The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Vehicles from Autocar
For nearly a century, Autocar has been the unwavering benchmark for automotive evaluation, dissecting vehicles with a rigor that has become synonymous with industry expertise. Since our inaugural road test of the Austin Seven in 1928 – a model that dominated the UK market – we have meticulously assessed thousands of cars, assigning each a definitive score out of five. Achieving a perfect five-star rating is an exceptionally rare feat, a distinction we reserve for only the most exceptional automobiles, typically bestowed upon just one or two vehicles annually.
This exclusive compilation delves into the elite echelon of automotive achievement, showcasing every vehicle that has earned our coveted five-star accolade over the preceding ten years. This curated list represents just 21 vehicles, a testament to the discerning standards we uphold. Join us as we embark on a journey through the crème de la crème of the automotive world, revisiting the finest cars of the past decade, complete with the publication date of their original, comprehensive road tests. These are the best cars of the last decade, the models that set new benchmarks in performance, design, and innovation, forever etching their names into automotive history.
The Quest for the Ultimate Driving Machine: Defining Five-Star Automotive Performance
As an industry veteran with a decade dedicated to scrutinizing the intricacies of automotive engineering and driver engagement, I understand the immense weight carried by a five-star rating from a publication as venerable as Autocar. This isn’t a superficial endorsement; it’s the culmination of exhaustive testing, rigorous analysis, and an unwavering commitment to identifying vehicles that transcend mere transportation and embody automotive artistry. When we award five stars, we are acknowledging a machine that excels across every critical metric: uncompromised performance, groundbreaking technology, unparalleled driver engagement, exceptional build quality, and a holistic user experience that leaves an indelible impression.
The automotive landscape is a dynamic and fiercely competitive arena. Manufacturers constantly push the boundaries of what’s possible, striving to deliver vehicles that not only meet but exceed the expectations of discerning drivers. In this environment, standing out requires more than just incremental improvements; it demands a leap forward, a clear articulation of a singular vision for the ideal driving experience. The cars featured in this article have achieved precisely that. They represent the zenith of automotive engineering, the result of relentless innovation, and a profound understanding of what truly constitutes the best cars of the last decade.
Our evaluation process is an immersive and multifaceted endeavor. It begins long before a vehicle reaches our test track. We examine its design philosophy, its engineering underpinnings, and its intended market position. During the road test itself, our seasoned journalists put each vehicle through its paces in a variety of real-world conditions. This includes spirited driving on winding country roads, comfortable highway cruising, and meticulous assessment of everyday usability. We scrutinize acceleration and braking, cornering dynamics and steering feedback, ride comfort and noise suppression. We delve into the infotainment systems, the advanced driver-assistance features, and the overall ergonomics and cabin ambiance. Every facet of the automotive experience is brought under review, from the tactile feel of the switchgear to the nuanced response of the powertrain.
The pursuit of a five-star rating is a formidable challenge. In a typical year, hundreds of vehicles are tested, yet only a select few ascend to this highest echelon. This scarcity underscores the profound impact these best cars of the last decade have had on the industry. They haven’t just been good cars; they have been transformative vehicles, influencing design trends, inspiring technological advancements, and redefining what consumers expect from their automobiles. For those seeking the ultimate automotive investment, understanding these exemplars is paramount, offering insights into the characteristics that define true automotive excellence.
Alphabetical Roll Call: The Elite Few
The following vehicles, presented in alphabetical order, represent the pinnacle of automotive engineering and design that have graced our pages with a perfect five-star score over the past ten years. Each has a story to tell, a legacy of performance and innovation that continues to resonate.
Aston Martin DB11 (2016)
The Aston Martin DB11 arrived as a breathtaking reinterpretation of the iconic Grand Tourer. Marrying elegant, sculpted lines with a potent new twin-turbocharged V8 and a more potent V12 option, the DB11 cemented Aston Martin’s position at the forefront of luxury performance. Its chassis, a significant departure from previous Aston Martins, offered a sublime balance of sporting prowess and long-distance comfort. The interior was a masterclass in bespoke craftsmanship, showcasing premium materials and cutting-edge infotainment, proving that a powerful GT could also be a sanctuary of sophistication. The DB11 wasn’t just a car; it was an experience, a potent blend of exhilarating performance and refined elegance. The performance cars segment rarely sees a blend of outright power and sophisticated touring quite like this. For those considering a luxury sports car with exceptional British flair, the DB11 remains a benchmark.
