin Seven in 1928, a model that swiftly ascended to become the United Kingdom’s best-selling automobile, we have subjected thousands of cars to our rigorous scrutiny. Each vehicle undergoes a comprehensive assessment, culminating in an overall score out of a possible five stars. Achieving the coveted full five stars is an exceptionally rare feat, a distinction bestowed upon a mere handful of automobiles each year – typically no more than one or two.
This exclusive compilation represents the zenith of automotive engineering and design from the past decade, bringing together every single vehicle that has earned our highest possible accolade: five out of five stars. This elite gathering comprises just 21 exceptional machines, a testament to their unparalleled quality, performance, and desirability. Embark on this curated journey with us as we delve into the crème de la crème of the automotive world from the last ten years, offering a glimpse into the groundbreaking vehicles that have truly set the benchmark for automotive excellence. For each entry, we will also provide the original publication date of its test, offering context to its groundbreaking status at the time of its release.
Our quest to identify these best cars of the past decade has been driven by an unwavering commitment to providing our readership with the most accurate and insightful automotive critiques. We understand that investing in a new vehicle is a significant decision, and our five-star rating is not awarded lightly. It signifies a car that transcends its contemporaries, offering a holistic package of innovation, driver engagement, practicality, and enduring value.
The Uncompromising Pursuit of the Perfect Drive
The concept of a “perfect” car is, of course, subjective to some degree, influenced by individual needs and preferences. However, certain objective benchmarks consistently emerge when evaluating automotive greatness. These include:
Driving Dynamics: How a car feels on the road is paramount. This encompasses steering precision, brake feel, suspension composure over varied surfaces, and the overall balance and feedback provided to the driver. A five-star car will inspire confidence and elicit genuine enjoyment from behind the wheel, whether navigating tight city streets or tackling an exhilarating mountain pass.
Performance and Powertrain: While not every top-tier car needs to be a supercar, its powertrain must be well-matched to its purpose. This means smooth, responsive acceleration, efficient operation, and an engine that complements the car’s character. For performance-oriented vehicles, outright power and acceleration are crucial, but they must be delivered in a refined and usable manner. The pursuit of electric car performance has seen significant advancements, with many manufacturers now offering EVs that rival or surpass their internal combustion engine counterparts in terms of sheer speed and responsiveness.
Interior Quality and Comfort: The cabin is where occupants spend their time, and its design, materials, and ergonomics are critical. A five-star car will feature premium materials, meticulous craftsmanship, and a comfortable, supportive seating position. Advanced climate control, noise insulation, and intuitive infotainment systems also contribute to an exceptional interior experience. We’ve seen a noticeable shift towards luxury car interiors that prioritize sustainable materials alongside traditional opulence, reflecting evolving consumer values and the growing importance of eco-consciousness in the premium vehicle market.
Technology and Innovation: The automotive landscape is constantly evolving, and innovation plays a key role. A top-rated car will often showcase cutting-edge safety features, advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), and seamless connectivity. Infotainment systems should be user-friendly and integrate effortlessly with personal devices. The integration of AI in automotive technology is rapidly transforming driver assistance, predictive maintenance, and even in-car entertainment, pushing the boundaries of what’s possible in future cars.
Practicality and Usability: Even the most exhilarating sports car must offer a degree of practicality. This includes adequate passenger space, generous luggage capacity, and ease of ingress and egress. For family cars, these aspects are even more critical. A five-star vehicle strikes a harmonious balance between its primary function and everyday usability.
Reliability and Durability: While our road tests focus on immediate performance and characteristics, a car’s long-term potential for reliability is always an underlying consideration. We favor vehicles from manufacturers with a proven track record for building robust and dependable automobiles. The rise of certified pre-owned cars also speaks to the enduring value and reliability of well-built vehicles from reputable brands.
Value for Money: While price is a factor, true value extends beyond the sticker price. A five-star car offers an ownership experience that justifies its cost, considering its performance, features, build quality, and potential for strong resale value. In the current market, understanding car depreciation rates is crucial for buyers looking to maximize their investment, and our featured vehicles typically demonstrate excellent long-term value retention.
The Elite Circle: A Decade of Automotive Stardom
The following vehicles, presented in alphabetical order, have not only met but exceeded these stringent criteria, earning the ultimate commendation from Autocar’s expert reviewers. Their inclusion is a testament to their exceptional engineering, visionary design, and the sheer joy they deliver to their owners.
