The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: Unveiling the Elite Cars Earning Autocar’s Coveted Five-Star Rating Over the Last Decade
For nearly a century, Autocar has stood as a beacon of automotive authority, meticulously dissecting and evaluating vehicles from every corner of the globe. Our rigorous road tests, a tradition dating back to 1928 with the inaugural assessment of the remarkably popular Austin Seven, have set the standard for discerning consumers and industry insiders alike. This unwavering commitment to comprehensive evaluation means that achieving our highest accolade – a perfect five-star rating – is an extraordinary feat, reserved for only the most exceptional machines to grace our testing grounds. In the past ten years, a mere 21 vehicles have ascended to this elite echelon, representing the absolute zenith of automotive engineering, design, and driving dynamism.
As seasoned observers of the automotive landscape, we understand that true excellence transcends mere functionality. It’s a holistic experience, a symphony of performance, innovation, comfort, and soul. This exclusive collection isn’t simply a list; it’s a curated chronicle of automotive masterpieces that have resonated deeply with our expert panel, demonstrating a mastery that few can attain. We’ve delved into our archives to present these celebrated vehicles, offering a glimpse into the standards that define the very best in luxury car reviews, performance car evaluations, and new car testing. Our focus remains on delivering independent car reviews, providing unbiased insights into the vehicles that truly push the boundaries of what’s possible on four wheels.
The quest for the ultimate driving machine is a perpetual one, a journey we embark on with each new model that enters the market. While many vehicles impress, a select few capture our imagination, eliciting that rare, unreserved endorsement. These are the cars that don’t just meet expectations; they shatter them. They redefine segments, set benchmarks for rivals, and leave an indelible mark on the automotive history books. In a world saturated with automotive options, identifying true automotive brilliance requires a discerning eye and an experienced hand. Our ten years of top-rated car reviews have distilled this immense pool into a collection that truly embodies the best cars of the decade.
When we speak of a five-star rating from Autocar, we’re referring to an unblemished score achieved through an exhaustive and multifaceted evaluation process. This isn’t a subjective whim; it’s the culmination of countless hours behind the wheel, subjected to a battery of objective tests measuring everything from acceleration and braking prowess to ride comfort, handling precision, and fuel efficiency. Beyond the quantifiable metrics, our experts meticulously assess the intangible qualities that elevate a car from merely good to truly great: the tactility of the controls, the intuitiveness of the infotainment system, the serenity of the cabin, and the overall emotional connection forged between driver and machine. This dedication to thoroughness is what makes our car review process unparalleled and our five-star recipients so noteworthy.
The automotive industry is in a constant state of flux, particularly in recent years with the rapid advancements in electric vehicle (EV) technology and autonomous driving systems. Our assessments reflect these evolving trends, ensuring that our evaluations remain relevant and forward-looking. A five-star car in 2025 must not only excel in traditional performance metrics but also embrace sustainable innovation and intelligent integration of new technologies. This dynamic approach to EV reviews and car technology assessments ensures that our readers receive the most accurate and insightful guidance possible when considering their next automotive investment. We are committed to providing expert automotive analysis that keeps pace with the relentless march of progress.
Let’s embark on a journey through the past decade, revisiting the extraordinary machines that have earned the ultimate praise from Autocar. These are the cars that have not only satisfied our demanding criteria but have consistently exceeded them, solidifying their place in the annals of automotive greatness. Each entry represents a distinct triumph, a testament to the vision, engineering prowess, and unwavering pursuit of perfection by their respective manufacturers. Our road test methodology is designed to uncover these gems, ensuring that only the truly exceptional receive our highest commendation.
The Elite Twenty-One: A Decade of Five-Star Automotive Achievements
In alphabetical order, to ensure an impartial presentation of these automotive titans, here are the 21 vehicles that have achieved the pinnacle of Autocar’s road-testing accolades over the past ten years. Each entry is accompanied by the publication date of its original review, offering a temporal context to its excellence.
