The Pinnacle of Automotive Excellence: A Decade of Five-Star Vehicles
For nearly a century, Autocar has been the unwavering arbiter of automotive excellence, rigorously putting vehicles through their paces to guide discerning buyers. Our commitment to comprehensive road tests dates back to 1928, when we first evaluated the Austin Seven, a car that held the title of the UK’s best-seller at the time. Since that foundational assessment, we have meticulously scrutinized thousands of vehicles, assigning each a definitive overall score out of a possible five stars. Achieving a perfect score is an exceedingly rare feat; typically, only one or two vehicles per year manage to earn this ultimate commendation.
This exclusive compilation delves into the select group of automobiles that have achieved this unparalleled distinction over the past decade. A mere 21 vehicles have earned the coveted five-star rating in our rigorous testing regime, a testament to their exceptional engineering, performance, and overall desirability. Join us as we embark on a journey through the finest cars of the past ten years, meticulously curated and presented with the publication date of their original review. Each entry represents a benchmark in automotive innovation and driving pleasure, a true embodiment of automotive excellence that sets the standard for luxury car reviews and new car recommendations.
The world of automobiles is a constantly evolving landscape, with manufacturers perpetually pushing the boundaries of what’s possible. From groundbreaking electric powertrains to sophisticated driver-assistance systems, the pace of innovation is relentless. In this environment, identifying truly exceptional vehicles requires a deep understanding of engineering principles, a keen eye for design, and an unwavering commitment to objective evaluation. Autocar’s five-star rating is not merely a number; it represents the culmination of countless hours of driving, testing, and expert analysis, designed to identify vehicles that transcend the ordinary and deliver an unparalleled ownership experience.
When we bestow a five-star rating, it signifies a vehicle that has not only met but demonstrably exceeded our stringent criteria across all key aspects. This includes, but is not limited to, its driving dynamics, powertrain performance, interior comfort and ergonomics, technological integration, safety features, build quality, and overall value proposition. These are vehicles that inspire confidence, deliver exhilarating performance, and provide a sanctuary of refinement for their occupants. They are the cars that automotive enthusiasts dream of, and the models that represent the absolute apex of their respective segments, often becoming sought-after performance car investments.
The Elite Twenty-One: A Masterclass in Automotive Engineering
In alphabetical order, here are the extraordinary vehicles that have earned the ultimate five-star accolade from Autocar in the past ten years, representing the absolute best in automotive engineering and design. These are not just cars; they are rolling masterpieces that have defined their eras and continue to inspire. For those seeking the ultimate in high-performance vehicles and best electric cars, this list offers invaluable insights.
Aston Martin DB11 (October 26, 2016): The Aston Martin DB11 stands as a magnificent embodiment of British automotive elegance and performance. It masterfully blends a potent twin-turbocharged V8 or V12 engine with a chassis tuned for both grand touring comfort and spirited driving. Its exquisite design, a hallmark of Aston Martin’s lineage, is characterized by flowing lines, a distinctive grille, and a confident stance. Inside, the DB11 offers a cabin that is both luxurious and technologically advanced, providing a serene environment for long journeys. The driving experience is one of refined power, with effortless acceleration and a beautifully balanced ride. This car solidified Aston Martin’s position as a purveyor of desirable GTs, making it a compelling option for those seeking luxury grand tourers.
Aston Martin DBS Superleggera (August 15, 2018): Taking the concept of the grand tourer to its most potent expression, the DBS Superleggera represents the zenith of Aston Martin’s performance capabilities in a GT package. The name “Superleggera,” meaning super-light in Italian, hints at the engineering prowess that allows this formidable machine to achieve astonishing speeds with grace. Powered by a thunderous V12 engine, the DBS Superleggera delivers breathtaking acceleration and a visceral driving experience that few cars can match. Its aerodynamic design is not just for show; it actively contributes to its immense stability at high speeds. Within its opulent interior, occupants are treated to bespoke craftsmanship and cutting-edge technology. This is a car that blurs the lines between a supercar and a grand tourer, a true statement of intent for fast luxury cars.