Aston Martin DBS Superleggera (Published: August 29, 2018)
The Aston Martin DBS Superleggera represents the pinnacle of grand touring performance, a potent blend of brutal power and exquisite refinement. Its 5.2-liter twin-turbo V12 engine unleashes a formidable 715 horsepower, propelling the Superleggera from 0 to 60 mph in a mere 3.4 seconds. Yet, it’s not just about raw speed. The chassis is a masterclass in balance, offering a compliant ride for long-distance journeys while providing an engaging and communicative experience when the driver decides to exploit its considerable capabilities. The exterior design is breathtakingly sculpted, a flowing, aerodynamic form that is both aggressive and elegant. Inside, the cabin exudes Aston Martin’s signature blend of luxury and sporting intent, with hand-stitched leather and meticulously crafted carbon fiber accents. For those seeking the ultimate statement in performance luxury and a truly exhilarating sports car experience, the DBS Superleggera stands as a magnificent achievement. The high-performance car market continues to be dominated by such masterpieces, offering an escape from the ordinary.
Audi e-tron GT (Published: October 27, 2021)
The Audi e-tron GT is a bold declaration of intent from the Ingolstadt-based manufacturer, proving that electric vehicles can be as desirable and exciting as their gasoline-powered counterparts. This sleek four-door coupe combines electrifying performance with avant-garde design and Audi’s renowned interior quality. Its dual electric motors produce a combined output of 469 horsepower (in standard guise, with a more potent RS variant available), delivering instant torque and effortless acceleration. The sophisticated all-wheel-drive system, known as quattro, ensures tenacious grip and composure through corners. The e-tron GT’s range is also impressive, making it a viable and compelling option for those transitioning to electric vehicle ownership. Its low-slung profile, aggressive stance, and minimalist yet luxurious interior showcase Audi’s forward-thinking approach to future car design. The success of the e-tron GT has solidified Audi’s position as a leader in the premium electric car segment, showcasing how performance and sustainability can coexist.
Bentley Continental GT Speed (Published: May 12, 2021)
The Bentley Continental GT Speed is the embodiment of luxurious power, a grand tourer that effortlessly blends blistering performance with unparalleled comfort and craftsmanship. Beneath its imposing yet elegantly sculpted exterior lies a monstrous 6.0-liter W12 TSI engine, tuned to deliver a staggering 650 horsepower and 664 lb-ft of torque. This potent powerplant propels the GT Speed from 0 to 60 mph in a mere 3.9 seconds, a remarkable feat for a car of its size and stature. The “Speed” designation signifies a focus on dynamic prowess, with a retuned chassis and suspension that offer sharper handling without compromising the signature Bentley waft. The interior is a sanctuary of opulence, featuring the finest materials, from hand-stitched leather to ethically sourced wood veneers. The Continental GT Speed is more than just a car; it’s an experience, a statement of success and a testament to the enduring appeal of luxury grand tourers. For those seeking the ultimate in luxury car performance, Bentley continues to set the standard.
BMW M3 Competition Touring (Published: March 16, 2022)
The BMW M3 Competition Touring is a game-changer, proving that a high-performance estate car can deliver the thrills and agility of its sedan sibling without significant compromise. This is the first-ever M3 estate, and it hits the mark with astonishing accuracy. Powered by a potent 3.0-liter twin-turbocharged inline-six engine producing 503 horsepower, it rockets from 0 to 60 mph in just 3.6 seconds, while retaining the practicality expected of a touring model. The intelligent xDrive all-wheel-drive system, with its rear-biased setup, offers an engaging and adjustable driving experience, allowing drivers to tailor the car’s behavior to their preferences. The chassis is meticulously engineered to handle the power, providing exceptional grip and body control. The M3 Competition Touring is a masterclass in blending everyday usability with track-day capability, a highly sought-after combination in the performance estate car market. It represents a significant evolution in BMW M cars, offering a compelling option for enthusiasts who need more space.
Ferrari 296 GTB (Published: December 15, 2021)
The Ferrari 296 GTB is a revolutionary step forward for the legendary Italian marque, ushering in a new era of hybrid performance. This mid-engined marvel combines a compact 3.0-liter twin-turbo V6 engine with a powerful electric motor, creating a formidable plug-in hybrid powertrain that produces a combined output of 830 horsepower. The result is breathtaking acceleration, a symphony of engine notes, and an incredibly engaging driving experience. The 296 GTB’s lightweight construction, advanced aerodynamics, and sophisticated chassis electronics contribute to its incredible agility and precision. The exterior design is a modern interpretation of classic Ferrari lines, blending sensuous curves with functional aerodynamic elements. The interior is driver-focused, luxurious, and technologically advanced. The 296 GTB is a compelling testament to Ferrari’s ability to innovate while staying true to its core values, pushing the boundaries of supercar performance and hybrid technology. It’s a glimpse into the future of supercars.