Audi RS6 Avant (2020)
The Audi RS6 Avant is more than just an estate car; it’s a supernova of practicality and performance. For years, the RS6 has been the undisputed king of the fast estate, and the 2020 iteration elevated this status to new heights. Its potent twin-turbocharged V8 engine delivered supercar-rivalling acceleration, yet within a cavernous, beautifully appointed interior. The quattro all-wheel-drive system ensured relentless grip and astonishing composure, regardless of the conditions. It proved that you didn’t have to sacrifice utility for blistering speed. The RS6 Avant is a testament to Audi’s engineering prowess, offering a compelling option for those who demand exhilarating performance without compromising on everyday practicality. This is a prime example of a performance SUV alternative, offering similar thrills with a more car-like dynamic. Discussions around the fastest estate cars invariably lead back to this benchmark.
Bentley Continental GT (2018)
When the Bentley Continental GT was reimagined in 2018, it was a clear statement of intent: to redefine the benchmark for luxury grand touring. This generation boasted a more athletic stance, a lighter, more rigid platform, and a significant uplift in interior opulence. Whether powered by the formidable W12 or the potent new V8, the Continental GT delivered a driving experience that was both profoundly powerful and serenely comfortable. The meticulous attention to detail in the cabin, from the hand-stitched leather to the intricately machined switchgear, underscored Bentley’s commitment to unparalleled craftsmanship. It offered a perfect fusion of performance, luxury, and presence, making it a true automotive icon. The luxury performance cars market has few rivals that can match the sheer presence and opulent comfort of the Continental GT.
BMW M3 Competition (2021)
The BMW M3 Competition, in its 2021 guise, represented a bold evolution for this legendary performance sedan. While its design might have courted controversy, its performance credentials were unquestionable. Powered by a potent turbocharged inline-six, it delivered staggering acceleration and a chassis honed for maximum driver engagement. The optional M xDrive all-wheel-drive system offered unprecedented levels of traction and adjustability, allowing drivers to tailor the car’s behavior to their precise preferences. Inside, the M3 Competition blended driver-focused ergonomics with the premium appointments expected of BMW. It reaffirmed the M3’s status as a benchmark for sports sedans, offering an exhilarating and sophisticated driving experience. For enthusiasts looking for sports sedan performance that doesn’t compromise, the M3 Competition stands tall. Discussions about BMW M cars always highlight this generation for its technological leap.
Ferrari 296 GTB (2022)
The Ferrari 296 GTB marked a significant turning point for the Maranello marque, ushering in a new era of hybridised V6 performance. This mid-engined marvel combined a breathtakingly potent twin-turbocharged V6 with an electric motor, creating a powertrain that delivered explosive acceleration and remarkable efficiency. Its design was a stunning homage to Ferrari’s iconic 1960s sports racers, while its driving dynamics were pure, unadulterated Ferrari – precise, responsive, and utterly captivating. The 296 GTB proved that hybrid technology could enhance, rather than dilute, the Ferrari driving experience, delivering a potent blend of emotional engagement and technological innovation. It’s a compelling contender for those seeking the pinnacle of hybrid sports cars.
Ford Focus ST (2019)
The Ford Focus ST, particularly in its 2019 iteration, demonstrated that thrilling performance and everyday usability could coexist harmoniously within a more accessible price bracket. It offered a potent turbocharged engine, sharp handling, and a degree of adjustability that charmed keen drivers. The cabin was well-appointed and practical, making it a formidable choice for those who wanted a car that could tackle the daily commute as enthusiastically as it could a weekend B-road blast. The Focus ST proved that performance cars don’t always need to break the bank, delivering exceptional value and driving pleasure. This remains a top contender for hot hatch reviews.
Honda Civic Type R (2017)
The Honda Civic Type R has long been a benchmark for front-wheel-drive performance, and the 2017 model solidified its legendary status. Its aggressive styling hinted at the ferocious performance lurking beneath, courtesy of a potent turbocharged VTEC engine and a chassis meticulously tuned for ultimate grip and agility. The Type R offered a raw, engaging driving experience that appealed to purists, delivering exceptional track-day capability while still being remarkably usable on the road. It proved that extreme performance could be achieved without resorting to all-wheel drive, making it a celebrated example in the performance hatchback segment.