Audi RS6 Avant (March 28, 2019): The Audi RS6 Avant is a triumphant demonstration of practicality meeting blistering performance. It defies conventional wisdom by offering the immense utility of an estate car without compromising the thrilling dynamics expected of a high-performance machine. Under its muscular hood lies a potent twin-turbocharged V8 engine that propels the RS6 Avant from standstill to exhilarating speeds with alarming ease. The Quattro all-wheel-drive system ensures tenacious grip and confidence-inspiring handling in all conditions, making it a formidable performer on both road and track. The interior is a testament to Audi’s renowned build quality and sophisticated design, featuring premium materials and the latest infotainment technology. It’s a car that can effortlessly transport a family and their luggage one moment, and deliver a deeply engaging driving experience the next, earning its reputation as a highly versatile sports estate car.
Bentley Continental GT V8 (December 11, 2019): The Bentley Continental GT V8 represents a more accessible yet still incredibly potent iteration of Bentley’s iconic grand tourer. Swapping the W12 for a muscular V8 engine, it offers a compelling blend of performance, refinement, and efficiency. The V8’s character is spirited yet smooth, delivering effortless acceleration and a sonorous exhaust note that hints at its power. Bentley’s commitment to handcrafted luxury is evident in every detail of the Continental GT’s interior, from the finest leathers to the intricately crafted wood veneers. The driving experience is one of supreme comfort and effortless progress, making it an ideal companion for long-distance journeys or spirited weekend drives. It’s a car that embodies British opulence and engineering prowess, a strong contender for premium grand touring cars.
BMW M3 Competition Touring (July 20, 2022): The arrival of the BMW M3 Competition Touring marked a significant moment for enthusiasts who crave practicality without sacrificing ultimate performance. This is the first-ever M3 estate, and it delivers on the promise of the M division’s legendary driving dynamics within a versatile body style. Powered by a potent inline-six engine, it offers blistering acceleration and the sharp, engaging handling that M cars are renowned for. The all-wheel-drive system with its rear-bias setup allows for a thrilling and adjustable driving experience. The interior is a blend of sporty intent and premium comfort, with supportive seats and advanced technology. The M3 Touring proves that you don’t have to compromise on performance to enjoy the utility of a wagon, making it a highly sought-after performance estate car for families.
Ferrari 296 GTB (March 9, 2022): The Ferrari 296 GTB represents a bold new chapter for the Italian marque, showcasing a groundbreaking plug-in hybrid powertrain that delivers astonishing performance while ushering in a new era of efficiency. This mid-engined supercar boasts a compact but incredibly potent V6 engine paired with an electric motor, producing a combined output that rivals V12s of the past. The driving experience is electrifying, characterized by razor-sharp handling, immediate throttle response, and a unique soundtrack. The design is a breathtaking fusion of aerodynamic efficiency and classic Ferrari aesthetic. Inside, the cockpit is driver-focused, offering a blend of cutting-edge technology and exquisite craftsmanship. The 296 GTB demonstrates Ferrari’s commitment to innovation and its ability to produce some of the most exciting hybrid supercars on the market.
Ford Focus ST (August 1, 2019): The Ford Focus ST has long been a benchmark for affordable hot hatch performance, and the model tested continued this legacy with aplomb. It delivers a wonderfully engaging driving experience thanks to its well-tuned chassis, responsive steering, and potent turbocharged engine. While not the most powerful in its class, the Focus ST offers a superb balance of performance, everyday usability, and value, making it an excellent choice for those seeking an exhilarating daily driver. The interior is practical and well-equipped, offering comfortable seating and modern infotainment. It’s a car that proves that thrilling driving dynamics don’t need to come with an astronomical price tag, cementing its place as a favorite for hot hatch enthusiasts.