Ford F-150 Raptor R (Published: November 9, 2022)
The Ford F-150 Raptor R represents the ultimate expression of off-road performance in a production pickup truck. Building upon the already formidable Raptor, the ‘R’ variant injects the supercharged 5.2-liter Predator V8 engine from the Mustang Shelby GT500, delivering a colossal 700 horsepower. This beast is engineered to conquer any terrain, with an ultra-wide track, long-travel suspension featuring Fox shocks, and massive 37-inch tires. The Raptor R’s capability is simply astonishing, whether it’s blasting through desert landscapes or crawling over challenging rock formations. Beyond its off-road prowess, the cabin offers a comfortable and well-equipped environment for long excursions. The F-150 Raptor R is not just a truck; it’s a statement of intent for extreme capability and a dream for off-road enthusiasts. It exemplifies the pinnacle of performance truck engineering and the enduring appeal of the Ford F-150 legacy, especially within the off-road truck market.
Genesis GV60 (Published: July 6, 2022)
The Genesis GV60 is a refreshing and exciting entry into the premium electric SUV segment. Built on a dedicated EV platform, the GV60 boasts a distinctive design, a luxurious and feature-rich interior, and a compelling performance profile. Available in dual-motor all-wheel-drive configurations, it offers spirited acceleration and a comfortable ride. What sets the GV60 apart is its focus on delightful details and innovative features, such as the crystal sphere gear selector and the Face Connect system. Genesis has successfully translated its commitment to luxury and craftsmanship into the electric age, creating a vehicle that feels truly special and offers excellent value. The GV60 is a strong contender for those seeking a stylish, comfortable, and technologically advanced electric SUV that stands out from the crowd, representing a significant step for Genesis electric vehicles.
Honda Civic Type R (FK8 Generation) (Published: January 25, 2017)
While this generation of the Civic Type R has since been superseded, its inclusion here speaks volumes about its groundbreaking impact and enduring excellence. The FK8 generation Civic Type R, with its aggressive styling and formidable 2.0-liter VTEC Turbo engine producing 306 horsepower, redefined the hot hatchback segment. Its razor-sharp handling, exceptional steering feedback, and track-ready performance made it a darling of driving enthusiasts. The bold aerodynamics, including the prominent rear wing, weren’t just for show; they contributed significantly to its downforce and stability at high speeds. The manual gearbox was a joy to operate, further enhancing the driver’s connection to the machine. The Type R demonstrated that a front-wheel-drive car could deliver truly exceptional handling and performance, solidifying its status as a benchmark for hot hatchbacks and a testament to Honda’s engineering prowess. It remains a highly sought-after vehicle in the performance car market.
Hyundai Ioniq 5 (Published: September 15, 2021)
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 is a groundbreaking electric vehicle that has reshaped expectations for mainstream EVs. Its retro-futuristic design, inspired by the Pony concept car, is a breath of fresh air in a segment often criticized for its homogeneity. Beneath its distinctive exterior lies a sophisticated EV platform offering impressive range, rapid charging capabilities, and a spacious, minimalist interior. The Ioniq 5 provides a comfortable and refined driving experience, with brisk acceleration from its electric powertrains. Its innovative features, such as the vehicle-to-load (V2L) function, which allows the car to power external devices, showcase Hyundai’s commitment to pushing the boundaries of EV utility. The Ioniq 5 has rightfully earned its place among the elite, proving that practical family cars can also be stylish, technologically advanced, and environmentally conscious. It is a leading example in the affordable electric car segment and a triumph for Hyundai electric cars.
Jaguar I-PACE (Published: March 14, 2018)
The Jaguar I-PACE was a pioneering force in the premium electric SUV market, arriving with a blend of Jaguar’s signature sporting DNA, elegant design, and advanced electric powertrain technology. Its sleek coupe-like silhouette, coupled with a spacious and luxurious interior, made it an attractive proposition. The dual electric motors deliver immediate torque and impressive acceleration, while the sophisticated all-wheel-drive system provides sure-footed handling. The I-PACE’s chassis tuning emphasizes a balance between comfort and agility, offering a refined yet engaging driving experience. As one of the early entrants into the luxury electric SUV space, the I-PACE demonstrated Jaguar’s commitment to electrification and its ability to translate its brand values into the EV era. It remains a compelling choice for those seeking a stylish and dynamic premium electric crossover, a cornerstone of Jaguar electric vehicles.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO RWD (Published: February 12, 2020)
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO RWD is a purist’s dream, stripping back the all-wheel-drive complexity of its siblings to deliver a more raw and engaging driving experience. Powered by a thunderous 5.2-liter naturally aspirated V10 engine producing 610 horsepower, it offers an intoxicating blend of sound and fury. The rear-wheel-drive setup, combined with advanced torque vectoring and electronic stability control, allows for spectacular slides and a deeply communicative connection to the road. The EVO RWD is a masterclass in sensory engagement, demanding driver input and rewarding skillful control. Its aggressive styling is unmistakably Lamborghini, and the cabin, while driver-focused, offers a blend of sportiness and necessary appointments. For those who crave an unfiltered supercar experience, the Huracán EVO RWD is an exceptional machine, a true embodiment of Lamborghini performance and the allure of naturally aspirated engines.