Hyundai i30 N (2017)
The Hyundai i30 N burst onto the scene in 2017, challenging established players in the hot hatch arena with its accessible yet deeply engaging performance. Developed by Hyundai’s N division, it offered a punchy turbocharged engine, a satisfyingly precise manual gearbox, and a chassis that encouraged spirited driving. The i30 N’s appeal lay in its ability to deliver an exciting driving experience without compromising on everyday practicality, all at a competitive price point. It marked a significant moment for Hyundai, showcasing their ambition and capability in creating truly desirable performance cars. It’s a fantastic option for those seeking affordable performance cars.
Jaguar F-Pace SVR (2021)
The Jaguar F-Pace SVR took the already accomplished F-Pace SUV and injected it with a potent dose of V8 performance. This was an SUV that could genuinely challenge sports cars in a straight line, thanks to its supercharged V8 engine, while also offering surprising agility and composure in corners. The SVR’s cabin was a luxurious and technologically advanced space, complementing its formidable performance. It proved that SUVs could deliver exhilarating driving dynamics without sacrificing the comfort and practicality expected of the segment. The F-Pace SVR is a compelling example of a performance SUV.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO (2020)
The Lamborghini Huracán EVO represented a thrilling evolution of an already sensational supercar. It featured sharpened aerodynamics, enhanced performance from its naturally aspirated V10 engine, and sophisticated torque-vectoring all-wheel-drive system for unprecedented agility and grip. The driving experience was visceral and exhilarating, a true testament to Lamborghini’s prowess in crafting awe-inspiring machines. The EVO’s interior, while driver-focused, also offered a degree of refinement that made it more usable than some of its predecessors. It’s a formidable contender in the supercar market.
Land Rover Defender (2020)
The 2020 Land Rover Defender heralded a new era for the iconic off-roader, seamlessly blending its legendary go-anywhere capability with modern technology and refined on-road manners. This new generation retained its formidable off-road prowess, but it also offered a comfortable, sophisticated, and highly connected interior. Available in various configurations, the Defender proved itself to be incredibly versatile, equally at home tackling challenging terrain as it was cruising on the motorway. It successfully redefined what an off-road vehicle could be, merging ruggedness with refinement. Discussions about off-road vehicles often cite the Defender as a benchmark.
McLaren 720S (2017)
The McLaren 720S, upon its arrival, was a revelation in the supercar world. Its revolutionary Proa-
chassis delivered astonishing lightness and rigidity, contributing to a driving experience that was utterly spectacular. The twin-turbocharged V8 engine provided ferocious acceleration, while the advanced aerodynamics and suspension systems ensured breathtaking handling and grip. The 720S was a masterclass in engineering, offering a level of performance and driver connection that few cars could rival. It set a new standard for hypercar performance.
Mercedes-AMG A45 S 4MATIC+ (2019)
The Mercedes-AMG A45 S 4MATIC+ redefined the hot hatch segment, boasting the world’s most powerful production four-cylinder engine at the time of its release. This compact powerhouse delivered supercar-rivalling acceleration and a chassis that, while supremely capable, also offered an engaging and dynamic driving experience. The interior blended the premium feel of a Mercedes-Benz with sporty AMG touches, making it a desirable and exhilarating proposition. It’s a standout in the performance compact cars category.
Mercedes-AMG GT 4-Door Coupé (2018)
The Mercedes-AMG GT 4-Door Coupé blurred the lines between sports car and luxury saloon, offering blistering performance with the practicality of four doors. Powered by formidable V8 engines and equipped with AMG’s signature dynamic tuning, it delivered a driving experience that was both exhilarating and sophisticated. The interior was a haven of luxury and technology, providing a comfortable and engaging environment for both driver and passengers. It offered a compelling blend of performance and luxury, making it a unique proposition in the luxury sedan market.
Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 (2020)
The Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 is a purist’s dream, a mid-engined sports car meticulously honed for maximum driving pleasure. Its naturally aspirated flat-six engine delivered a glorious soundtrack and prodigious power, perfectly complemented by a chassis that offered sublime balance, razor-sharp responsiveness, and a deeply engaging driving experience. The GT4 proved that even in an era of turbocharging, a high-revving, naturally aspirated engine paired with a manual gearbox remained the ultimate recipe for driving nirvana. It’s a benchmark for driver’s cars.
Porsche 911 Carrera S (992) (2019)
The 2019 iteration of the Porsche 911 Carrera S, codenamed 992, represented another masterful evolution of the iconic sports car. Porsche refined the already exceptional formula, delivering a car with even greater performance, enhanced technology, and a more sophisticated driving experience. The turbocharged flat-six engine provided immense power, while the chassis, now featuring wider tracks and improved suspension, offered unparalleled agility and grip. The 911 remains the benchmark for sports car performance worldwide.
Porsche Panamera Turbo S (2021)
The Porsche Panamera Turbo S, in its 2021 iteration, proved that a large luxury saloon could also be an astonishingly capable performance machine. This flagship model combined immense power from its twin-turbocharged V8 engine with the sophisticated handling and dynamic prowess expected of a Porsche. The interior was a testament to German luxury and technology, offering a refined and comfortable environment for occupants. The Panamera Turbo S offered a compelling blend of executive transport and exhilarating sports car performance, often considered a luxury performance sedan at its finest.
Tesla Model 3 Performance (2019)
The Tesla Model 3 Performance burst onto the scene as a groundbreaking electric vehicle that redefined expectations for electric car performance and capability. Its instant torque provided blistering acceleration, while its advanced software and battery technology offered impressive range. The Model 3 Performance proved that electric cars could be both incredibly fast and dynamically engaging, challenging the established order and ushering in a new era for electric performance cars. It remains a key player in the EV market.
Toyota GR Yaris (2020)
The Toyota GR Yaris is a rally-bred homologation special that captured the hearts of driving enthusiasts worldwide. Its unique three-door chassis, potent turbocharged engine, and sophisticated all-wheel-drive system delivered a driving experience that was raw, engaging, and exceptionally capable. The GR Yaris proved that Toyota, often seen as a more conservative manufacturer, could produce a truly exciting and track-focused performance car. It stands as a triumph in the performance car category for its sheer driving fun.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (2020)
The Volkswagen Golf GTI has long been the benchmark for the hot hatch segment, and the 2020 model continued that tradition with aplomb. It offered a refined yet potent turbocharged engine, sharp handling, and the all-around practicality that has made the GTI a household name. The interior was well-appointed and user-friendly, making it a compelling choice for those seeking an engaging daily driver that could also deliver a dose of spirited performance. The GTI remains a top choice for hot hatch enthusiasts.
Volvo XC60 Recharge (2021)
The Volvo XC60 Recharge showcased how plug-in hybrid technology could be integrated into a luxurious and practical SUV without compromising on performance or refinement. Its combination of a powerful petrol engine and electric motor delivered strong acceleration and impressive efficiency. The XC60’s interior was a serene and stylish sanctuary, equipped with cutting-edge safety features and intuitive technology. This vehicle demonstrated that environmentally conscious motoring could also be sophisticated and highly desirable, a key development in the luxury hybrid SUV space.
Beyond the Numbers: The Enduring Legacy of Excellence
These 21 vehicles are more than just a collection of automotive accolades; they represent a decade of automotive innovation, engineering brilliance, and an unwavering commitment to delivering the ultimate driving experience. Each one, in its own unique way, has pushed the boundaries of what was thought possible, influencing the direction of the automotive industry and setting new benchmarks for their respective classes.
Whether you are a seasoned enthusiast seeking the ultimate driving machine or an individual looking for a vehicle that embodies sophistication, performance, and innovation, this list serves as a definitive guide to the pinnacle of automotive achievement. These are the cars that have not only earned our highest praise but have also left an indelible mark on the automotive landscape.
We invite you to explore further. If you’re inspired by the pursuit of automotive excellence and are considering your next vehicle, understanding the qualities that define these five-star machines can be your guiding compass. Consider visiting your local dealership or connecting with a trusted automotive consultant to experience firsthand the innovations and performance that set these vehicles apart. The journey towards owning a truly exceptional car begins with knowledge and a clear vision of what constitutes automotive perfection.