Honda Civic Type R (August 2, 2017): The Honda Civic Type R has achieved legendary status among hot hatch aficionados, and the model that received our five-star rating continued this tradition with exceptional flair. It’s a car that prioritizes the driving experience above all else, boasting a rev-happy turbocharged engine, a precise manual gearbox, and a chassis that offers an incredible level of grip and feedback. The aggressive styling is matched by its ferocity on the road, providing an exhilarating and engaging drive that few competitors can match. Despite its track-focused capabilities, the Type R remains surprisingly practical for everyday use, offering a comfortable ride and a well-appointed interior. It remains a benchmark for front-wheel-drive performance.
Jaguar F-Type P450 R-Dynamic Convertible (July 14, 2021): The Jaguar F-Type P450 R-Dynamic Convertible is a captivating blend of raw power, exquisite design, and open-top exhilaration. It embodies the spirit of classic British sports cars with a modern, sophisticated edge. The potent V8 engine delivers thunderous acceleration and a soundtrack that stirs the soul, while the chassis is tuned for agile handling and a rewarding driving experience. The convertible top can be lowered in mere seconds, allowing occupants to fully immerse themselves in the driving pleasure and the surrounding environment. The interior is a luxurious and driver-focused space, crafted with high-quality materials. It’s a car that appeals to the senses, offering a truly visceral and unforgettable experience, making it a compelling choice for luxury sports cars.
Lamborghini Huracán EVO (January 29, 2020): The Lamborghini Huracán EVO is a purebred supercar that delivers an unadulterated dose of Italian passion and performance. Its naturally aspirated V10 engine is a masterpiece of engineering, producing a symphonic roar and relentless acceleration that pushes the boundaries of what’s possible. The chassis is exquisitely tuned for maximum agility and grip, providing an incredibly engaging and communicative driving experience. Visually, the Huracán EVO is a striking piece of automotive art, with sharp angles and an aerodynamic silhouette that commands attention. The interior is driver-centric, with a focus on performance and a sense of occasion. For those seeking the thrill of a naturally aspirated supercar, the Huracán EVO is an exceptional offering.
McLaren 720S (May 10, 2017): The McLaren 720S stands as a monumental achievement in supercar engineering, pushing the boundaries of performance, technology, and driver engagement. Its twin-turbocharged V8 engine delivers otherworldly acceleration, while its advanced aerodynamic package and lightweight construction contribute to its astonishing agility and cornering prowess. The dihedral doors and sleek, purposeful design are instantly recognizable. Inside, the cabin is a masterclass in minimalist design and driver focus, with innovative features like the retractable instrument cluster. The 720S offers a driving experience that is both incredibly fast and surprisingly accessible, making it a benchmark for supercar performance.
Mercedes-AMG C63 S Estate (October 18, 2017): The Mercedes-AMG C63 S Estate represents the ultimate fusion of potent performance and everyday practicality. It’s a car that can comfortably ferry a family and their belongings, yet unleash a torrent of V8 power when the mood strikes. The hand-built AMG V8 engine is a marvel of engineering, delivering ferocious acceleration and a characterful soundtrack. The chassis is expertly tuned to handle the immense power, offering a balance of comfort and dynamic capability. The interior is a luxurious and technologically advanced space, befitting the Mercedes-Benz brand. This estate car proves that you don’t have to compromise on driving pleasure to enjoy the benefits of a larger vehicle, solidifying its reputation as a top-tier performance estate.
Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S 4MATIC+ (January 8, 2019): The Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S 4MATIC+ is a four-door coupe that embodies a unique blend of luxury, performance, and practicality. It’s a car that can compete with traditional sports cars in terms of outright speed and dynamic ability, while also offering the comfort and space required for daily use. The AMG-tuned V8 engine delivers breathtaking acceleration, and the sophisticated all-wheel-drive system ensures that power is deployed effectively. The interior is a lavish and technologically advanced sanctuary, featuring premium materials and a host of innovative features. This car represents the pinnacle of Mercedes-AMG’s engineering prowess, offering a compelling option for those seeking high-performance luxury cars.