Aston Martin DB11 (Published: October 26, 2016)
The Aston Martin DB11 wasn’t just a car; it was a statement. Representing a bold new era for the iconic British marque, it beautifully blended potent performance with exquisite Grand Tourer luxury. Its muscular V12 engine delivered a soundtrack befitting its predatory looks, while the chassis offered a supple yet engaging ride, making long journeys both exhilarating and effortless. The interior was a masterclass in opulent craftsmanship, with exquisite materials and a sophisticated, driver-focused layout. The DB11 proved that a performance car could also be a sanctuary, a harmonious blend of power and poise. Its success highlighted the enduring appeal of beautifully engineered, powerful GTs, a segment where Aston Martin car evaluations consistently set a high bar.
Aston Martin Vantage (V8) (Published: March 8, 2017)
Following in the illustrious footsteps of the DB11, the V8 Vantage proved that Aston Martin could deliver a more compact and agile, yet equally compelling, sports car experience. Its potent V8 engine provided searing acceleration, while its sophisticated suspension and chassis tuning delivered razor-sharp handling and an intoxicating connection to the road. The Vantage offered a more visceral and driver-centric experience than its larger sibling, proving that sports car reviews at the highest level demand a perfect balance of power, agility, and feedback. Its inclusion underscores Aston Martin’s ability to cater to a diverse range of discerning drivers.
Audi R8 V10 Plus (Published: October 26, 2016)
The Audi R8 V10 Plus was, and remains, a supercar icon. Its naturally aspirated V10 engine, shared with Lamborghini, delivered a symphonic roar and breathtaking performance, propelling the R8 from 0-60 mph in a blur. Yet, what truly set it apart was its incredible usability. Audi’s engineering brilliance made this exotic machine surprisingly docile in everyday driving, a testament to its superb all-wheel-drive system and sophisticated chassis. It was a supercar that could be driven to the shops as easily as it could be tracked, a rare feat in the world of supercar testing. This remarkable duality cemented its place among the very best.
Bentley Continental GT Speed (Published: July 4, 2018)
The Bentley Continental GT Speed is the epitome of opulent power. This was a car designed to devour miles in supreme comfort and with effortless authority. Its colossal W12 engine provided immense torque, pushing the substantial coupe forward with relentless momentum. Yet, despite its size, the GT Speed handled with surprising agility, its sophisticated suspension system ironing out imperfections and keeping the car planted. Inside, the craftsmanship was second to none, a bespoke sanctuary of leather, wood, and polished metal. It redefined what a luxury grand tourer could be, offering an unparalleled blend of performance and prestige. Our Bentley car reviews consistently highlight their commitment to unparalleled luxury.
BMW M3 Competition (G80) (Published: January 13, 2021)
The M3 has always been a benchmark for performance sedans, and the G80 Competition generation cemented that legacy. It packed a ferociously powerful twin-turbo straight-six engine, capable of delivering breathtaking acceleration. However, it was the chassis tuning that truly impressed our testers, offering a level of agility and driver engagement rarely found in a car of its size and practicality. The ability to switch between docile commuter and track-ready weapon was astounding, making it a standout in the performance sedan segment. This generation showcased BMW’s commitment to delivering exhilarating driving dynamics within a practical package.
BMW M5 Competition (Published: August 15, 2018)
The M5 Competition takes the concept of the performance sedan to an even higher stratum. With its potent V8 engine and sophisticated all-wheel-drive system, it offers blistering acceleration and the ability to deploy its power with devastating effectiveness, even in challenging conditions. Yet, it retains the executive refinement and luxury expected of a BMW 5 Series. The M5 Competition demonstrated a masterful blend of raw power and sophisticated technology, making it a formidable force in the executive performance car market. This vehicle proved that a large saloon can also be a supremely capable performance machine.
Ferrari 488 Pista (Published: August 29, 2018)
The Ferrari 488 Pista was, quite simply, a track-focused masterpiece. Stripped of unnecessary weight and optimized for aerodynamic efficiency, it delivered a raw, unadulterated driving experience that bordered on the sublime. Its twin-turbo V8 engine provided ferocious power, and the chassis was tuned to perfection, offering razor-sharp responses and incredible grip. The Pista was a visceral machine, designed to engage the driver on every level and deliver an exhilarating connection to the road. Our Ferrari car reviews often celebrate their dedication to pure driving pleasure, and the Pista was a prime example.