Lotus Emira (Published: October 27, 2021)
The Lotus Emira represents a pivotal moment for the historic British marque, marking its final gasoline-powered sports car before transitioning to full electrification. This stunning machine blends exotic supercar looks with everyday usability, a rare combination. Powered by a choice of engines, including a potent supercharged V6 and a new AMG-sourced turbocharged inline-four, the Emira promises exhilarating performance. Its lightweight construction, mid-engined layout, and sophisticated chassis dynamics are hallmarks of Lotus engineering, promising a driving experience that is both thrilling and precise. The interior is a significant step up in refinement and technology for Lotus, offering a more contemporary and luxurious environment. The Emira stands as a poignant and beautiful swansong for an era, a captivating new sports car that honors Lotus’s legacy while looking towards the future. It’s a key vehicle in understanding the future of Lotus cars.
Mercedes-AMG GT Black Series (Published: September 9, 2020)
The Mercedes-AMG GT Black Series is an extreme machine, a road-legal race car designed for ultimate track performance. Its 4.0-liter twin-turbo V8 engine is significantly re-engineered, producing a blistering 720 horsepower and 590 lb-ft of torque, making it the most powerful V8 engine ever fitted to a production Mercedes-AMG. The aerodynamics are extreme, with a massive rear wing, aggressive front splitter, and numerous vents and louvers that generate significant downforce. The chassis is equally focused, featuring a flat-plane crankshaft engine, adaptive coil-over suspension, and a sophisticated braking system. The GT Black Series delivers a visceral and uncompromising driving experience, pushing the boundaries of what’s possible on a circuit. It is a testament to AMG’s dedication to motorsport and a dream machine for track enthusiasts, representing the pinnacle of AMG performance and a significant entry in the track-focused car segment.
Mercedes-Benz EQS 450+ (Published: May 19, 2021)
The Mercedes-Benz EQS 450+ signifies a new era of luxury electric sedans, setting an exceptionally high bar for refinement, technology, and comfort. As the electric equivalent of the S-Class, the EQS offers a serene and opulent experience. Its aerodynamic design, with a drag coefficient of just 0.20, contributes to its impressive range and quiet operation. The MBUX Hyperscreen, a sweeping dashboard display stretching across the entire width of the car, is a technological marvel that offers intuitive control over virtually all functions. The electric powertrain delivers smooth, potent acceleration, making for effortless cruising. The interior is a sanctuary of calm, featuring premium materials and exquisite craftsmanship. The EQS 450+ embodies the future of luxury electric sedans and showcases Mercedes-Benz’s vision for premium automotive technology. It’s a benchmark for sustainable luxury vehicles.
Porsche 911 GT3 (992 Generation) (Published: March 10, 2021)
The Porsche 911 GT3 (992 generation) is, for many, the ultimate expression of the iconic 911 formula. It distills the essence of motorsport into a road-legal package. Powered by a sublime 4.0-liter naturally aspirated flat-six engine, it revs to an exhilarating 9,000 rpm, producing 503 horsepower and an intoxicating soundtrack. The GT3 is available with a manual gearbox, further enhancing driver engagement, or a lightning-fast PDK automatic. The chassis is a masterpiece of engineering, offering unparalleled grip, feedback, and adjustability. The distinctive rear wing and aerodynamic enhancements contribute to its formidable track performance. The 911 GT3 is a car that demands to be driven, rewarding skill and precision with an unparalleled driving experience. It is a benchmark for performance sports cars and a testament to Porsche’s unwavering commitment to driving purity. For many, it’s the ultimate driving experience car.
Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo (Published: July 28, 2021)
The Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo expands the appeal of the groundbreaking Taycan electric sedan, blending its electrifying performance with increased practicality and rugged styling. This all-electric estate car offers a higher ride height, protective cladding, and a more versatile interior, making it suitable for a wider range of adventures. The dual electric motors deliver blistering acceleration and all-wheel-drive traction, while the sophisticated chassis provides a composed and engaging ride, as expected from Porsche. The Cross Turismo retains the Taycan’s luxurious and high-tech interior, complete with the impressive infotainment system. It represents Porsche’s successful entry into the electric performance car market and its ability to create EVs that deliver on the brand’s core values. The Taycan Cross Turismo is a compelling choice for those seeking a sporty, practical, and sustainable electric crossover.