Porsche 911 Carrera S (September 6, 2017): The Porsche 911 is an icon, and the Carrera S model tested continued to uphold its legendary status. It represents the quintessential sports car experience, offering a perfect balance of performance, handling, and driver engagement. The rear-mounted, twin-turbocharged flat-six engine delivers potent power and a unique driving character, while the chassis is honed to perfection, providing unparalleled feedback and agility. The driving position is iconic, and the interior, while minimalist, is focused on the driver. The 911 Carrera S is a car that inspires confidence and delivers immense joy, a true testament to Porsche’s unwavering commitment to the driving experience, making it a perennial favorite for sports car enthusiasts and a highly desirable performance car investment.
Porsche 911 GT3 (October 25, 2017): The Porsche 911 GT3 is not merely a car; it’s a track-honed weapon designed for the purest driving experience. It embodies the spirit of motorsport, with its naturally aspirated, high-revving engine delivering searing performance and an intoxicating soundtrack. The chassis is meticulously engineered for maximum grip, precise control, and unparalleled feedback, making it a joy to drive on both road and circuit. The aggressive aerodynamic enhancements are not just for show; they are functional components that contribute to its exceptional performance. The interior, while functional and driver-focused, eschews unnecessary fripperies in favor of weight reduction and a direct connection to the driving environment. This is a car that defines what a track-focused sports car should be.
Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS (December 8, 2021): The Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 RS represents an extreme and exhilarating evolution of the Cayman platform, pushing the boundaries of track-focused performance into new territory. Leveraging a motorsport-derived engine and chassis, it offers a truly visceral and engaging driving experience. The naturally aspirated engine, shared with the 911 GT3, provides intoxicating revs and a spine-tingling soundtrack. Its aerodynamic efficiency is paramount, with extensive use of carbon fiber and a prominent rear wing. The GT4 RS is a lightweight, agile machine that delivers an unparalleled level of connection between driver and machine, making it a dream for those seeking the ultimate track day car.
Renault Sport Clio RS 18 (April 4, 2018): The Renault Sport Clio RS 18 is a testament to the enduring appeal of the hot hatch. It’s a car that punches well above its weight, delivering a driving experience that is both thrilling and incredibly accessible. The turbocharged engine provides eager acceleration, and the chassis is tuned for agility and engagement, making it incredibly fun to drive on winding roads. While it may not possess the outright power of some rivals, its balanced dynamics and sharp handling make it a joy to pilot. The interior is functional and well-equipped for its segment, offering a comfortable and practical space for daily use. It’s a car that prioritizes driver enjoyment above all else, a true icon in the realm of compact performance cars.
Seat Leon Cupra R ST (January 17, 2018): The Seat Leon Cupra R ST is a rare and exceptionally potent combination of a performance estate and exclusive styling. Building upon the already capable Leon Cupra, the R ST variant offers enhanced performance and unique design elements, including a striking copper accent package. Its turbocharged engine delivers formidable power, and the chassis is tuned for dynamic prowess, providing a thrilling yet composed driving experience. The estate body style ensures ample practicality, making it a car that can excel in both spirited driving and everyday tasks. The interior is sporty and well-appointed, reflecting the car’s performance credentials. This is a vehicle that offers a unique proposition for those seeking a blend of power, practicality, and exclusivity, making it a strong contender in the performance wagon segment.
Skoda Octavia vRS (May 8, 2019): The Skoda Octavia vRS has long been a byword for sensible performance, offering a compelling blend of practicality, value, and engaging driving dynamics. The tested model continued this trend with its potent turbocharged engine and well-tuned chassis, providing a genuinely enjoyable driving experience without compromising its everyday usability. The Octavia’s spacious interior and generous boot capacity make it an ideal choice for families or those who need to transport larger items, while the vRS treatment adds a welcome dose of sporty character. It’s a car that offers a complete package, proving that performance and practicality can go hand-in-hand, and remains a benchmark for family performance cars.