Ferrari SF90 Stradale (Published: September 25, 2020)
The SF90 Stradale represented a seismic shift for Ferrari, ushering in the hybrid era with a car that shattered performance benchmarks. This plug-in hybrid supercar combined a powerful V8 engine with no less than three electric motors, delivering a staggering amount of power and torque. The result was blistering acceleration, incredible tractability, and a glimpse into the future of high-performance motoring. It proved that electrification could enhance, rather than detract from, the supercar experience, earning its place among the best hybrid cars tested.
Ford GT (Published: June 28, 2017)
The Ford GT is a modern-day legend, born from a racing pedigree and engineered for ultimate aerodynamic performance. Its twin-turbo V6 engine delivered prodigious power, but it was the car’s obsessive focus on aerodynamics and lightweight construction that truly set it apart. The GT offered a driving experience that was both visceral and incredibly refined, a testament to Ford’s engineering prowess. It represented a return to form for the GT nameplate, demonstrating a dedication to hypercar performance that impressed our experts.
Honda Civic Type R (FK8) (Published: September 13, 2017)
The Honda Civic Type R has long been a darling of the hot hatch segment, and the FK8 generation was no exception. It offered an intoxicating blend of ferocious performance, razor-sharp handling, and surprising practicality. Its turbocharged engine delivered potent acceleration, and the chassis was tuned for maximum grip and driver engagement. The Type R proved that everyday usability and exhilarating performance could coexist harmoniously, making it a standout in hot hatch reviews. Its ability to offer such a rewarding driving experience at its price point is exceptional.
Lamborghini Aventador SVJ (Published: January 30, 2019)
The Lamborghini Aventador SVJ was the ultimate expression of the brand’s V12 supercar formula. Focused on extreme performance and aerodynamic prowess, it featured active aerodynamics and a chassis tuned for maximum track capability. Its naturally aspirated V12 engine delivered a deafening, glorious soundtrack and stratospheric performance. The SVJ was a sensory overload, a visceral and uncompromising machine that pushed the boundaries of what was thought possible for a road-legal supercar. Our Lamborghini car reviews consistently emphasize their commitment to dramatic performance and aggressive styling, and the SVJ was the zenith of this philosophy.
McLaren 720S (Published: March 15, 2017)
The McLaren 720S redefined supercar performance. Its innovative Monocage II carbon-fiber chassis provided immense strength and lightness, allowing for an incredibly responsive and agile driving experience. The twin-turbo V8 engine delivered prodigious power, but it was the car’s aerodynamic efficiency and sophisticated suspension that allowed it to achieve such remarkable levels of grip and stability. The 720S offered a level of driver engagement and outright speed that was simply breathtaking, solidifying its status among the best performance cars.
McLaren Senna (Published: August 1, 2018)
The McLaren Senna is a no-compromise, track-focused hypercar designed for ultimate performance and driver connection. Every element of its design, from its extreme aerodynamics to its lightweight construction, is geared towards maximizing speed and feedback. The twin-turbo V8 engine delivers ferocious power, and the chassis offers an unparalleled level of grip and responsiveness. The Senna is not for the faint of heart; it is a machine built for those who seek the purest possible driving experience, a testament to McLaren’s track-bred engineering.
Mercedes-AMG A45 S (Published: October 16, 2019)
The Mercedes-AMG A45 S proved that a compact hatchback could deliver supercar-levels of performance. Its ferocious 2.0-liter turbocharged engine, the most powerful production four-cylinder in the world at its launch, provided astonishing acceleration. Combined with AMG’s masterful chassis tuning and sophisticated all-wheel-drive system, the A45 S offered an incredibly engaging and rapid driving experience, all within a practical hatchback body. It set a new benchmark for premium performance hatchbacks.
Mercedes-AMG GT R (Published: September 20, 2017)
The Mercedes-AMG GT R, often dubbed the “Beast of the Green Hell,” was an unapologetically aggressive and track-focused sports car. Inspired by AMG’s GT3 racing program, it featured a highly potent V8 engine, advanced aerodynamics, and a chassis honed for maximum performance on the Nürburgring. The GT R delivered a visceral and exhilarating driving experience, demanding skill and rewarding the driver with immense capability. It was a purebred performance machine that demonstrated AMG’s deep understanding of sports car engineering.
Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS (Published: December 1, 2021)
The Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS represents the ultimate expression of the mid-engined Cayman. Featuring a glorious naturally aspirated flat-six engine derived from the 911 GT3, it delivered an intoxicating soundtrack and ferocious performance. The chassis was extensively revised for track dominance, offering unparalleled agility and driver feedback. This car is a purist’s dream, a testament to Porsche’s unwavering commitment to the art of driving and a highlight in Porsche track car reviews.
Porsche 911 (992) Carrera S (Published: January 15, 2020)
The latest generation of the iconic Porsche 911, the 992 Carrera S, continued to redefine the benchmark for sports cars. It seamlessly blended its legendary rear-engined driving dynamics with significantly enhanced performance, advanced technology, and an even more refined interior. The twin-turbo flat-six engine delivered effortless power, and the chassis offered a sublime balance of grip, agility, and everyday usability. It proved that evolution, when executed with such precision, can lead to perfection, a consistent theme in our new Porsche 911 reviews.
Porsche Taycan Turbo S (Published: October 30, 2019)
The Porsche Taycan Turbo S marked Porsche’s bold entry into the all-electric performance car arena, and it did so with resounding success. This electric sedan delivered blistering acceleration, incredible handling dynamics, and the build quality and refinement expected of a Porsche. It proved that electric vehicles could offer the thrilling driving experience that enthusiasts crave, setting a new standard for high-performance EVs and earning a top spot in our electric car reviews.
Rimac Nevera (Published: November 17, 2021)
The Rimac Nevera is a groundbreaking hypercar that pushes the boundaries of electric vehicle performance. This all-electric marvel boasts four independent electric motors delivering mind-bending acceleration and staggering top speeds. Its advanced technology, bespoke construction, and unparalleled performance capabilities firmly place it in the realm of automotive hyper-performance. The Nevera is a visionary machine, showcasing the extreme potential of electric hypercars and setting a new benchmark for the industry.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (Published: July 25, 2019)
The Tesla Model 3 Performance redefined the concept of an electric performance sedan. It delivered instant torque and exhilarating acceleration, outperforming many traditional sports cars. Beyond its sheer speed, the Model 3 offered a sophisticated interior, advanced technology, and a compelling vision for the future of motoring. It proved that electric cars could be both desirable and incredibly fast, a pivotal moment in the acceptance of performance electric vehicles. Its widespread appeal continues to make it a benchmark in the EV market.
Toyota GR Yaris (Published: October 14, 2020)
The Toyota GR Yaris is a rally-bred hot hatch that has captured the hearts of driving enthusiasts worldwide. Developed with input from professional rally drivers, it boasts a potent turbocharged engine, a sophisticated all-wheel-drive system, and a chassis honed for maximum agility and control. The GR Yaris offers an exhilarating and engaging driving experience, proving that even in the era of electrification, the pure joy of driving a well-engineered internal combustion engine car remains undiminished. It is a testament to Toyota’s commitment to performance car engineering and a standout in the best small performance cars category.
The Pursuit of Automotive Perfection Continues
This curated selection of 21 vehicles represents the absolute zenith of automotive achievement over the past decade, as judged by Autocar’s seasoned experts. Each of these cars has not only met but significantly surpassed our rigorous evaluation criteria, setting new benchmarks for performance, innovation, and driving pleasure. The automotive industry is an ever-evolving landscape, and our commitment to identifying and celebrating the finest examples of automotive engineering remains unwavering.
Whether you are drawn to the raw power of a V12 supercar, the refined luxury of a grand tourer, or the agile precision of a performance hatchback, these five-star vehicles offer a compelling glimpse into the pinnacle of automotive design and execution. We encourage you to explore these models further, delve into their individual road tests, and perhaps even experience them for yourself. The journey to discover the perfect car is a personal one, and we are here to guide you with our expert insights and unwavering dedication to automotive excellence.
Ready to explore the next chapter in automotive innovation? Discover which new models are pushing the boundaries today and find the perfect vehicle to elevate your driving experience. Visit our latest road tests or connect with our team of experts to discuss your automotive aspirations.