Rimac Nevera (Published: June 9, 2022)
The Rimac Nevera is a revolutionary hypercar that redefines the boundaries of electric performance. Hand-built in Croatia, this all-electric machine is an engineering tour de force, boasting four independent electric motors producing a staggering 1,914 horsepower and 1,740 lb-ft of torque. The result is simply mind-bending acceleration; it can sprint from 0 to 60 mph in under two seconds, making it one of the fastest production cars ever created. Beyond its raw power, the Nevera features an advanced carbon-fiber chassis, sophisticated aerodynamics, and cutting-edge battery technology. The interior is a blend of luxury and performance, with bespoke materials and a minimalist, driver-focused design. The Nevera is not just a hypercar; it’s a statement of what’s possible with electrification, pushing the envelope of electric hypercar technology and setting new benchmarks for automotive innovation. It’s a glimpse into the extreme potential of EV technology.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (Published: August 16, 2017)
The Tesla Model 3 Performance, even in its earlier iterations, demonstrated the disruptive power of electric vehicles in the mainstream market. Its combination of blistering acceleration (0 to 60 mph in under 3.5 seconds), impressive range, and minimalist, tech-focused interior made it a standout. Tesla’s relentless pursuit of software updates and over-the-air improvements meant the Model 3 Performance continually evolved, enhancing its driving dynamics and features. The instant torque provided by its dual electric motors offered an exhilarating driving experience, while its practical sedan body style and growing Supercharger network made it a compelling choice for everyday use. The Model 3 Performance was instrumental in proving that electric cars could be both desirable and practical, significantly impacting the electric sedan market and accelerating the adoption of Tesla vehicles.
Toyota GR Yaris (Published: September 2, 2020)
The Toyota GR Yaris is a rally-bred hot hatch that has taken the automotive world by storm. Developed by Gazoo Racing, Toyota’s motorsport division, this three-door marvel is a homologation special, meaning it was created to allow Toyota to compete in the World Rally Championship. Powered by a unique 1.6-liter turbocharged three-cylinder engine producing 257 horsepower, it boasts a compact but potent powertrain. Its advanced all-wheel-drive system, with switchable front and rear differentials, offers exceptional grip and agility. The GR Yaris delivers a raw, engaging, and incredibly fun driving experience, punching well above its weight in terms of performance and handling. It is a testament to Toyota’s commitment to driving enjoyment and a clear demonstration of their motorsport expertise, solidifying its status as a modern icon in the hot hatch segment and a celebrated example of Toyota performance cars.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk8) (Published: October 21, 2020)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI, a perennial favorite, continues its reign as the benchmark for the front-wheel-drive hot hatch segment with its Mk8 iteration. While retaining the core GTI DNA of approachable performance and everyday usability, the Mk8 introduces a sharper design and a more digitally focused interior. The 2.0-liter turbocharged engine delivers a healthy 245 horsepower, providing brisk acceleration and the characteristic GTI verve. The chassis has been refined to offer a dynamic and engaging driving experience, with excellent body control and communicative steering. The interior, while featuring a minimalist aesthetic with touch-sensitive controls, offers a comfortable and modern environment. The Golf GTI Mk8 remains a compelling proposition for those seeking a practical yet exhilarating daily driver, a true icon in the Volkswagen Golf lineup and a continued leader in the compact performance car class.
A Continuing Legacy of Excellence
These 21 vehicles represent the absolute pinnacle of automotive achievement over the past decade, each a masterclass in engineering, design, and driver engagement. They are the cars that have captivated our expert reviewers and earned the ultimate endorsement: five stars.
As the automotive industry continues its rapid evolution, driven by advancements in electrification, autonomous technology, and sustainable materials, we remain committed to identifying and celebrating the vehicles that truly push the boundaries of what’s possible. Our mission is to provide you with the insights and expertise needed to navigate this exciting landscape and make informed decisions about your next vehicle.
Whether you are in the market for a thrilling sports car, a luxurious electric sedan, a practical family SUV, or a go-anywhere off-road machine, the vehicles we have highlighted offer a glimpse into the highest echelon of automotive design and performance. We encourage you to explore these remarkable machines further, research their capabilities, and perhaps even experience them firsthand. Your next unforgettable driving experience might just be a test drive away.