Toyota GR Yaris (September 2, 2020): The Toyota GR Yaris is a homologation special that has taken the performance car world by storm. Developed with input from rally experts, it’s a compact hatchback that delivers an extraordinary driving experience, boasting a potent turbocharged engine, a sophisticated all-wheel-drive system, and a chassis designed for ultimate grip and agility. Its motorsport-derived engineering is evident in every aspect of its performance, from its explosive acceleration to its tenacious cornering ability. The GR Yaris is a car that prioritizes driver engagement and raw performance, offering a level of excitement typically found in much more expensive vehicles. It has redefined what’s possible in the hot hatch segment, solidifying its place as a modern legend among rally-inspired cars.
Volkswagen Golf GTI (August 21, 2020): The Volkswagen Golf GTI is an automotive icon, and the generation tested once again proved why it’s considered the benchmark for hot hatch performance. It masterfully blends everyday usability with a truly engaging and fun driving experience. The turbocharged engine offers brisk acceleration, and the chassis provides a superb balance of comfort and sportiness, making it as adept at commuting as it is at spirited drives. The interior is typically VW – well-built, ergonomic, and featuring modern technology. The GTI’s enduring appeal lies in its ability to consistently deliver on its promise of a fun, practical, and sophisticated compact car, making it a perennial favorite for hot hatch driving dynamics.
The Defining Characteristics of Excellence
What unites these 21 exceptional vehicles? Beyond their diverse segments and price points, they share a common thread: an unwavering commitment to engineering excellence, a passion for driving pleasure, and a level of refinement that elevates them beyond the ordinary. These are cars that don’t just get you from A to B; they make the journey an event. They inspire confidence, deliver exhilaration, and provide a sanctuary of comfort and advanced technology.
The pursuit of automotive excellence is a multifaceted endeavor. It involves meticulously balancing power and precision, luxury and functionality, and innovation with timeless design. For manufacturers, achieving a five-star rating from a publication with Autocar’s pedigree is the ultimate validation of their engineering and design philosophies. For consumers, it represents a shortcut to the absolute best, a curated list of vehicles that have demonstrably met the highest standards of automotive merit. Whether you’re searching for the thrill of a sports car investment, the practicality of a performance estate, or the cutting-edge technology of a luxury electric vehicle, this collection offers invaluable insights into what truly defines automotive greatness.
The industry trend towards electrification, advanced driver-assistance systems, and sustainable manufacturing continues to shape the automotive landscape. Even within this highly exclusive group, we see a growing presence of hybrid and electric powertrains, signaling a shift in how performance and luxury are defined. These vehicles are not just about raw power; they are about intelligent integration of technology, sustainable performance, and an enhanced driving experience that is both thrilling and responsible. This evolution ensures that the benchmark for new car reviews remains dynamic and forward-looking, reflecting the accelerating pace of innovation.
Navigating the Path to Ownership
For those who aspire to own a piece of automotive history or simply desire the pinnacle of driving technology and experience, this list serves as an unparalleled guide. It highlights vehicles that have not only impressed our seasoned road testers but have also resonated with a broader sense of automotive achievement. The considerations for purchasing such vehicles extend beyond mere specifications; they encompass brand heritage, long-term value, and the sheer joy of ownership.
If the pursuit of automotive excellence has captured your imagination, or if you’re considering a significant investment in a new vehicle, we encourage you to explore these lauded models further. Understanding the nuances of each, from their unique driving characteristics to their technological advancements, is the crucial next step. Engage with your local dealerships, schedule test drives of models that pique your interest, and immerse yourself in the driving experience. For discerning buyers seeking the absolute best, the journey to finding your perfect five-star vehicle begins here.
